Jemena Asset Management (3) Pty Ltd v Coinvest Ltd

High Court of Australia · 2011

Constitutional LawFederalism

Jemena Asset Management (3) Pty Ltd v Coinvest Ltd [2011] HCA 33

Federal awards already gave construction employees long service leave. A Victorian Act made their employers pay into a fund for portable long service leave as well. Were both laws able to stand?

What happened?

Three companies that operate electricity infrastructure assets in Victoria employed people to perform construction work and were bound by federal industrial instruments under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth): an award and a succession of certified agreements that dealt with long service leave ([1], [5]-[6]). The Construction Industry Long Service Leave Act 1997 (Vic) required employers to pay a long service leave charge to the trustee of a fund, which paid portable long service leave benefits to workers in the construction industry ([7]-[8]).

The trustee asked the companies for details of their workers and for payments and gave notices under the State Act, and the companies brought proceedings in the Federal Court in October 2007, contending that the State Act was inconsistent with the federal instruments and invalid under s 109 ([9]-[10]). The primary judge answered the separate questions concerning the existence of inconsistency no, the Full Court of the Federal Court dismissed an appeal, and the companies appealed to the High Court, where the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth intervened in support of the respondent ([3], [31], [34]).

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was dismissed with costs ([62]).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

In the joint reasons of French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ, s 109 requires a comparison between two laws which create rights, privileges or powers, and duties or obligations, and an award or other instrument made under a statute can be a law of the Commonwealth or of a State for that purpose ([37]-[38]). The expression cover the field means cover the subject matter, and indirect inconsistency involves a more subtle contrariety than a direct collision ([40]).

The notions of altering, impairing or detracting from the operation of a Commonwealth law have in common the idea that a State law undermines the Commonwealth law, so that any alteration, impairment or detraction must be significant and not trivial ([41]). All tests of inconsistency applied for s 109 are tests for discerning whether a real conflict exists, and more than one test may be applied in a case ([42]). Where powers are concurrent, inconsistency concerns the operation of both laws and not the limits of constitutional power, and its extent depends on the text and operation of the respective laws ([44]-[45]).

In the same joint reasons, the Victorian Construction Industry Long Service Leave Act 1997, which required employers to pay a charge into a fund that paid portable long service leave benefits to construction workers, was held not to be inconsistent with federal industrial instruments that dealt with the grant of, and payment for, long service leave in the employment relationship. The State Act’s operation was limited to the provision of a benefit payable from the fund, and it did not undermine the employers’ obligations under the federal instruments or the employees’ correlative entitlements ([51]-[53]).

The field said to be covered by the federal instruments had to be identified: they did not deal with, or even mention, portable long service leave benefits for workers in continuous service in the construction industry ([54]-[59]). On direct and on indirect inconsistency the result turned on the same consideration, that there was no real conflict between the State law and the federal instruments ([60]-[61]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Proposition 1

Ratio · French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ

Read judgment: [41]–[42] (PDF p 19) (opens in a new tab), [45] (PDF p 21) (opens in a new tab), [60]–[61] (PDF p 26) (opens in a new tab)

The real-conflict test is the operative reasoning for resolving the two inconsistency arguments in this appeal. The joint reasons require an undermining of the Commonwealth law, assess the text and operation of the respective laws, and apply that approach at [60] to reject both direct and indirect inconsistency. This classifies the test used to reach that result; it does not make every general observation about s 109 a separate holding.

Proposition 2

Ratio · French CJ, Gummow, Heydon, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ

Read judgment: [51]–[53] (PDF p 23) (opens in a new tab), [56] (PDF p 24) (opens in a new tab), [59] (PDF p 25) (opens in a new tab), [60]–[61] (PDF p 26) (opens in a new tab)

These passages provide the grounds needed to reject both challenges. The State scheme supplies a payment from a fund and accommodates the employer’s federal leave obligations through reimbursement and reduced fund entitlements. The federal instruments do not cover portable industry benefits. Those constructions establish the complementary operation and absence of real conflict on which the conclusion that s 109 did not invalidate the State Act depends.

Why does this case matter?

Students who learn s 109 from the cases in which the State law lost often assume that a State law on a related topic cannot survive beside a federal industrial instrument. Jemena is the counterweight, and the case to cite when the answer turns out to be that two laws sit together. It is also a High Court restatement of the tests, so an answer can rely on it for the framework and not only for its result.

Exam and application relevance

Attribute the framework and the result to the joint reasons of the six Justices. The federal laws in issue were awards and certified agreements made under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), and the reasons record that no issue arose in the appeal in respect of the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth), which repealed that Act ([16]). Check the legislation now in force before stating the result as a rule about modern industrial instruments, and read any other State scheme for itself.

Check your understanding

1. What did the joint reasons say s 109 requires a court to compare, and what kinds of instrument can be a law for that purpose?

2. What did the joint reasons say about the size of an alteration, impairment or detraction, and what do all the tests of inconsistency discern?

3. Why did the Court say the federal instruments did not cover the field said to be in issue?