Clark v Macourt

High Court of Australia · 2013

ContractDischarge And Remedies

Clark v Macourt [2013] HCA 56

A buyer received stock that did not meet its warranty, then recovered its cost from her own customers. Has she lost anything at all?

What happened?

Dr Clark bought the assets of a fertility clinic from a company controlled by Dr Macourt, who guaranteed the company’s obligations. The company warranted that the donors of a stock of frozen sperm had been identified in accordance with specified guidelines. Of the stock of sperm delivered, 1,996 straws that Dr Clark would have expected to be able to use were not as warranted and could not be used.

Replacement sperm was not available in Australia, but could be bought from a United States supplier at a cost of about $1 million at the date of breach. The price paid for the assets, including the stock, was under $400,000. Dr Clark bought replacement straws and used them in treating her patients. The Court of Appeal found that she had charged each patient a fee covering the cost of the straws used for that patient (Hayne J at [5]).

The primary judge assessed damages at the cost of the replacement straws (Hayne J at [5]). The Court of Appeal held that Dr Clark had avoided her loss, because her fees to patients recouped the cost of the straws she had bought (Hayne J at [5]). She appealed by special leave.

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed with costs. The orders of the Court of Appeal were set aside and its appeal dismissed, so the primary judge’s assessment of damages was reinstated. Hayne J, Crennan and Bell JJ, and Keane J formed the majority. Gageler J would have dismissed the appeal.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Keane J, with whose reasons Hayne J and Crennan and Bell JJ agreed, rejected the argument that the purchaser’s loss was mitigated by her recovery from patients. The loss was fixed at completion of the purchase, when the assets were less valuable than the warranty promised, and the purchaser’s decisions about how to use the assets did not measure it. Hayne J separated the two propositions that the word mitigation runs together, and held that the purchaser’s later purchases replaced what the vendor had promised to supply, so that she was left neither better nor worse off by them. Gageler J dissented, and would have measured the loss as the cost of replacement sperm not recouped from patients.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Keane J, with Hayne J and Crennan and Bell JJ agreeing

Read judgment: [125]–[129] (PDF p 40) (opens in a new tab)

These paragraphs reject the argument that the purchaser’s loss was fully mitigated by recovery from her patients. The argument fails because the loss was fixed at completion, when the assets were less valuable than the warranty promised, and the purchaser’s commercial choices on how to exploit them do not measure it. This is the step by which the appeal is allowed on the measure of damages.

Separate reasoning · Hayne J (concurring in the result and agreeing generally with Keane J)

Read judgment: [17]–[22] (PDF p 11) (opens in a new tab)

Hayne J separates the two propositions that the word mitigation runs together, and holds that the second, loss actually avoided, does not apply where the later purchases only replaced what the vendor had agreed to supply. His route differs from Keane J’s, so it is recorded separately and not as the ground of the joint result.

Separate reasoning · Gageler J (dissenting)

Read judgment: [72]–[74] (PDF p 25) (opens in a new tab)

Gageler J would measure the purchaser’s loss as the cost of sourcing replacement sperm that she could not recoup from patients, which is the measure adopted by the Court of Appeal. He would dismiss the appeal.

Why does this case matter?

Students often treat the net outlay as the loss, because it is the figure that the purchaser’s own accounts show. Ask what the examiner is testing when the claimant has later dealt with the goods, and what the claim measures.

Exam and application relevance

Where a question describes a buyer who dealt with the goods after the breach, identify the promised performance first, then ask what the buyer lost by not receiving it.

Ask whether the question calls for a mitigation analysis at all, and if it does, which limb of the analysis it engages. Check which Justice’s reasons you are citing for each step.

Check your understanding

1. Which Justices formed the majority, and what did Gageler J hold?

2. On the Court’s reasons, does a purchaser’s recovery from her own customers reduce the damages for a vendor’s breach of warranty? Answer from the proposition, and say whose reasons support it.