Approaching a torts problem question

What the question is asking

First, work out who is suing whom, and what harm is involved. A question like “Advise Nadia” wants you to reach a clear position.

A question like “Discuss the liability of the hospital” names only one defendant. Do not discuss every party in the facts.

Next, identify the type of harm. Personal injury, property damage, pure economic loss and mental harm are different categories.

Each category has different things you must establish. The statute also treats each one differently.

Which Act governs

Know which Act applies before you start. Negligence law mixes common law with statute. Each State and Territory has civil liability legislation. This legislation modifies the common law but does not replace it. The rules differ between jurisdictions, so check what your Act covers and what it leaves out.

Causation appears in different sections across States: s 5D in NSW, ss 11 and 12 in Queensland, ss 51 and 52 in Victoria. These use the same two-stage structure but different wording. For example, NSW asks whether a case is exceptional, while Victoria asks whether it is appropriate.

You cannot use a section number from one State in another. Citing the wrong jurisdiction’s provision is wrong, even with sound reasoning. Work out which Act governs your subject before the exam, not during it. If your study materials discuss a different State’s statute, the reasoning may still apply, but the section numbers will not.

Working the elements in order

Work through the elements in order: duty, breach, causation, and harm within the scope of liability. Then consider defences, then any apportionment between wrongdoers. Finish each element before moving to the next.

This order matters. If there is no duty, breach does not arise. If breach fails, causation does not arise.

If an element is not established, say the claim fails there. You can discuss later elements as well, but only if they are genuinely arguable, or your instructions require it. Make clear you are doing this, and be brief.

The same applies in reverse. If an element is clearly satisfied, say so briefly and move on. Focus your analysis on the elements the facts actually put in doubt.

Choosing what to leave out

Markers do not reward length. The body that examines the NSW Diploma in Law says marks go to arguments that answer the question.[^cite:lpab-open-book-advice] The shortest answers often score best, because they avoid padding and stay relevant.

Working through every element, even ones the facts do not dispute, is still padding. It just has a structure, so it can look useful when it is not.

Example: a cyclist is hit at an unlit intersection by a speeding driver. The council had not replaced the street light for six months. The question asks only whether the council is liable.

Duty and breach can be argued against the council. But the real contest is causation: would the crash have happened if the council had fixed the light?

The driver’s speeding does not cancel out the council’s failure. More than one negligent act can each be a necessary cause of the same harm.

The driver’s own liability is a separate question, and it is not what was asked. One sentence noting that it is not in issue is enough. That keeps the answer focused on the actual question.

Self-check

Check your own work with these quick tasks.

Look back at a negligence problem you have already answered. Work out which element got the most words. Then ask if the facts really made that element doubtful.

Think of a section number you know by heart. Check which jurisdiction it comes from. Make sure that is the jurisdiction your exam will test.

Finally, write one sentence that deals with an element the facts do not dispute.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.