Approaching a torts problem question

How to work a negligence problem as a sequence of elements, find which civil liability Act governs your jurisdiction, and keep factual causation and scope of liability apart.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
au-national, nsw, qld, vic
Subjects
torts
Topics
negligence

Learning outcomes

  • Identify which civil liability statute governs the jurisdiction being examined.
  • Work the elements of negligence in order and stop where one is not established.
  • Separate factual causation from scope of liability and answer each on its own terms.
  • Reach a conclusion that names what a missing fact would decide.

A negligence problem gives you an injury and asks who, if anyone, must pay for it. The answer is a sequence: each element has to be established, and the claim stops at the first one that is not. This guide is about working that sequence. It is not about the law of negligence, which the articles it points to cover.

Assessment differs between subjects and between teaching periods: how long you have, what you may bring, what the task is worth, and whether it is a problem question at all — some torts subjects set an essay as well. Read your own subject’s assessment instructions, and treat nothing here as a prediction of what you will be asked.

What the question is asking

Start with who is suing whom, and for what harm. “Advise Nadia” asks you to reach a position. “Discuss the liability of the hospital” names one defendant, and is not an invitation to work through every party in the facts.

Then notice what kind of harm is in issue. Personal injury, property damage, pure economic loss and mental harm are not interchangeable: what has to be established differs between them, and so does what the statute says about it.

Which Act governs

Identifying the applicable legislation matters because the provisions differ between jurisdictions. Negligence in Australia combines common law principles with statutory rules: each State and Territory has civil liability legislation that modifies the common law rather than replacing it, and the provisions are not identical. Check what your Act covers and what it leaves out, because the schemes do not reach every claim. Causation sits in s 5D of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), ss 11 and 12 of the Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), and ss 51 and 52 of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) — the same two-stage structure, in different words. Where the NSW provision speaks of an exceptional case, the Victorian one speaks of an appropriate case.

A section number from one jurisdiction cannot be used in another: citing the wrong State’s provision is wrong however sound the reasoning around it. Find out which Act governs the subject you are sitting before you revise, not in the exam. Where material you are studying discusses a different State’s statute, the reasoning may still help you; the section numbers will not.

Working the elements in order

Duty, breach, causation, and harm within the scope of liability — then defences, then any apportionment between wrongdoers. Take them in that order and finish each before starting the next.

The order is doing work, not decoration. If no duty is owed, breach does not arise. If breach is not established, causation does not arise. If you conclude an element is not established, the claim fails there and you should say so. You may go on in the alternative where the element is genuinely contestable, or where your instructions ask you to deal with all of them — but say that is what you are doing, and keep it brief.

It cuts the other way too. Where an element is plainly satisfied on the facts, say so in a sentence and move on. Spend your analysis on the elements the facts put in doubt.

Choosing what to leave out

There are no marks for volume. The body that examines the NSW Diploma in Law states that marks go to an argument that responds to the question, and that the best answers are often the shortest because they resist padding and concentrate on what is relevant.1 Working through elements the facts do not contest is padding with a structure.

Suppose the facts are: a cyclist is struck at an unlit intersection by a driver who was speeding, and the council had not replaced the street light for six months. The question asks whether the council is liable. Duty and breach are arguable against the council, but the contest on these facts is causation: would the collision have happened had the council replaced the light? Note that the driver’s speed being a cause does not displace the council’s failure — more than one negligent act can be a necessary condition of the same harm. The driver’s own liability, though, is not what you were asked about. One line recording that it is not in issue costs almost nothing and keeps the answer on the question.

Factual causation and scope of liability are two questions

The statute separates factual causation from scope of liability. Address each separately.

Factual causation is a question of fact: was the negligence a necessary condition of the harm? Scope of liability is a normative question: should this defendant be liable for this harm? Satisfying the first does not carry you through the second.

Wallace v Kam is the clean illustration. A surgeon failed to warn of two distinct material risks of different physical injuries, and only one of them materialised. Factual causation was established on the assumed facts. Liability still did not extend to that injury, because the patient would have gone ahead with the surgery had he been warned of that risk alone. Answer the two questions separately, and say which one you are answering.

Reaching a conclusion

Say who is liable to whom and for what. Where the facts leave it open, name the fact that would decide it: “the council is unlikely to be liable unless the plaintiff can show the collision would not have happened had the light been replaced” is a conclusion. “This is a difficult question” is not.

Checking your answer

Under time pressure, four questions:

  1. Did I name the Act that governs this jurisdiction, and its provisions rather than another State’s?
  2. Did I take the elements in order, and stop where one was not established?
  3. Did I answer factual causation and scope of liability separately?
  4. Did I advise on the party the question named?

Self-check

  • Take a negligence problem you have already attempted. Which element did you spend the most words on, and did the facts actually put it in doubt?
  • Name a section number you have memorised. Which jurisdiction is it from, and is that the one you will be examined on?
  • Write one sentence that disposes of an element the facts do not contest.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.