Negligence: duty of care and pure economic loss
How the High Court approaches the duty of care where the loss is purely financial: the general rule, assumption of responsibility, knowledge, vulnerability and indeterminacy, as applied in Perre, Woolcock, Brookfield and Mallonland.
Learning outcomes
- Identify whether a loss is pure economic loss and state the general rule on duty of care for it.
- Explain the matters the High Court examines for a duty to avoid pure economic loss: assumption of responsibility, knowledge, vulnerability and indeterminacy.
- Compare Perre, Woolcock, Brookfield and Mallonland on vulnerability and assumption of responsibility, attributing each point to the right judgment.
- State accurately how settled the salient features approach is after Mallonland.
When a defendant’s carelessness causes the plaintiff a financial loss but no physical injury to the plaintiff’s person or property, the first question is whether the defendant owed a duty of care at all. The High Court’s answer does not stop at foreseeability: it looks to the relationship between the parties. This article states what the High Court has said at common law, and the New South Wales statutory duty for building defects. It does not examine whether any civil liability statute changes the position on duty, so check each jurisdiction’s statutes separately (see the statutory modification article in this subject).
The general rule and why it exists
Pure economic loss is loss that is not consequential upon injury to person or property.1 In Woolcock Street Investments Pty Ltd v CDG Pty Ltd (2004) 216 CLR 5152, a purchaser’s loss from buying a building with defective foundations was treated by the joint reasons as pure economic loss, and they saw no reason to reopen the argument that physical damage to the building took the claim outside that category.
In Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 25 the joint reasons stated the starting point: ordinarily a person does not owe a duty to take reasonable care to avoid causing reasonably foreseeable pure economic loss to another. The joint reasons recorded that the rule reflects the position that the infliction of economic loss does not by itself infringe a legally protected interest of the plaintiff, and that it is also said to reflect policy concerns about liability “in an indeterminate amount for an indeterminate time to an indeterminate class”.
Reasonable foreseeability of the loss is necessary but not sufficient for a duty to avoid pure economic loss.
Matters the High Court examines
The joint reasons in Mallonland discuss the following matters. This grouping is the article’s, not a statutory test, and the Court did not present it as a closed list.
- Assumption of responsibility. Where a defendant has assumed a responsibility to take reasonable care to avoid economic loss to the plaintiff, a duty may well be established. The joint reasons described it as an undertaking, express or implied, to take on a task or job for another person or class of persons, from which it can be inferred that care would be taken. A defendant can negate or limit the assumption by words or conduct directed to that person or class.
- Knowledge. Actual knowledge of the risk to a person or class of the particular economic loss that eventuated, and of its magnitude, strengthens a case for a duty.
- Vulnerability. This means the plaintiff’s inability to protect itself from the economic loss, either entirely or in a way that would cast the loss on the defendant, for example by contractual stipulation. A mere likelihood of suffering loss if care is not taken will not amount to vulnerability. The capacity to protect oneself by contract, or by analogy by any other reasonable means, is a reason, and often a decisive one, for rejecting a duty.
- Indeterminacy. Where liability cannot realistically be calculated, that will ordinarily deny a duty. The converse does not follow: that the plaintiffs are an ascertainable class excludes the spectre of indeterminate liability but does not itself improve the case for a duty.
The joint reasons also said that weighing such matters is not an “instinctive synthesis”: it needs a chain of reasoning, and an incremental and analogical approach.
Vulnerability in the cases
In Perre v Apand Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 1804 the respondent had negligently introduced bacterial wilt onto one farmer’s land. Western Australian regulations barred imports of potatoes grown within a set distance of affected land, so the appellants’ potato-growing land was treated as if affected, though none of it was physically harmed. The appeal was allowed. Gleeson CJ, agreeing with Gummow J that a duty was owed, pointed to land use, proximity to the infected land, the known vulnerability of people in the appellants’ position, and the respondent’s control of the activity on that land. The Justices wrote separately, and Hayne J would have allowed the appeal of only one appellant, Warruga Farms. The joint reasons in Woolcock later described Perre as a case in which the plaintiffs could do nothing to protect themselves. That is a later court’s account and not a holding of Perre.
Woolcock went the other way. A consulting engineer had designed foundations for a commercial complex, and a later purchaser sued for the structural distress. The question was decided on a case stated, on the facts alleged and agreed. The joint reasons found no relevant vulnerability on those facts: nothing showed the purchaser could not have sought contractual terms casting the burden on the engineer, and it was not alleged that the defects could not have been discovered. The appeal was dismissed. The joint reasons noted that in Bryan v Maloney (1995) 182 CLR 609 a majority had held that a builder of a dwelling owed a duty to a later purchaser, and doubted that the decision depended on a bright line between dwellings and other buildings. They left open how general the importance of vulnerability is.
In Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 (2014) 254 CLR 1853 the owners corporation of a strata complex claimed from the builder the cost of latent defects in the common property. The High Court held that no duty was owed. French CJ, Hayne and Kiefel JJ, and Crennan, Bell and Keane JJ each, in different words, treated the contractual arrangements surrounding the building and the purchases as bearing on the owners corporation’s vulnerability (French CJ also relied on the interaction with the strata statutes). French CJ treated the case as analogous to Woolcock and not to Bryan v Maloney.
A producer and its customers’ customers
The growers in Mallonland bought seed that was contaminated with shattercane, from a distributor authorised by the producer, and claimed their purely economic losses. The loss was accepted as reasonably foreseeable. The bags carried prominent conditions placing the risk of fitness for use on the buyer, and stating that the producer would not be liable for loss caused by its negligence. The High Court unanimously dismissed the appeal; the producer owed no duty.
The joint reasons gave the following reasons.
- The packaging “communicated to the class of potential future purchasers that the producer was positively not assuming the responsibility which is at the core of the alleged duty of care”. The point was not merely that it disclaimed legal liability: the packaging delimited the nature of the product made available.
- The producer knew that a class of purchasers would suffer loss if the seed was contaminated, but did not know the seed was contaminated, and did not know that these growers would buy it.
- The growers were able to protect themselves by choosing not to plant. They bore the onus of proving that they could not return unopened bags for a refund, and did not do so.
- Their being an ascertainable class excluded indeterminacy but did not strengthen the case.
A New South Wales statutory duty for building defects
The common law result in Brookfield is not the whole position for building defects in New South Wales. Section 37(1) of the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW)6 provides that a person who carries out construction work has a duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects in or related to a building for which the work is done and arising from the construction work. The duty is owed to each owner of the land and each subsequent owner (s 37(2)), and for a strata scheme the owners corporation counts as an owner (s 36(3)). An owners corporation is taken to suffer economic loss if it bears the cost of rectifying defects that are the subject of a breach (s 38(1)). The duty cannot be delegated (s 39), contracts made or amended after the commencement of Part 4 cannot exclude it (s 40), and Part 4 is subject to the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) (s 41(3)).
Section 202(c) of the Building (Approvals and Practitioners) Act 2026 (NSW)7 repeals the 2020 Act once it commences, and Part 8 of the 2026 Act (ss 177-184) provides a duty of care in similar terms, with its own definitions (s 179(1)-(2)). Those provisions commence on a day appointed by proclamation (s 2(b)). As at 3 October 2026 s 202(c) had not commenced, so the 2020 Act remained in force; whether it has since commenced must be checked.
In Pafburn Pty Limited v The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 495 the joint reasons of Gageler CJ, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ described the 2020 Act’s enactment as occurring amid a crisis of confidence among people considering buying a unit in a residential apartment building, in a context that included the decision in Brookfield. The question decided there concerned proportionate liability under Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), which this article does not cover. Other jurisdictions’ legislation is not covered here.
How settled is the approach?
The joint reasons in Mallonland recorded that the salient features approach has attracted significant academic and judicial criticism, but noted that neither party argued for departure from it. Edelman J, in separate reasons, agreed that the appeal should be dismissed, applied the approach because it was not challenged, and said that until Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge “Willemstad” (1976) 136 CLR 529 and its progeny are challenged or rationalised, a duty of care based on salient features must be “confined as narrowly as possible”. Mallonland (7 August 2024) is the most recent common law duty decision cited here; Pafburn (11 December 2024) concerns the New South Wales statutory duty. Mallonland did not overrule the approach, so an answer should use it while noting that it is under criticism.
Applying this in a problem question
- Classify the loss. Mallonland states the general rule for loss that is not consequential upon injury to person or property, so it does not apply on its terms to loss that is.
- If it is pure economic loss, begin from the general rule. Say that foreseeability is necessary but not sufficient.
- Look for an assumption of responsibility, to this plaintiff or to a class. Check whether words or conduct directed to that class negated or limited it, as in Mallonland.
- Ask what the plaintiff could have done to protect itself, by contract or other reasonable means, and what the facts show about whether it could. In Woolcock and Mallonland what the facts showed, or did not show, about the plaintiff’s ability to protect itself was part of the result.
- Consider indeterminacy, and what the defendant knew about this plaintiff or class and about the loss.
- Compare the facts with the decided cases, noting the differences, and give a chain of reasoning rather than a list. Note that the approach is criticised. For a building-defect claim in New South Wales, address the statutory duty (s 37 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW), or its replacement if commenced) as well as the common law; check any other statute or jurisdiction separately.
Self-check
- Have I confirmed the loss is pure economic loss?
- Have I avoided treating foreseeability as sufficient, and treated vulnerability as one matter that can weigh decisively against a duty, not as a test?
- Have I attributed Perre to the Justice whose reasons I am using?
- Have I said that the civil liability statutes were not considered, and that only the New South Wales building duty is stated here?
Where the authority sits
The common law authorities are High Court judgments. They bind courts in every Australian jurisdiction, but they do not settle what any state or territory statute adds. The only statutes stated here are the New South Wales building-duty provisions; any other, including each jurisdiction’s civil liability legislation, must be checked in its own current compilation.