A research trail in practice: a worked example for a statutory problem
What each entry has to show
This is one way to set out a research trail, not a strict legal rule.
For each authority relied on, the entry should record six things. First, the question it answers, and the jurisdiction it comes from.
Second, where it was found, and when. Third, the exact version used. For legislation, that means the compilation number and date. For a judgment, it means the court, citation, judge, and paragraphs relied on.
Fourth, what the authority was used for, and its status. It might be binding, persuasive, or based on different legislation.
Fifth, what checks were done on later treatment of the authority, and what those checks found.
Sixth, what was not read, or could not be checked. This last item is often left out. But it matters most, because it shows the trail did not stop early.
A worked example
This example imagines a pilot told he must retire at 65 under a company rule, and he claims age discrimination. The relevant law is Commonwealth law: the Age Discrimination Act 2004 (Cth) applies Australia-wide, subject to its constitutional limits in s 9(2).
Step one looked at the current compiled version of the Act. Section 18(2)(c) makes it unlawful for an employer to dismiss someone because of age. But s 18(4) says this does not apply if the person cannot perform the “inherent requirements” of the job because of age. Section 18(5) lists factors relevant to that assessment. The researcher checked for uncommenced amendments and found none affecting this.
Step two looked at Qantas Airways Ltd v Christie (1998), a High Court case. Gaudron J said an “inherent requirement” is something essential to the job, tested by asking whether the position would stay essentially the same without it. Brennan CJ said to look at the contract and the employee’s role in the business. This case is important, but it was decided under a different provision (the old s 170DF of the Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth)), not s 18(4). It only binds on what it actually decided.
Step three looked at Summers v Qantas Airways Limited [2021], a single judge Federal Court decision. The court granted an interim injunction, finding a prima facie case that the pilot could meet the inherent requirements. It also held that the employer bears the burden of proving the employee cannot. But this was only an interim ruling—the final result is unknown.
Step four searched for later cases discussing Christie and Summers. No such search was done; the only information about how Summers treated Christie comes from within the Summers judgment itself. So later treatment of both cases remains unknown, and the answer must say so.
Because of these limits, the answer cannot state whether a mandatory retirement age is lawful or unlawful under s 18(4)—no source in the trail decides that question. It can only describe what s 18(4) says, how “inherent requirements” was understood under the earlier, different provision, and that one interim federal decision touched on the issue.
Recording what was not done
This step records what you did not check. That gap limits what your answer can claim.
Summers mentions a High Court decision on similar disability legislation, at [91]-[95]. Your trail should list that decision as found but not read. Your answer should not rely on it.
A case you only know from another case’s description is a lead, not an authority. A proper trail keeps this distinction clear.
Using the trail
The trail serves two purposes. First, while writing, it checks the law. Each sentence about the law must match a row in the trail. If no row supports it, the sentence is cut, or more research is done.
Second, after writing, the trail helps the reader follow the answer. The version and date used matter here. A different compilation, or a later decision, could change the result. Recording this lets the reader see exactly what was relied on.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by writing down the question and the jurisdiction. Update them as research shows which statute actually applies.
Read legislation in its authorised version. Note the compilation number, its date, and the date you read it.
For each case, record the court, the neutral citation, and the judge. Note the paragraphs you relied on. Say whether the case is binding on the problem, merely persuasive, or was decided under different legislation.
Record any check you made for later treatment of a case, and what it showed. If you made no such check, say so.
List any authority you found but did not read, or read only part of. Do not rely on these.
Before finishing, match every legal statement in your answer to a research note. Also say plainly what your research failed to establish.
Self-check
Before finishing, check your research trail against a few questions.
Make sure every authority shows its version or paragraph numbers. This lets a reader find the exact passage you relied on.
Record what you did not do, not just what you found. This shows the limits of your search.
For each case, say whether it binds this problem, or was decided under different legislation. This tells the reader how much weight it carries.
Finally, check that a reader can trace each sentence in your answer back to its source, using the trail alone.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.