Law reform commissions in Australia

What Australian law reform commissions and institutes are, how the Australian Law Reform Commission and each State and Territory body is constituted and receives its work, why their recommendations have no legal force of their own, and how a student may use their reports, including under s 15AB of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth).

Learning level
Foundation
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, act, nt
Subjects
australian-legal-system
Topics
statutory-bodies-and-regulators, statutory-interpretation

Learning outcomes

  • Explain what a law reform commission does, and identify the instrument that constitutes the Australian Law Reform Commission and each State and Territory body, distinguishing statutory commissions from institutes and committees without a statute of their own.
  • Describe how the Australian Law Reform Commission receives its work under the reference model in ss 20-21 of the Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth), and how its reports reach Parliament under s 23.
  • Explain why a law reform recommendation has no legal force of its own, and check whether, and by whom, a recommendation has been implemented.
  • Decide whether and for what purpose a law reform report may be used to interpret a Commonwealth provision under s 15AB of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth).

A law reform commission is a body that examines an area of law and recommends how it should change. Before relying on a law reform report, a student must ask a prior question: which body wrote it, under what authority, and has anyone acted on it? The answer matters because a report is not law. Its recommendations have no legal force of their own: they take effect only if someone with the power to act on them does so, such as Parliament, the government or a court, and the Australian jurisdictions have organised law reform differently: some through a commission created by statute, some through an institute formed by agreement with a university, and one through a committee with no statute at all.

What a law reform body is for

The Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth) speaks of bringing the law into line with current conditions, removing defects in the law, simplifying the law, adopting new or more effective methods for administering the law and dispensing justice, and providing improved access to justice (s 21(1)(a)).1 The New South Wales Act speaks of eliminating defects and anachronisms, repealing obsolete or unnecessary enactments, and consolidating, codifying or revising the law (s 10(1)(a)).3

A law reform body is not a court or a source of legal advice. The Queensland Law Reform Commission states that it does not offer legal advice and cannot intervene in individual cases,9 and the Law Reform Commission of Western Australia says the same of itself.10 As with any statutory authority, the instrument that creates each body sets what it can do.

The Australian Law Reform Commission

The Australian Law Reform Commission (ALRC) is established by s 5(1) of the Australian Law Reform Commission Act 1996 (Cth).

The reference model. Under s 20(1) the Attorney-General may refer a matter to the Commission, either at the Commission’s suggestion or on the Attorney-General’s own initiative. The Commission’s functions in s 21(1) exist “in relation to matters referred to it by the Attorney-General”: to review Commonwealth laws relevant to those matters, and to consider proposals for making, consolidating or repealing Commonwealth laws, for uniformity between State and Territory laws, and for complementary Commonwealth, State and Territory laws. So the ALRC can propose an inquiry but does not choose its own. The Attorney-General may alter the terms of a reference (s 20(2)), direct the order in which references are dealt with (s 20(3)) and direct an interim report (s 22(2)).

How it must work. The Commission must aim at ensuring that what it recommends does not trespass unduly on personal rights and liberties and is, as far as practicable, consistent with Australia’s relevant international obligations (s 24(1)). It may inform itself in any way it thinks fit (s 38).

Independence, and its limits. The Act protects the Commission’s independence expressly where it allows the Attorney-General to establish a management advisory committee: that committee “must not attempt to compromise the independence or impartiality of the Commission in any way” (s 27(2)). The Act does not place the Commission beyond ministerial control: besides controlling what it inquires into, the Attorney-General may give written policies and directions that the President must follow in the capacity of chief executive officer (s 26(2A)).

Reporting and tabling. The Commission reports to the Attorney-General with any recommendations it wants to make (s 21(2)). The Attorney-General must table each report and interim report on a reference in each House of Parliament within 15 sitting days of that House after receiving it (s 23).

The State and Territory bodies

The States and Territories have arranged law reform differently, and the arrangements differ in their legal basis.

New South Wales. The Law Reform Commission Act 1967 (NSW) provides for a Law Reform Commission (s 3(1)). The Commission considers the law “in accordance with any reference to it made by the Minister” (s 10(1)). For an inquiry, the Commission and its Chairperson have the powers, authorities, protections and immunities of a commissioner under Division 1 of Part 2 of the Royal Commissions Act 1923 (NSW) (s 10(2)(a)). Each report furnished to the Minister must be tabled in each House within 14 sitting days after the Minister receives it (s 13(5)).3

Victoria. The Victorian Law Reform Commission Act 2000 (Vic) establishes the Victorian Law Reform Commission (VLRC) as a body corporate (s 4). It examines, reports and makes recommendations on matters referred by the Attorney-General (s 5(1)(a)). It may also examine on its own initiative a matter it considers “raises relatively minor legal issues that are of general community concern”, if that will not require a significant deployment of its resources (s 5(1)(b)). A report on a reference must be laid before each House within 14 sitting days of that House after the Attorney-General receives it (s 21(4)).4

Queensland. The Law Reform Commission Act 1968 (Qld) gives the Queensland Law Reform Commission (QLRC) a broader standing function: to take and keep under review all the law applicable to the State with a view to its systematic development and reform (s 10(1)). It examines branches of the law under a program the Minister approves, or when the Minister asks (s 10(3)). For an inquiry, its members have the powers of a commissioner under the Commissions of Inquiry Act 1950 (Qld) (s 11). The Minister must table each report in the Legislative Assembly within 14 sitting days after receiving it (s 16).5 The Commission describes itself as an independent statutory body that makes recommendations on topics selected by the Attorney-General.9

Western Australia. Under the Law Reform Commission Act 1972 (WA), the Law Reform Commission of Western Australia (LRCWA) prepares and submits proposals for the review of areas of law, and the Attorney-General may refer to it any of those matters or any other matter (s 11(1)-(2)). On a reference it must examine the law critically and report, with any recommendations it considers desirable (s 11(3)). The Attorney-General must present its proposals and reports to each House of Parliament as soon as practicable after receiving them (s 11(7)).6 The Commission describes itself as an independent statutory authority.10

Tasmania. The Tasmania Law Reform Institute (TLRI) is not created by a statute of its own. It was established in 2001 by agreement between the Tasmanian Government, the University of Tasmania and the Law Society, and it may receive proposals from sources including the judiciary, the Attorney-General, the Legal Aid Commission, government departments, the Parliament, the legal profession and the community.11

South Australia. The South Australian Law Reform Institute (SALRI) is likewise formed under an agreement, between the Attorney-General of South Australia, Adelaide University and the Law Society of South Australia. Its Advisory Board receives proposals from bodies including the Attorney-General, and its work may be referred by the Government or self-initiated.12

Northern Territory. The Northern Territory Law Reform Committee is a non-statutory committee established to advise the Attorney-General on law reform, and it considers matters referred to it by the Attorney-General.13

Australian Capital Territory. The ACT Law Reform and Sentencing Advisory Council released a report on dangerous driving in September 2024 and was discontinued in February 2025.14 The sources cited here identify no body that has replaced it, so a student researching ACT law reform should check the Territory’s current arrangements rather than assume a standing commission exists.

JurisdictionBodyBasisHow work beginsTabling
CommonwealthALRCStatute, 1996Reference from the Attorney-General15 sitting days (s 23)
NSWNSW Law Reform CommissionStatute, 1967Reference from the Minister14 sitting days (s 13(5))
VictoriaVLRCStatute, 2000Reference; minor community matters on its own initiative14 sitting days (s 21(4))
QueenslandQLRCStatute, 1968Approved program or Minister’s request14 sitting days (s 16)
WALRCWAStatute, 1972Reference from the Attorney-GeneralAs soon as practicable (s 11(7))
TasmaniaTLRIAgreement, 2001Proposals from several sourcesNot stated in the sources cited
SASALRIAgreementGovernment referral or self-initiatedNot stated in the sources cited
NTNT Law Reform CommitteeNon-statutoryReferral from the Attorney-GeneralNot stated in the sources cited
ACTLaw Reform and Sentencing Advisory CouncilDiscontinued February 2025——

How a reference runs

The ALRC describes its usual sequence.7 The Attorney-General’s written Terms of Reference set the subject matter and goals of the inquiry. The ALRC researches and consults, usually with an advisory committee whose advice it is not bound to accept, and calls for submissions when it releases consultation documents. Each inquiry ends in a Final Report, delivered by the date in the Terms of Reference and embargoed until it is tabled.

Consultation papers go by different names. The Queensland Act allows “working and discussion papers” (s 10(5)),5 and the Tasmania Law Reform Institute released an issues paper for its review of the Coroners Act 1995 (Tas).11

Recommendations have no binding force of their own

A report changes no law. The ALRC states that the Australian Government decides whether to implement its recommendations, in whole or in part, with no set time frame for a response.7 The Queensland Law Reform Commission states that its recommendations do not automatically become law,9 and the South Australian Law Reform Institute states that acceptance of its recommendations is solely at the discretion of the State Government and Parliament.12 Implementation is not always legislative. The ALRC counts a recommendation as implemented by those to whom it is directed, and they are not always Parliament: it records, for example, that in January 2020 the Family Court and the Federal Circuit Court adopted a joint practice direction implementing recommendation 34 of its Report 135 on the family law system.8

So a recommendation is not a statement of the current law, however persuasive. Where Parliament has acted, the enacted words govern, and they may depart from the recommendation. Likewise, any other implementing measure, such as a court’s practice direction, is read in its own terms and may depart from the recommendation. The native title continuity article shows the point: it records an ALRC recommendation alongside a statutory definition that does not reflect it.

Using a report in study and in statutory interpretation

As a secondary source. A report is a useful map of an area, but it is commentary, not authority for what the law is. Cite it as a report, by body, title, report number and year.

As extrinsic material. For a Commonwealth Act, s 15AB of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) allows material outside the Act to be considered if it is capable of assisting in ascertaining a provision’s meaning.2 Section 15AB(2)(b) expressly includes “any relevant report of a Royal Commission, Law Reform Commission, committee of inquiry or other similar body that was laid before either House of the Parliament before the time when the provision was enacted”. Section 15AB(1) permits such material to be considered for two purposes: to confirm that the meaning is the ordinary meaning conveyed by the text in its context and in light of the Act’s purpose, or to determine the meaning when the provision is ambiguous or obscure, or when the ordinary meaning leads to a result that is manifestly absurd or unreasonable. In deciding whether to use the material, and what weight to give it, regard must be had to the desirability of persons being able to rely on the ordinary meaning, and the need to avoid prolonging proceedings without compensating advantage (s 15AB(3)). See also Statutory interpretation in Australia.

Section 15AB is a Commonwealth provision. For a State or Territory Act, check that jurisdiction’s own interpretation legislation; for Western Australia, see the Western Australian statutory interpretation supplement.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the jurisdiction whose law governs the issue, and the body whose report is in front of you.
  2. State the report’s status: its recommendations have no legal force of their own.
  3. Check whether the recommendation has been implemented, and by whom (for example Parliament, the government or a court), and read the enacted provision or other implementing measure, which may differ from what was recommended.
  4. For a Commonwealth provision, ask whether s 15AB permits use of the report: is it being used to confirm the ordinary meaning or to resolve ambiguity, obscurity or a manifestly absurd or unreasonable result? A report laid before either House before the provision was enacted falls within s 15AB(2)(b), but that list does not limit s 15AB(1), so another report may still be considered under s 15AB(1). Either way, weigh it under s 15AB(3).
  5. For a State or Territory Act, apply that jurisdiction’s interpretation legislation rather than s 15AB.

Self-check

  • Have I said which jurisdiction’s body wrote the report, and whether that body is statutory?
  • Have I treated a recommendation as a proposal rather than as the law?
  • Have I read the enacted provision or other implementing measure, not only the report that preceded it?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.