EPBC assessment approaches and controlled actions

Is the action a controlled action?

An action is a “controlled action” if doing it without approval under Part 9 would breach Part 3 (or would, but for s 25AA, s 28AB or a determination under s 79E). The relevant Part 3 provision is called the controlling provision. A person cannot take a controlled action unless an approval is in force, or another permission under s 67A applies.

The Minister decides whether an action is controlled, and which provisions control it. This must happen within 20 business days of the referral. That clock pauses while requested information is outstanding, or if the Minister and proponent agree in writing to stop counting days.

Section 75 sets two extra rules for this decision. First, the Minister must consider comments made within the public comment period.

Second, where impacts matter, the Minister must consider all adverse impacts on whatever each Part 3 provision protects. The Minister must not consider beneficial impacts on that same matter. This is subject to limits in s 75(2A)-(2B), which apply to certain provisions and to regional forest agreement forestry operations.

What counts as a significant impact

Several Part 3 prohibitions depend on a “significant impact”, like s 12 and s 18. The Act does not define this term.

In Booth v Bosworth [2001] FCA 1453, Branson J accepted the parties’ formulation: a significant impact is “important, notable or of consequence” given its context or intensity. This was a single-judge decision based on agreement, so it is only persuasive.

In Save Our Strathbogie Forest Inc v Secretary to the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action [2024] FCAFC 134, the Full Court said the primary judge correctly stated the same principles. These included that “likely” means a real, not remote, chance. The case concerned s 18, not a controlled action decision.

The primary judge treated significance as a factual question, decided on all the evidence. A student should ask what the actual impact is, not imagine any possible harm.

“Impact” has its own statutory meaning: a direct consequence of the action, or an indirect consequence the action substantially causes, subject to further conditions where someone else’s later action intervenes.

What each approach produces

All four approaches end with a report to the Minister. They differ in who does the work along the way.

For referral information, the Secretary prepares a draft recommendation report within 30 business days. The Secretary publishes it, invites comments within 10 business days, then finalises it for the Minister.

For preliminary documentation, the proponent publishes set information and invites comments, using periods the Minister directs (at least 10 business days). If comments arrive, the proponent summarises them and the response; if none, it tells the Minister in writing. The Secretary then sends the Minister a recommendation report.

For a public environment report or environmental impact statement, the proponent drafts to guidelines, needs Ministerial approval to publish, and allows at least 20 business days for comment. It finalises the document with a summary of how comments were addressed. The Secretary again gives the Minister a recommendation report.

For an inquiry, the Minister appoints commissioners and sets terms of reference, including a reporting deadline. Hearings are public unless the commission directs otherwise.

A recommendation report only advises the Minister on approval and conditions. It does not decide either matter.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by checking that a proposal was referred and a decision made. Find the controlling provision first. This matters because the matter it protects sets the benchmark for assessing impacts.

Next, test whether the “significant impact” threshold under Part 3 is met. Use the Booth formulation as persuasive authority. Remember the parties in that case accepted this formulation.

When weighing the controlled action decision, focus only on adverse impacts. The Act says beneficial impacts on the protected matter cannot be considered.

Then identify which of the six assessment approaches applies. Check any condition attached to it. Note who prepares the report and what comment period applies.

Finally, link the assessment report to the approval decision. The report must be considered together with ecologically sustainable development principles. The approval decision itself is made by the Minister under Part 9.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.