Minister for Planning v Walker
Minister for Planning v Walker [2008] NSWCA 224; (2008) 161 LGERA 423
A coastal concept plan was challenged for failing to address climate-change flood risk. Did that omission make the approval invalid?
Clarified by Barrington-Gloucester-Stroud Preservation Alliance Inc v Minister for Planning and Infrastructure [2012] NSWLEC 197
In Barrington-Gloucester-Stroud, Pepper J held that the Planning Assessment Commission, exercising the Minister’s power under former s 75J, was bound to consider ESD principles as part of the public interest. Her Honour considered that the time anticipated by Hodgson JA in Walker had arrived. The obligation operated at a high level of generality: it required consideration of the substance of the principles, but the level of generality did not mandate any particular method of analysis or outcome, and a direct application of the principles to each condition imposed was not required. The challenge was dismissed. Her Honour acknowledged that Walker had overruled Gray v Minister for Planning to the extent that it held a Part 3A decision-maker was obliged to consider ESD principles ([158]), and reached her conclusion on s 75J by drawing substantially on later Land and Environment Court decisions ([162]-[169]). That conclusion sits in some tension with Hodgson JA’s treatment of ESD at [55] as one of the Act’s objects whose omission would not without more make a decision void. Barrington was a first-instance decision on a later project approval: it developed Hodgson JA’s prospective observation at [56] for s 75J decisions, but it did not reverse Walker’s result on the earlier concept plan.
What happened?
The Minister approved a concept plan for redevelopment at Sandon Point. Jill Walker challenged the approval in the Land and Environment Court. Biscoe J declared the approval and associated determinations void. The Minister appealed.
The dispute concerned climate-change flood risk and the principles of ecologically sustainable development, usually shortened to ESD. The approval was made under the former Part 3A of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). Hodgson JA identified the applicable version as the one before changes commencing on 12 January 2007. This historical setting matters: the decision addresses that statutory scheme, rather than supplying a current checklist for planning approvals.
What did the Court decide?
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the orders below and dismissed the proceedings below. Written submissions on costs were to be provided. The Minister’s concept-plan approval survived the challenge.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Hodgson JA distinguished an obligation to consider the public interest from an obligation to consider each particular aspect of it. The first did not itself turn every aspect into a condition of validity. Whether consideration of ESD was mandatory depended on construing the legislation, rather than moving straight from the importance of environmental protection to invalidity.
The Act’s objects included encouraging ESD alongside other objectives. Hodgson JA reasoned that failure to consider whether an object was relevant, or an incorrect judgment that it was irrelevant, would not without more make a decision void. Campbell JA agreed. Bell JA agreed with the reasons that failure to consider ESD did not render this approval void. Hodgson JA, with Campbell JA agreeing, also held that consideration of the public interest is itself a condition of validity ([39]), so that failure to consider the public interest would avoid a decision of the Minister, but that the primary judge had not found, and could not find, that the Minister failed to consider it ([57]); Bell JA’s reservation extended to that part of the reasons ([56]-[63]).
Hodgson JA did not think that approval of the concept plan should be considered as resolving these matters in favour of the development ([62]). Hodgson JA said it was not strictly necessary for him to make a finding on whether ESD had been considered, but that, had he considered consideration of the ESD principles mandatory, he would have inferred that the substance of the precautionary principle and intergenerational equity had not been addressed ([59]-[60]). Those observations followed his conclusion on validity; Bell JA expressly declined to express a view on that later part of his reasons.
Hodgson JA also suggested that the principles of ESD are likely to come to be seen as so plainly an element of the public interest that failure to consider them will become strong evidence of failure to consider the public interest or to act bona fide, and thus capable of avoiding decisions ([56]). He expressly said that this was not suggested to be the situation when the Minister made this decision, and that he would not so conclude ([56]). That prediction concerned future challenges, rather than the basis for allowing this appeal.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Hodgson JA; Campbell JA agreeing; Bell JA agreeing on the validity ground
Read judgment: [44] (opens in a new tab), [52]–[55] (opens in a new tab)
These passages reject the proposed implication that a failure to consider an aspect of the public interest necessarily invalidates approval ([44], [52]-[55]). That reasoning supplies the ground for setting aside the declarations of invalidity. Bell JA expressly joins the reasons on that ground.
Ratio · Hodgson JA, with Campbell JA agreeing (Bell JA expressly reserved on paragraphs 56-63)
Read judgment: [39] (opens in a new tab), [57] (opens in a new tab)
Hodgson JA holds that consideration of the public interest is itself a condition of validity ([39]), so that a failure to consider it would avoid a decision of the Minister, but that the primary judge had not found, and could not find, that the Minister failed to consider it, because the Minister took into account the Director-General’s report ([57]). Bell JA preferred not to express a view on paragraphs 56-63, which include [57]; her agreement at [66] is with the reasons that a failure to consider ESD did not render the approval void, and does not expressly address [39].
Obiter · Hodgson JA, with Campbell JA agreeing
Read judgment: [56] (opens in a new tab)
Hodgson JA suggests that failure to consider ESD is likely to become strong evidence of failure to consider the public interest or to act bona fide ([56]). He expressly says that this was not suggested to be the situation at the time of this decision and that he would not so conclude. The prediction was unnecessary to allowing the appeal; Bell JA expressly declined to express a view on paragraphs 56-63.
Why does this case matter?
Environmental litigation can involve a powerful criticism of an assessment alongside a more demanding question about the remedy sought. Walker helps you read an appeal with both the challenged decision and the requested relief in view. It is also useful practice in separating a judge’s criticism from the legal ground on which the litigation ends.
Exam and application relevance
Start with the statutory power exercised and the version of the legislation. Explain the route from the alleged omission to the claimed legal consequence. A reference to environmental objectives needs to be connected to the particular provision and the ground of review.
For a problem using later legislation, identify what that legislation requires before transferring the result of this historical approval dispute. When discussing a passage beyond the ground of decision, identify the judges who joined it and the role it played in the appeal.
Check your understanding
1. What is the difference between identifying an important environmental concern and establishing a condition of validity?
2. Why does Hodgson JA’s prediction about future ESD challenges have a different status from the reasoning that disposed of the appeal?
3. How does Bell JA’s express reservation affect the way you describe agreement among the judges?