EPBC assessment approaches and controlled actions

What follows a referral under the EPBC Act: the controlled action decision and the meaning of significant impact, the Minister’s choice among six assessment approaches, what each produces, and how the result feeds the approval decision.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
environmental-and-planning-law
Topics
environmental-impact-assessment

Learning outcomes

  • Explain what makes a referred action a controlled action, what the Minister may and may not weigh in that decision, and what the courts have said a significant impact is.
  • Identify the six assessment approaches the Minister may choose between under the EPBC Act, the conditions on choosing an accredited process or assessment on referral information, and what each approach produces.
  • Trace how the assessment report feeds the approval decision, and where Part 8 does not apply.

This article states Commonwealth law under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) (the EPBC Act), as compiled to 24 August 2026. After a proposal is referred, the Minister makes two separate decisions, and a student must not run them together: whether the action is a controlled action, and, if it is, which of six assessment approaches will be used. The referral step, and the bar on referring while an alternate pathway applies, are described in Environmental impact assessment; this article starts where that one stops.

Is the action a controlled action?

An action is a controlled action if taking it without approval under Part 9 would be prohibited by a provision of Part 3 (or would be, but for s 25AA, s 28AB or a determination under s 79E). That provision is then a controlling provision for the action, and a person must not take a controlled action unless an approval is in operation or one of the other permissions in s 67A applies.1 The Minister decides whether the action is a controlled action and which Part 3 provisions control it, and must do so within 20 business days after receiving the referral (days are not counted while information the Minister requested is outstanding or where the Minister and the proponent agree in writing not to count them).

Two rules in s 75 shape the decision. The Minister must consider the comments received within the period specified in the public invitation. And, where the impacts of the action are relevant, the Minister must consider all adverse impacts on the matter each Part 3 provision protects and must not consider beneficial impacts on that matter, subject to limits in s 75(2A)-(2B) for particular provisions and for regional forest agreement forestry operations.

What counts as a significant impact

Several Part 3 prohibitions turn on a “significant impact”, for example s 12 on world heritage values and s 18 on listed threatened species. The Act’s definitions section has no stand-alone entry for the term.5 The working formulation comes from Booth v Bosworth [2001] FCA 1453, where Branson J, hearing an application about an electric grid that killed flying foxes near the Wet Tropics World Heritage Area, recorded that the parties were in broad agreement that a significant impact is “important, notable or of consequence having regard to its context or intensity”, and applied it ([99], [105]-[106]).6 That is a single-judge decision on a formulation the parties accepted, and it is persuasive only. In Save Our Strathbogie Forest Inc v Secretary to the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action [2024] FCAFC 134, a Full Court of the Federal Court recorded that no issue was taken on appeal with the primary judge’s discussion of the principles, which included the same formulation and the view that “likely” means a real or not remote chance or possibility ([62]), and said that the primary judge had correctly stated them ([116]).7 That case concerned s 18, not the controlled action decision. The primary judge in Strathbogie treated the question as one of fact decided on the evidence as a whole, so a student should ask what the impact is on the protected matter, not whether any adverse effect can be imagined.

An impact has a statutory meaning of its own: a direct consequence of the action, or an indirect consequence of which the action is a substantial cause, with further conditions where another person’s later action intervenes.

Choosing the assessment approach

Once the Minister has decided that an action is a controlled action, the Minister must choose one approach for assessing its relevant impacts, which are the impacts on the matter protected by each controlling provision (for some provisions, only those of the part of the action taken in a Commonwealth area or similar place).2 The six approaches are:

  • an accredited assessment process;
  • assessment on referral information (Division 3A);
  • assessment on preliminary documentation (Division 4);
  • a public environment report (Division 5);
  • an environmental impact statement (Division 6); and
  • an inquiry (Division 7).

Three of them carry conditions. An accredited process may be chosen only if the Minister is satisfied that it is carried out under a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a self-governing Territory, that the process and the law meet any standards prescribed by the regulations, that it will ensure the relevant impacts are adequately assessed, and that it will give the Minister a report that is enough to decide whether to approve. This is the route in s 87 by which an assessment under a State or Territory law can serve as the assessment the Commonwealth needs, and the Minister must be satisfied of each of those matters before choosing it. Assessment on referral information is open only if the action meets criteria prescribed in the regulations. Preliminary documentation may be chosen only if the Minister is satisfied that it will allow an informed approval decision. The decision is due within 20 business days after the referral, not counting days while requested information is outstanding or where time is suspended by written agreement, and on the same day as the controlled action decision unless the Minister has asked for more information; notice of it must be given within 10 business days.

What each approach produces

Each approach ends in a report to the Minister.3 The pattern differs in who does the work.

  • Referral information: within 30 business days of the approach decision the Secretary must prepare a draft recommendation report, publish it with an invitation to give comments within 10 business days, finalise it and give it to the Minister.
  • Preliminary documentation: the designated proponent publishes, within a period specified in the Minister’s direction of at least 10 business days, the specified information and an invitation to comment within the period specified in the direction and, if comments are received, prepares a document that summarises them and how they were addressed (if none are received, it gives the Minister a written statement to that effect); the Secretary then gives the Minister a recommendation report.
  • Public environment report and environmental impact statement: the designated proponent prepares a draft to guidelines, needs the Minister’s approval to publish it, allows at least 20 business days for comment and finalises it with a summary of how comments were addressed; the Secretary again gives the Minister a recommendation report.
  • Inquiry: the Minister appoints commissioners and sets terms of reference including the period for reporting, and hearings are public unless the commission directs otherwise.

A recommendation report advises on whether to approve and on conditions. It does not decide either question.

From assessment to approval, and where Part 8 falls away

At the approval stage the Minister must consider matters relevant to each controlling provision and economic and social matters, and in doing so must take into account the principles of ecologically sustainable development and the report that the chosen approach produced. The Minister must not consider matters the Division does not require or permit.4 How the ecologically sustainable development principles operate is taken up in Ecologically sustainable development in statute and in the courts.

Part 8 does not apply to an action in a State or self-governing Territory where a bilateral agreement in operation declares that the class of actions need not be assessed under it, or where the Minister’s own declaration to that effect is in operation. The notes to ss 83 and 84 add that an action is within such a class only if it was assessed in the manner the agreement or declaration specifies. A student should therefore check for a bilateral agreement or declaration before applying Part 8.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Establish that a proposal has been referred and decided: identify the controlling provision, because the relevant impacts and the whole assessment are measured against the matter it protects.
  2. Test the Part 3 “significant impact” threshold on the evidence, using the Booth formulation as persuasive authority and remembering that it was a formulation the parties accepted.
  3. In the controlled action decision, weigh the adverse impacts: the Act says that beneficial impacts on the protected matter are not to be considered.
  4. Identify which of the six approaches was chosen, check the condition attached to it, and say who prepares the report and what comment period applies.
  5. Link the assessment to the approval decision: the report must be taken into account with the principles of ecologically sustainable development, and the approval decision under Part 9 is the Minister’s.

Self-check

  • Have I kept the controlled action decision and the choice of assessment approach apart?
  • Have I called Booth v Bosworth persuasive, and said it concerned s 12 and a formulation the parties accepted?
  • Have I checked whether a bilateral agreement or declaration takes the action out of Part 8?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.