Deciding a development application and appealing the decision
Victoria: s 60 and the permit decision
In Victoria, the responsible authority decides permit applications. Under s 60(1), it must consider the planning scheme, planning objectives, objections and submissions not withdrawn, referral authority decisions, and likely environmental, social and economic effects.
Section 60(1A) lists further matters it may consider if needed. A planning scheme can exempt some applications from parts of s 60 (s 60(3A)), and if no notice was required, objections need not be considered (s 60(3)).
Where relevant, the authority must consider the number of objectors when assessing social effect (s 60(1B)).
Under s 61(1)-(2), the authority may grant, grant with conditions, or refuse a permit on any ground it thinks fit. But it must refuse if a determining referral authority objects.
Merits appeals in New South Wales
An applicant who disagrees with a decision can appeal to the Land and Environment Court, under EP&A Act s 8.7. The appeal must be made within six months of notification (s 8.10(1)).
An appeal cannot be made while a review under Division 8.2 is pending. For determinations open to that review, the review period is left out when counting the six months (ss 8.9A, 8.10(4)).
If the consent authority has not decided within the set period, the application is treated as refused for appeal purposes. The appeal can then be lodged any time after that period, up until an actual decision is made (ss 8.10(2), 8.11).
There is no appeal against an Independent Planning Commission decision made after a public hearing (s 8.6(3)). An objector’s appeal right under s 8.8 is narrower: only an objector who made a submission can use it, only against a grant of consent for designated development, and only within 28 days of notification (ss 8.8, 8.10(3)).
These appeals are Class 1 proceedings. The Court gets all the powers of the consent authority, hears the matter afresh, and may accept new evidence. Its decision counts as the consent authority’s decision (Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) ss 17(d), 39(2)-(5)). The Court must weigh the relevant Acts and planning instruments, the facts of the case, and the public interest.
A party unhappy with the Court’s decision can appeal further, but only on a question of law. This goes to the Supreme Court under s 57(1). Decisions made by a Commissioner instead go to the Land and Environment Court itself under s 56A, except for certain decision types listed in s 57(4)(a)-(b). Some decisions under s 57(4) need leave before they can be appealed.
Warkworth Mining Ltd v Bulga Milbrodale Progress Association Inc [2014] NSWCA 105 shows both appeal levels in action. The Land and Environment Court had heard a Class 1 appeal against an earlier Part 3A decision, re-exercising the Minister’s power afresh. The Chief Judge accepted the project had real economic and social benefits, but on balance found refusal was the better outcome. The further appeal to the Court of Appeal, under s 57, could only succeed by showing an error of law.
Appeals in Victoria and Queensland
In Victoria, an applicant can ask VCAT to review a refusal (s 77). But s 82AA removes this right for refusals over marine and coastal Crown land, where the Marine and Coastal Act 2018 Minister has refused, or is deemed to have refused, consent.
An objector can apply to review a decision granting a permit (s 82(1)). However, a planning scheme may exempt some applications from this objector right. Where it does, no review application is possible (s 82(2)-(3)). The passage does not say what powers the Tribunal has once a review is before it.
In Queensland, Schedule 1 to the Planning Act sets out which matters can be appealed, to a tribunal, to the Planning and Environment Court (P&E Court), or to either. It also says who may appeal.
The forum chosen matters, because the basis of each appeal differs. A tribunal appeal is a “reconsideration” — it reviews the evidence that was before the original decision-maker. It may look at other evidence only with leave, and cannot change the development application except by a minor change (ss 253(4)-(5), 254(3)).
A P&E Court appeal, subject to any relevant enabling Act, is “by way of hearing anew” — a fresh hearing, not just a review. An applicant appealing must show the appeal should succeed. But where a submitter brings the appeal, the applicant must instead show it should be dismissed.
Applying this in a problem question
First, work out the State, the Act, and who is deciding. This decision-maker may be called a consent authority, a responsible authority, or an assessment manager, depending on the State.
Next, state what the Act requires the decision-maker to consider. Check whether a carve-out applies, like targeted assessment development in New South Wales or a planning scheme exemption in Victoria. A carve-out changes or removes the usual requirement.
In Queensland, first ask whether the development needed code assessment or impact assessment. Answer this before applying s 60.
Then identify who is appealing, which body hears the appeal, and the time limit. Use the time limit set in the Act itself. Note whether the appeal right belongs to the applicant or to an objector, since this can differ.
Finally, explain what the appeal body actually does. In New South Wales, it re-exercises the decision-maker’s power on a rehearing. In Victoria, it reviews the decision. In Queensland, it hears the appeal afresh or reconsiders the evidence. Keep this separate from an appeal on a question of law, which is a different, narrower process.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.