Booker Industries Pty Ltd v Wilson Parking (Qld) Pty Ltd
Booker Industries Pty Ltd v Wilson Parking (Qld) Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 600
A tenant exercised an option to renew a lease at a rent “mutually agreed” or, failing agreement, fixed by an arbitrator. The landlord said there was no deal until the rent was set. Was it right?
What happened?
Booker Industries Pty Ltd owned buildings in Brisbane that it let to Wilson Parking (Qld) Pty Ltd for use as a car park and service station, for a term of three years from 1 August 1977 (Brennan J). Clause 4.01 of the lease gave the tenant, on conditions that were not in dispute, “the right to be granted a further lease of the demised premises for the term of THREE (3) YEARS” on the same terms, except that the rental would be “such rental as may be mutually agreed between the Lessor and the Lessee and failing agreement then such rental as may be fixed by an arbitrator”, and in any event not less than the rental in the last year of the first term. The arbitrator was to be nominated by the President of the Queensland Law Society.
Wilson gave notice exercising the option. Booker refused to recognise it and required Wilson to leave when the first term ended on 31 July 1980. Wilson stayed in possession and sued for specific performance, and Booker sued to recover possession. No rental for the new term had been agreed or fixed.
Andrews J found that the option had been validly exercised and made declarations in Wilson’s favour. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland, as the joint reasons record, held that no order for specific performance could be made until the rent had been fixed, set aside the declarations, and dismissed Booker’s appeal on possession. In the High Court, counsel for Booker abandoned the argument that the option had not been validly exercised, and the issue left was whether the renewal agreement in the lease was a concluded agreement.
What did the Court decide?
The High Court allowed Wilson’s appeal and dismissed Booker’s. It set aside the Full Court’s orders, affirmed the order of Andrews J with a further order that, upon the rental being fixed, Booker specifically perform clause 4.01 and grant a further lease of three years, and awarded Wilson its costs. Gibbs CJ, Murphy and Wilson JJ gave joint reasons, and Brennan J gave separate reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
The joint reasons accepted that if the lease “provided for a renewal ‘at a rental to be agreed’ there would clearly be no enforceable agreement”, but said that parties “may leave terms - even essential terms - to be determined by a third person”. Because “the lease itself provides the entire mechanism for determining the rental for the renewed term” and “[t]here is no further agreement required of the parties”, their Honours held that there was “a valid agreement for the renewal of the lease subject to the fixation of a rental for the new term”, the fixation of the rental being “a condition precedent to the performance of the agreement”.
They assumed that if the President or the person nominated declined to act, “the renewal cannot be effected”. They implied a term that, once the conditions in clause 4.01 had been performed, “both parties will do all that is reasonably necessary to procure the nomination by the President of an arbitrator”, and held that the contract immediately bound the lessor to that obligation, so that a limited decree of specific performance could be made.
Brennan J reached the conclusion by a different route. He would have construed clause 4.01 “as providing for a fair and just rental to be ascertained by the appointed arbitrator or, in default, by the court”, so that “[i]f the contractual machinery for fixing the rental were to fail, the rental would be fixed by the court”, and he held that the obligation to grant the lease was not “conditioned or contingent upon the occurrence of a future event (the fixing of the rental)”.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Gibbs CJ, Murphy and Wilson JJ
Read judgment: pp 605–606 (opens in a new tab)
The agreed machinery required no further agreement between the parties, so the renewal agreement was binding although the grant of the renewed lease depended on fixing the rent. The implied obligation to do what was reasonably necessary to procure an arbitrator supported a limited decree compelling cooperation and requiring renewal once the rent was fixed. These steps were necessary to reject Booker’s claim to possession and grant Wilson relief.
Classification unresolved · Gibbs CJ, Murphy and Wilson JJ
Read judgment: p 605 (opens in a new tab)
The joint reasons assumed that renewal could not be effected if the President or the nominated arbitrator declined to act. No such refusal had occurred. This was an assumption delimiting their reasoning, rather than a determination that every failure of the agreed machinery defeats renewal; it should not be treated as a settled holding on that contingency.
Separate reasoning · Brennan J
Read judgment: pp 617–618 (opens in a new tab)
Brennan J concurred in allowing Wilson’s appeal and dismissing Booker’s appeal, but took a distinct route and differed on the appropriate relief. He construed the clause as requiring a fair and just rental ascertainable by the arbitrator or, in default, the court. On that construction the obligation to grant the lease was immediately enforceable and did not depend on prior fixation of rent. This was his own basis for relief, rather than the joint reasons’ conditional-performance analysis.
Why does this case matter?
Whether a clause of this kind makes a binding agreement and what a court can order if the agreed machinery breaks down are separate questions, and the case is useful for keeping them apart.
A tenant’s option is a common setting for the problem, and a question about a renewal at a rent “to be determined” invites an answer that stops at “uncertain”. That is the shortcut the case is used to test.
Exam and application relevance
Ask what is to settle the open term and whether the contract itself supplies everything needed. If a mechanism is named, deal with the failure of the mechanism as a separate step and say whose reasons you are relying on.
The case was decided in 1982 and concerns a lease with an option to renew; check for later authority before relying on it for a current problem.
Check your understanding
1. What did clause 4.01 provide about the rental for the renewed term, and who was to nominate the arbitrator?
2. Why did the joint reasons say that the agreement was not an agreement to agree?
3. What term did the joint reasons imply, and what kind of order did it support?
4. How did Brennan J’s reasoning about a failure of the agreed machinery differ from the joint reasons?