Law reform commissions in Australia
What a law reform body is for
Law reform commissions exist to improve the law. The Commonwealth Act lists goals like modernising the law, fixing defects, simplifying it, and improving access to justice (s 21(1)(a)).
The New South Wales Act focuses on removing outdated provisions and consolidating or codifying the law (s 10(1)(a)).
These bodies are not courts. They do not give legal advice or get involved in individual cases, as the Queensland and Western Australian commissions both confirm.
Each commission’s powers come from the law that created it. That founding instrument sets the limits on what it can do.
How a reference runs
The ALRC follows a usual process. The Attorney-General sets the inquiry’s topic and goals in written Terms of Reference.
The ALRC then researches and consults, usually with an advisory committee. It does not have to accept that committee’s advice. It also calls for submissions when it releases consultation documents.
Each inquiry ends with a Final Report. This is due by the date set in the Terms of Reference, and stays embargoed (not public) until tabled in Parliament.
Consultation documents have different names depending on the law reform body. Queensland’s Act allows “working and discussion papers” (s 10(5)). The Tasmania Law Reform Institute instead used an “issues paper” for its review of the Coroners Act 1995 (Tas).
Recommendations have no binding force of their own
A commission’s report does not itself change the law. The ALRC says government decides whether to adopt its recommendations, fully or partly, with no deadline to respond.
Other bodies agree. The Queensland Law Reform Commission says its recommendations do not automatically become law. The South Australian Law Reform Institute says adoption is up to the State Government and Parliament alone.
Implementation need not involve Parliament. The ALRC treats a recommendation as implemented by whoever acts on it, including courts. For example, in January 2020 two federal courts adopted a joint practice direction to implement one such recommendation.
Because of this, a recommendation does not state current law, however persuasive it seems. If Parliament legislates, the actual wording of the statute controls, and may differ from what was recommended. Similarly, a court’s practice direction is read on its own terms, and may also depart from the recommendation.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out which jurisdiction’s law applies, and which body wrote the report you’re looking at.
Remember the report itself has no legal force. Its recommendations are not binding law.
Check if the recommendation was actually implemented, and by whom, such as Parliament, government or a court. Read the actual enacted provision, since it may differ from what was recommended.
For Commonwealth provisions, consider s 15AB. This section allows use of extrinsic material like reports to confirm ordinary meaning, or to resolve ambiguity, obscurity, or a manifestly absurd or unreasonable result. A report tabled before either House before enactment fits s 15AB(2)(b), but this is not an exhaustive list, so other reports may still qualify under s 15AB(1). Whichever applies, the weight given to the report is assessed under s 15AB(3).
For State or Territory Acts, use that jurisdiction’s own interpretation legislation instead of s 15AB.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.