Deciding a development application and appealing the decision
How a development application is decided and appealed in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland: the matters each Act requires the decision-maker to consider, the decisions open to it, and the merits appeal routes, with the Land and Environment Court’s rehearing jurisdiction illustrated by the Warkworth decision.
Learning outcomes
- State the matters a consent authority or responsible authority must consider on a development or permit application in New South Wales and Victoria, and how Queensland structures the decision by category of assessment.
- Identify who may appeal a decision in each of the three States, to which body, and on what footing: rehearing, hearing anew or reconsideration of the evidence.
- Distinguish a merits appeal to the Land and Environment Court from an appeal on a question of law, using Warkworth Mining v Bulga.
Planning approval is State and local government law, so the first question in any problem is which State’s Act applies. The second is what that Act obliges the decision-maker to consider and who may challenge the result, and the answers differ more than the labels suggest. This article states the position in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland only; the other States and Territories have their own systems and are not covered. The general structure of a planning system, with its schemes, zones and applications, is in Planning approvals; this article takes the decision and the appeal in turn.
New South Wales: the matters in s 4.15
In New South Wales the consent authority determines a development application under Part 4 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) (the EP&A Act). Section 4.15(1) directs it to take into consideration “such of the following matters as are of relevance to the development”: the planning instruments, development control plans, planning agreements and regulations that apply to the land; the significant likely impacts of the development, including environmental impacts on the natural and built environments and social and economic impacts in the locality; the suitability of the site; submissions; and the public interest.1 The regulations may declare factors relevant or not relevant to likely impacts, site suitability and the public interest, and the authority must not consider a factor declared not relevant.
The list has a carve-out that reverses the usual answer. For targeted assessment development the authority may consider only the instruments and similar matters in s 4.15(1)(a) and submissions, and must not consider likely impacts, site suitability or the public interest (s 4.15(1C)-(1D)). The authority then grants consent, unconditionally or with conditions, or refuses it (s 4.16(1)). A condition may be imposed if it relates to a matter in s 4.15(1) of relevance or to a likely impact of the development (s 4.17(1)).
Victoria: s 60 and the permit decision
In Victoria the decision-maker is the responsible authority, and s 60(1) of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic) says that before deciding an application it must consider the relevant planning scheme; the objectives of planning in Victoria; objections and other submissions not withdrawn; any decision and comments of a referral authority; any significant effects on the environment that it considers the use or development may have, or the environment may have on it; and any significant social and economic effects it considers the use or development may have.4 The Act adds a second list of matters it “may” consider if the circumstances appear to require it (s 60(1A)), and a planning scheme may exempt a class of application, wholly or in part, from s 60(1)(b) to (f), (1A) and (1B) (s 60(3A)); if no notice of the application is required the authority need not consider objections or submissions (s 60(3)). Where appropriate it must have regard to the number of objectors in considering whether the use or development may have a significant social effect (s 60(1B)). The authority may grant a permit, grant it with conditions, or refuse “on any ground it thinks fit”, but it must refuse if a relevant determining referral authority objects (s 61(1)-(2)).
Queensland: the decision turns on the category of assessment
Queensland’s Planning Act 2016 (Qld) structures the decision differently.6 For development requiring code assessment the assessment manager must approve the application to the extent the development complies with all the assessment benchmarks, may approve even if it does not comply with some, may impose development conditions, and may refuse for non-compliance only if compliance cannot be achieved by imposing conditions (s 60(2)). For development requiring impact assessment it must approve all or part, approve with conditions, or refuse (s 60(3)). A referral agency’s response, other than advice, binds the decision, and conditions it requires must be included exactly as stated (s 62). Which category applies to a given development is a separate question that this article does not state.
Merits appeals in New South Wales
An applicant who is dissatisfied with the determination may appeal to the Land and Environment Court (EP&A Act s 8.7), within six months after the determination is notified or registered on the NSW planning portal (s 8.10(1)). An appeal cannot be made while a review of the determination under Division 8.2 is pending, and for determinations that can be reviewed under that Division the period of the review is disregarded in counting the six months (ss 8.9A, 8.10(4)). An application the consent authority has not determined within the prescribed period is taken to have been refused for the purposes of the appeal, which may be made at any time after that period ends and before the authority determines the application (ss 8.10(2), 8.11). There is no appeal under that Division against a decision of the Independent Planning Commission made after a public hearing (s 8.6(3)). An objector’s right under s 8.8 is narrower: it belongs to an objector who duly made a submission, it lies only against a grant of consent for designated development, and it must be exercised within 28 days of notification (ss 8.8, 8.10(3)).2 These appeals are Class 1 proceedings, in which the Court has all the functions and discretions of the consent authority, the appeal is by way of rehearing and fresh evidence may be given, and the Court’s decision is taken to be the consent authority’s decision (Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) ss 17(d), 39(2)-(5)).3 The Court must have regard to the relevant Acts and instruments, the circumstances of the case and the public interest.
A party dissatisfied with the Court’s decision may appeal on a question of law, to the Supreme Court under s 57(1), except that a decision made by a Commissioner is appealed to the Court itself under s 56A (other than the kinds of decision in s 57(4)(a) and (b)), and leave is needed for the decisions listed in s 57(4). Warkworth Mining Ltd v Bulga Milbrodale Progress Association Inc [2014] NSWCA 105 illustrates both levels.9 In the Court of Appeal’s description, the Land and Environment Court heard a Class 1 appeal against a former Part 3A decision by way of rehearing and re-exercised the Minister’s power; the Chief Judge accepted that the economic and positive social impacts were substantial but, balancing all relevant matters, concluded that the preferable decision was to disapprove the project. The appeal to the Court of Appeal was brought under s 57 and so depended on error on a question of law, which includes error about relevant and irrelevant considerations ([3]-[4]); the appeal was dismissed. The case was decided under a Part since repealed and shows the structure of the Court’s jurisdiction rather than a rule of Part 4. It binds courts below the Court of Appeal in New South Wales and is persuasive elsewhere.
Appeals in Victoria and Queensland
In Victoria an applicant may apply to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal for review of a refusal (s 77), subject to s 82AA, which removes the right for a refusal of a permit for marine and coastal Crown land where the Minister administering the Marine and Coastal Act 2018 has refused or is deemed to have refused consent, and an objector may apply for review of a decision to grant a permit (s 82(1)).5 A planning scheme may exempt classes of application from the objector’s right, and where it does no application for review can be made (s 82(2)-(3)). The Tribunal’s powers on review are not stated here.
Queensland’s appeal rights are set out by Schedule 1 to the Planning Act, which states which matters may be appealed to a tribunal, to the Planning and Environment Court (the P&E Court) or to either, and who may appeal.7 The forum matters because the footing differs. A tribunal decides by a reconsideration of the evidence that was before the original decision-maker, though it may consider other evidence if leave is given, and must not change a development application other than by a minor change (ss 253(4)-(5), 254(3)). An appeal to the P&E Court, subject to any relevant enabling Act, is by way of hearing anew, and an applicant who appeals must establish that the appeal should be upheld, while on an appeal by a submitter the applicant must establish that it should be dismissed.8
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the State and the Act, and the decision-maker: a consent authority, a responsible authority or an assessment manager.
- State the matters that Act requires the decision-maker to consider, and check for a carve-out, such as targeted assessment development in New South Wales or a planning scheme exemption in Victoria.
- In Queensland, ask whether the development required code or impact assessment before applying s 60.
- Identify who is appealing, the body they appeal to and the time limit, using the Act’s own period, and note whether the right is the applicant’s or an objector’s.
- Say what the appeal body does: re-exercise the decision-maker’s power on a rehearing (New South Wales), review the decision (Victoria), or hear the appeal anew or reconsider the evidence (Queensland), and keep that distinct from an appeal on a question of law.
Self-check
- Have I named the State and section for each matter for consideration and each right of appeal, instead of speaking of “the planning system”?
- Have I distinguished an applicant’s right of appeal from an objector’s, and the time limits?
- Have I treated Warkworth as illustrating the Court’s jurisdiction under a repealed Part, not as a Part 4 rule?