Maguire & Tansey v Makaronis
Maguire & Tansey v Makaronis [1997] HCA 23; (1997) 188 CLR 449
Two solicitors lend their clients money and take a mortgage over the clients’ main asset. The clients later prove the solicitors breached their duty to them. Can the mortgage simply be wiped out, and on what terms?
What happened?
In 1990 Mr and Mrs Makaronis borrowed $250,000 to buy a poultry farm. The loan carried interest at 24 per cent, reducible to 22 per cent for prompt payment, and was secured by a mortgage over the Radford property, their major asset. The mortgagees were Mr Maguire and Mr Tansey, partners in the firms of solicitors that had acted for the Makaronis. The joint reasons refer to the solicitors’ undisclosed role as mortgagee.
The farm failed and the clients became insolvent. The trial judge, Ashley J, found that the solicitors had breached their fiduciary duties to their clients. The majority of the Appeal Division of the Supreme Court of Victoria, Nathan and Smith JJ, would not impose terms on any relief. Brooking J, dissenting, would have imposed terms. The solicitors appealed to the High Court about the form of that relief.
What did the Court decide?
The appeal was allowed with costs. The Court of Appeal’s orders were set aside, and the matter was remitted to that Court to make orders in the terms the High Court set out, or to the effect of them. Five Justices agreed in the orders: the four joint judges, and Kirby J, who wrote separately.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Where solicitors who took a mortgage from their clients are in breach of fiduciary duty, the clients may have the mortgage set aside, but the setting aside must be conditioned on repayment of the advance. The joint reasons of Brennan CJ, Gaudron, McHugh and Gummow JJ say that setting the mortgage aside purely as a security, without that condition, would reform the transaction in an impermissible fashion. The clients’ equity is to have the whole transaction rescinded and, so far as possible, the parties remitted to their original position. The interest condition ran at the commercial rates the Supreme Court of Victoria allows, not at the 9 per cent rate Brooking J had used. Kirby J agreed in the orders, though he gave separate reasons.
Why does this case matter?
Many students treat rescission as a single switch: the contract or the mortgage is undone or it is not. This case separates the equity to rescind from the terms on which the court grants it. An examiner rewards the student who asks what the clients must do in return before the court sets the mortgage aside, and who checks which Justices agreed on those terms.
Exam and application relevance
In a rescission problem involving a fiduciary, check whether the relief the court would grant is conditional, and attribute any condition to the Justices who express it. Kirby J agreed in the orders on the approach the other Justices favoured, although he said he was initially attracted to the practical solution offered in the Appeal Division. Scope: the remedy discussion arises from breach of fiduciary duty, and the joint reasons say that rescission there was not sought on the ground of misrepresentation.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justices gave the joint reasons, and what did Kirby J say about the approach he took to the orders?
2. What did the joint reasons say would follow if the mortgage were set aside purely as a security, without a further condition?
3. What rate of interest did the joint reasons reject, and whose analogy was it?