Coulls v Bagot’s Executor & Trustee Co Ltd
Coulls v Bagot’s Executor & Trustee Co Ltd (1967) 119 CLR 460
A royalty document authorised a company to pay money to a husband and to his wife. After the husband died, the wife claimed the royalties, though the document was signed by the husband. Did she have a right to them?
What happened?
Arthur Coulls gave O’Neil Construction the right to quarry stone from his land, and the company agreed to pay a royalty. The written document, which the judgments set out, said: “I authorise the above Company to pay all money connected with this agreement to my wife, Doris Sophia Coulls and myself, Arthur Leopold Coulls as joint tenants (or tenants-in-common?) (the one which goes to living partner)” (Barwick CJ, reporting the document at p467). The document was signed by Coulls, by the company, and by his wife. Coulls died about eighteen months after it was made, and the company went on paying the royalties to his widow. His executor disputed her right to them. Her case was that the promise was made to her and her husband jointly, so that she could enforce it. The executor argued that she could not enforce it because she gave no consideration for the promise.
What did the Court decide?
Before you read the Proposition, decide the question on which the Justices divided. Read the document as the Justices did: was the promise made to the husband and wife together, or to the husband alone? If the wife was not a party, could she collect the royalties at all? Which Justices answered each question, and what did they point to in the document?
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
A person who is not a party to a contract may not sue on it so as directly to enforce its obligations, and whether a person is a party is a question of construction. The Justices divided on whether this document made a joint promise to the husband and wife, and therefore whether the wife was a promisee. Those who held that she was a promisee, and those who held she was not, are set out in the reasons, and the answer for an examiner is the reasoning of each.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Proposition 1
Separate reasoning · Barwick CJ (dissenting on the royalties appeal; his view that Mrs Coulls could enforce the promise did not prevail)
Read judgment: p 478 (opens in a new tab)
Barwick CJ states the general rule at 478 as the starting point for deciding whether the wife could enforce the promise. He reached the view that she could, by treating her as a promisee rather than by displacing the rule. That is a distinct route to the view he took, and it did not prevail on the royalties appeal, so it is classified as separate reasoning and not as the Court’s ratio.
Proposition 2
Separate reasoning · Barwick CJ and Windeyer J (joint promisee; both dissenting on the first appeal)
Read judgment: p 478 (opens in a new tab), p 493 (opens in a new tab)
Barwick CJ at 478 and Windeyer J at 493 read the document as making the promise to both spouses jointly, so that the wife was a joint promisee and a party. That reading did not prevail on the first appeal, and it is a distinct route to a different answer from the majority’s, so it is classified as separate reasoning rather than as the Court’s ratio.
Ratio · McTiernan J; Taylor and Owen JJ (the majority on the first appeal)
Read judgment: p 483 (opens in a new tab)
McTiernan J at 483 held that the words of the document, read as a whole, countervail the inference that the wife was a party, and Taylor and Owen JJ held that the testator was the only person entitled to demand the royalties. That construction of this document determined the first appeal, so it is the ratio of that appeal. It is a reading of this document rather than a general principle, and the record does not extend it beyond the document.
Why does this case matter?
Students who learn one sentence about third parties will be unprepared when a question turns on a particular document. The Justices here did not agree on what the document said, and that disagreement is the part of the case an examiner is likely to test. A student who names only the outcome, without the Justices’ readings of the document, has not answered the question.
Exam and application relevance
Where a question turns on who the parties to a promise are, say what the document says about that, and which Justices read it which way. Then say what follows for the person suing. Identify which reading of the document the majority adopted and which Justices took the minority view, rather than giving one answer for the Court.
Check your understanding
1. Why does the consideration objection not answer the privity question on its own?
2. Which Justices in Coulls thought that Mrs Coulls was a promisee, and which thought she was not?