A research trail in practice: a worked example for a statutory problem

What a research trail must record for each authority (version, paragraphs, status, later-treatment check and limits), illustrated by a worked trail for a Commonwealth statutory problem under the Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth), with the gaps in the research recorded and carried into what the answer may claim.

Learning level
Intermediate
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
legal-research-and-method
Topics
legal-research

Learning outcomes

  • Record, for each authority relied on, the source, date read, version or paragraphs, use, status for the problem, later-treatment check and limits.
  • Build a research trail for a statutory problem in which a statute, a decision on different legislation and an interim decision are distinguished by status.
  • Use a research trail to limit what an answer claims, by recording authorities found but not read and checks that were not made.

A research trail is the record that lets another person repeat your research, check it and see where it stops. Before writing a trail, a student must ask what the answer will rest on and, just as importantly, what the answer cannot say because the research did not reach it. The method in this article applies to any Australian legal problem; the worked example is a Commonwealth statutory problem, so the authorities in it are Commonwealth and federal. The general checklist is in Legal research with authoritative sources, and noting up cases and legislation is in Authority treatment and citation practice and Noting up legislation.

What each entry has to show

The following is one way of setting out a useful entry, not a rule of law. For every authority the answer relies on, the trail records:

  1. the question the authority was found to answer, and the jurisdiction;
  2. the source it was read from, and the date it was read;
  3. the exact version: for legislation, the compilation number and date; for a judgment, the court, the neutral citation, the Justice or judge, and the paragraphs relied on;
  4. what it was used for, and its status for the problem: binding, persuasive, or decided on different legislation;
  5. what was done to check later treatment, and what was found; and
  6. what was not read or could not be done.

The sixth item is the one most often left out and the one that most protects the writer. A trail that records only successes cannot be told from one that stopped early.

A worked example

The question is hypothetical. An airline tells a pilot that his employment will end when he turns 65, under a company rule, and the pilot has complained of age discrimination. The jurisdiction is the Commonwealth: the Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth) has effect throughout Australia, subject to its constitutional provisions (s 9(2)).1

StepSource and versionWhat was foundStatus and limits
1. StatuteAge Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth), Federal Register of Legislation, Compilation No 57, compilation date 1 July 2026, authorised version C2026C00266; read 20 October 2026Section 18(2)(c) makes dismissal on the ground of age unlawful for an employer; s 18(4) provides that para (2)(c) does not make it unlawful where the person is unable to carry out the inherent requirements of the particular employment because of age; s 18(5) lists matters to take into accountLatest compilation listed on the day. Uncommenced amendments, if any, are identified in its endnotes; none was relied on
2. Leading caseQantas Airways Ltd v Christie (1998) 193 CLR 280; [1998] HCA 18, High Court; AustLII text; read in the parts citedGaudron J: an inherent requirement is something essential to the position, and a practical test is whether the position would be essentially the same without the requirement ([34], [36]); Brennan CJ: look to the contract and to the employee’s function in the employer’s undertaking ([1])Decided under s 170DF of the Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth), which spoke of “the particular position”, not under s 18(4). Binding only as to what it decided
3. Case applying the statuteSummers v Qantas Airways Limited [2021] FCA 391, Katzmann J; AustLII text; read in fullAn interim injunction was granted on a prima facie case that the pilot could meet the inherent requirements ([110]); the burden of proving inability lies on the employer ([96])Single judge; interim decision only; final outcome not found
4. Later treatmentSearch for later treatment of steps 2 and 3None run; the treatment of Christie known only as Summers describes it ([78]-[95])Later treatment of both is unknown and the answer must say so

The entries show how the trail constrains the answer. It cannot say that a mandatory retirement age is lawful or unlawful, because no authority in it decides that question under s 18(4). It can say what s 18(4) provides, how the High Court approached “inherent requirements” under different legislation, and that one federal decision at an interim stage found a prima facie case for the pilot.23

Recording what was not done

Step 4 is a record of a gap, and the gap changes what the answer may claim. Summers discusses a High Court decision on the equivalent expression in the disability legislation at [91]-[95]; the trail should list that decision as found but not read, and the answer should not rely on it. A case known only from another case’s description is a lead and not an authority, and a trail that names it as one distinguishes the two.

Using the trail

The trail is used twice. While writing, each sentence stating the law is checked against a row: if no row supports it, the sentence is cut or the research is extended. After writing, the trail is the reader’s route into the answer, so the version and the date matter: a different compilation or a later decision may change the result, and the reader can see which was used.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Write the question and the jurisdiction before searching, and revise them as the research shows which statute governs.
  2. Read legislation from the authorised version, and record the compilation number and date and the date you read it.
  3. For each case, record the court, neutral citation, the Justice or judge, and the paragraphs relied on, and say whether it is binding for the problem, persuasive, or decided on different legislation.
  4. Record the later-treatment check you made and its result, including that none was made.
  5. Record each authority found but not read, or read only in part, and do not rely on it.
  6. Before finishing, match every statement of law in the answer to a row, and say in the answer what the research did not establish.

Self-check

  • Does every authority in my trail show its version or its paragraphs?
  • Have I recorded what I did not do, as well as what I found?
  • Have I said, for each case, whether it is binding for this problem or was decided on different legislation?
  • Can a reader tell, from the trail alone, which sentence of my answer rests on which source?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.