Goldsbrough, Mort & Co Ltd v Quinn

High Court of Australia · 1910

ContractContract Formation

Goldsbrough, Mort & Co Ltd v Quinn [1910] HCA 20; (1910) 10 CLR 674

A buyer pays a small sum for a week’s right to buy a large block of land at a fixed price. Before the week ends the seller says he is out. Can the buyer still make him sell?

What happened?

On 8 February 1909 John Quinn signed a document in the office of the appellants’ solicitor. It recited the sum of five shillings “paid to me” and granted the company the right to purchase his land near Canonbar, about 2,590 acres, “within one week from this date” at £1 10s an acre, “calculated on a freehold basis”. The land was partly freehold and partly held under conditional purchase and conditional lease.

Quinn said that before the week ran out, and before the company accepted, he repudiated the offer, because he had misunderstood the price. The company accepted within the week, without other notice of the repudiation. Quinn argued that the document was only an agreement to make another agreement, so that the company’s remedy was damages. The primary judge dismissed the suit for specific performance because he was not satisfied that Quinn’s consent was sufficiently full and deliberate.

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed. The judgment appealed from was set aside and the company was entitled to specific performance of the agreement, with the costs of the trial and of the appeal to be set off against the purchase money. Isaacs J said it was unnecessary to decide anything about damages.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

An option given for valuable consideration is irrevocable for the period it states. An offeror who withdraws before acceptance cannot defeat a contract formed by acceptance within that period, and the offeree may obtain specific performance of that contract, subject to the ordinary grounds on which specific performance is refused.

Griffith CJ held that the real transaction was a contract for valuable consideration to sell on condition of timely acceptance. O’Connor J held that equity disregards the withdrawal and treats the offer as if it had been accepted while still open. Isaacs J held that the whole question turned on the irrevocability of the option. Each of the three Justices allowed the appeal, for separate reasons.

Why does this case matter?

Many answers to a question about a withdrawn offer begin with the rule that an offer may be withdrawn before it is accepted. A student who stops there misses the question the case asks: what the offeror was paid to keep the offer open, and whether the offeree accepted within the period the offeror had agreed to hold it open.

Exam and application relevance

In a contract question, first find whether the offeror received anything for holding the offer open, and for how long. If the offeror attempted to withdraw within that period, ask what the offeree was entitled to do before the period ended, and whether the offeree did it. Then ask whether the document is a contract to sell on condition, or a bare promise not to withdraw, because Griffith CJ’s reasoning treats the two as different questions, and the second raises a separate question about damages. Keep those two characterisations apart in the answer.

Check your understanding

1. Why did Griffith CJ say the real transaction was not an offer accompanied by a promise?

2. What did Isaacs J say the whole question turned on, and which Justices allowed the appeal?