Ecologically sustainable development in statute and in the courts

How ecologically sustainable development is written into Commonwealth, New South Wales, Queensland and Victorian statutes, and what the New South Wales Court of Appeal decided in Walker and Warkworth about whether and how decision-makers must apply it.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, qld, vic
Subjects
environmental-and-planning-law
Topics
environmental-and-planning-framework

Learning outcomes

  • State the principles of ecologically sustainable development as the EPBC Act and the New South Wales legislation each define them, and note how the Queensland and Victorian Acts frame the idea.
  • Distinguish a statute that requires ecologically sustainable development to be taken into account from one that reaches it only through an object or the public interest.
  • Explain what Minister for Planning v Walker and Warkworth Mining v Bulga decided about the public interest and the principles, and why both are qualified by the repeal of Part 3A.

Ecologically sustainable development (ESD) is not defined once for Australia. The Commonwealth, New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria each state the idea in their own words, and each gives it a different job: a principle to be taken into account, an object of the Act, or a purpose that everyone exercising a function must advance. Before asking whether a decision-maker had to apply ESD, a student must therefore ask which Act confers the power and what role that Act gives ESD. Ecologically sustainable development introduces the idea in general terms; this article covers the texts, the two leading New South Wales appellate decisions and the first-instance decision that followed Walker. It states the position in those four jurisdictions only.

The Commonwealth text

Section 3A of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (the EPBC Act) lists five principles: integration of long-term and short-term economic, environmental, social and equitable considerations in decision-making; the precautionary principle; inter-generational equity; conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity as a fundamental consideration; and improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms.1 One object of the Act is to promote ESD through the conservation and ecologically sustainable use of natural resources.

The Act does not leave the principles as an object alone. In deciding whether to approve the taking of an action, and what conditions to attach, the Minister must take into account the principles of ecologically sustainable development (s 136(2)(a)). Separately, the Minister must take account of the precautionary principle in deciding whether an action is a controlled action (s 75) and whether to approve it (s 133), but only to the extent that can be done consistently with the Act’s other provisions (s 391).2 Where the Act itself names the principles in the approval provision, the Act makes them a matter the Minister must take into account. No case on how far the duty goes is cited here, and the approval process is described in EPBC assessment approaches and controlled actions.

New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria

In New South Wales the definition lives in s 6(2) of the Protection of the Environment Administration Act 1991 (NSW). ESD requires the effective integration of social, economic and environmental considerations in decision-making, and is achieved through four principles and programs: the precautionary principle, inter-generational equity, conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity, and improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms, including polluter pays.3 The current text says “social, economic and environmental”; the version quoted in a 2008 case spoke only of economic and environmental considerations, so older decisions must be read against the present wording. The Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) (the EP&A Act) adopts that definition (s 1.4) and makes it an object of the Act to facilitate ESD by integrating relevant economic, environmental and social considerations in decision-making (s 1.3(i)).4

The EP&A Act does not list ESD among the matters a consent authority must consider on a development application. It lists “the public interest” (s 4.15(1)(e)). That matters, as the cases below show, and it also matters that for targeted assessment development the consent authority must not take the public interest into consideration at all (s 4.15(1C)-(1D)).

Queensland frames the idea as “ecological sustainability”, a balance of the protection of ecological processes and natural systems, economic development, and people’s wellbeing, and that balance is said to include accounting for potential adverse impacts of development on climate change (s 3(3)(c)(iv)). Every entity that performs a function under the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) must do so in a way that advances that purpose, which includes applying the precautionary principle and seeking equity between present and future generations (ss 3 and 5).5 Victoria’s Planning and Environment Act 1987 states objectives of planning, including sustainable use and development of land, maintaining ecological processes and genetic diversity and balancing the present and future interests of all Victorians, and states as an objective of the planning framework that decisions give explicit consideration to climate change policy and obligations (s 4(1)(a), (b), (g) and (2)(da)).6 The matters that Victorian and Queensland decision-makers must consider on a permit or development application are described in Deciding a development application and appealing the decision. No Queensland or Victorian case on ESD is cited here.

When is ESD a condition of a valid decision?

The leading appellate discussion is Minister for Planning v Walker [2008] NSWCA 224, a New South Wales Court of Appeal decision. The Minister had approved a concept plan under former Part 3A of the EP&A Act, and the applicant argued that the approval was void because the Minister had not considered the principles of ESD or the risk that climate change would worsen flooding on the site. Hodgson JA gave the reasons, Campbell JA agreed with him, and Bell JA agreed with the orders and with his reasons that failure to consider ESD principles did not make the approval void, expressing no view on [56]-[63].7 The appeal was allowed.

Hodgson JA’s reasoning can be divided, for study, into three steps. First, consideration of the public interest is a condition of validity, but it “operates at a very high level of generality” and does not of itself require regard to any particular aspect of the public interest ([39]-[41]). Secondly, he agreed with Preston CJ’s view in Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hornsby Shire Council that the public interest in the former s 79C(1)(e), the predecessor of s 4.15(1)(e), embraces ESD, so that a consent authority, or the Land and Environment Court on a merits appeal, that declined to have regard to the principles where relevant issues arose would make an error of law ([42]-[43]). Thirdly, that did not make the principles themselves a condition of validity for the Minister’s decision: encouraging ESD is one of many objects of the Act, which include matters that would be irrelevant to many decisions, and an incorrect decision that an object is not relevant would not without more make a decision void ([44], [52]-[55]). His Honour added, as an obiter suggestion on which Bell JA expressed no view, that the principles are likely to become so plainly an element of the public interest that failure to consider them will be strong evidence of failure to consider the public interest ([56]).

Four years after Walker, in Barrington-Gloucester-Stroud Preservation Alliance Inc v Minister for Planning and Infrastructure [2012] NSWLEC 197, Pepper J, a single judge of the Land and Environment Court, reviewed the later decisions and held that a decision-maker exercising power under s 75J of Part 3A was bound to consider the principles of ESD as part of the public interest, at a high level of generality: in her Honour’s words, the time Hodgson JA had anticipated at [56] had come ([169]-[171]).9 That is a first-instance decision and persuasive only, and it does not overrule Walker. Two years later a joint judgment of the Court of Appeal in Warkworth Mining Ltd v Bulga Milbrodale Progress Association Inc [2014] NSWCA 105 rejected the mining company’s reading of Walker. The Court said that Walker is authority that where it is necessary to consider the environmental impact of a project, the public interest embraces ESD, and that a requirement to have regard to the public interest operates at a high level of generality ([296], [299]).8 It dismissed an appeal on a question of law against the Land and Environment Court’s disapproval of a mine extension, and held that it was a relevant consideration for the Court to ask what avoidance measures the proponent proposed for an undeniable impact on endangered ecological communities ([334]).

Both cases were decided under former Part 3A, which has since been repealed, and the EP&A Act has been renumbered and amended; the statements about the public interest are therefore authority by analogy for s 4.15(1)(e), not decisions on it. They bind courts below the Court of Appeal in New South Wales and are persuasive in other jurisdictions.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the Act that confers the power and find where it states or requires ESD: an object, a purpose clause, the public interest, or a provision naming the principles.
  2. If the provision names the principles, as s 136(2)(a) of the EPBC Act does, treat them as a mandatory consideration, and check s 391 separately for the precautionary principle.
  3. If the Act reaches ESD through an object or the public interest and does not name the principles, apply Walker and Warkworth by analogy: ask whether issues relevant to the principles arose on the facts, and do not assert that every omission to mention them voids the decision.
  4. Check the version of the definition: the New South Wales text now includes social considerations, and an older case may quote the earlier words.
  5. Separate the question of validity from the question of weight: Walker sets out the principle that, absent a statutory indication of weight, it is generally for the decision-maker and not the court to decide the weight given to a mandatory consideration ([34]), so a decision-maker who considered ESD may still decide against the more protective outcome.

Self-check

  • Have I named the Act and section that give ESD its role, rather than treating ESD as a free-standing rule?
  • Have I said that Walker and Warkworth were decided under former Part 3A and apply to the present Act by analogy?
  • Have I kept the obiter suggestion at [56] of Walker apart from what the Court decided?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.