Johnson v Perez

High Court of Australia · 1988

ContractDischarge And Remedies

Johnson v Perez [1988] HCA 64; (1988) 166 CLR 351

A client’s two injury claims were lost through his solicitors’ negligence, and he sued them. At what date should the court value what he lost: when the solicitors’ trial happens, or at some other time?

What happened?

The plaintiff, Perez, was injured in two accidents at work, in 1968 and 1973, and sued his employers. Both actions were dismissed for want of prosecution, the one for the 1968 accident in 1983 and the one for the 1973 accident in 1980. Because limitation periods had run, he could not bring fresh actions against his employers. He then sued his solicitors for negligence and for breach of contract.

The negligence action against the solicitors went to trial before Demack J, who assessed damages as at the date of that trial. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland upheld that approach. In the High Court the solicitors did not contest liability, so the appeals concerned only the date of assessment (Brennan J, opening reasons).

What did the Court decide?

The appeals were allowed with costs. The High Court set aside the judgment at trial on the damages question, left the finding of liability in place, and ordered new trials limited to damages (orders at the end of the reports). The Court did not decide the amount of damages.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Where a solicitor’s negligence causes a client to lose a personal injury action by its dismissal for want of prosecution, damages for the lost claim are not assessed as at the date of the trial of the negligence action. Mason CJ took the dates on which the lost actions would have been converted into money, that is when they would otherwise have been determined. Wilson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ, in joint reasons, and Dawson J took the date on which the actions were dismissed for want of prosecution. Changes in the law after the notional trial date are not taken into account. Brennan J and Deane J would have dismissed the appeals and kept the assessment made at the trial of the negligence action. Five Justices allowed the appeals.

Why does this case matter?

The choice of valuation date can change the sum awarded substantially, because the value of personal injury awards moved over the years between the accident, the lost trial and the trial of the negligence action. A student who does not see that the date is a live question can end up over-compensating or under-compensating the client. Examiners look for a student who identifies the date question, explains why it matters to the amount, and does not assume the answer.

Exam and application relevance

In a question about a lost claim, identify the event that removed the claim, then state what the court is valuing and why that date fits the claim. Do not assume the general rule that damages are assessed at breach applies without asking whether it fits a lost claim. Check whether a later change in the law, or later events, bear on the value of the lost claim, and say which Justices’ reasons you rely on for each step.

Check your understanding

1. At what point did the two lost actions end, and why could the plaintiff not simply bring them again?

2. What date did the trial judge use to assess the damages, and what did the Full Court do with that approach?

3. Mason CJ described the rule that damages are assessed as at breach. Does he treat that rule as universal, and in what kind of case does it give way?