Ecologically sustainable development in statute and in the courts
New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria
In New South Wales, ESD is defined in s 6(2) of the Protection of the Environment Administration Act 1991 (NSW). It means effectively integrating social, economic and environmental considerations in decision-making. It is achieved through four principles and programs: the precautionary principle, inter-generational equity, conservation of biological diversity and ecological integrity, and improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms, including polluter pays.
Note the wording has changed. The current text says “social, economic and environmental”; a version quoted in a 2008 case mentioned only economic and environmental considerations. Read older decisions against the present wording.
The Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) adopts that definition in s 1.4. Facilitating ESD, by integrating relevant economic, environmental and social considerations, is an object of the Act under s 1.3(i).
Importantly, the EP&A Act does not list ESD among the matters a consent authority must consider on a development application. It lists “the public interest” in s 4.15(1)(e). But for targeted assessment development, the consent authority must not consider the public interest at all: s 4.15(1C)-(1D).
Queensland uses the term “ecological sustainability”. It is a balance of protecting ecological processes and natural systems, economic development, and people’s wellbeing. That balance includes accounting for potential adverse impacts of development on climate change: s 3(3)(c)(iv).
Every entity performing a function under the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) must advance that purpose. That includes applying the precautionary principle and seeking equity between present and future generations: ss 3 and 5.
Victoria’s Planning and Environment Act 1987 states planning objectives in s 4(1)(a), (b) and (g). These include sustainable use and development of land, maintaining ecological processes and genetic diversity, and balancing present and future interests of all Victorians. Section 4(2)(da) states a planning framework objective that decisions give explicit consideration to climate change policy and obligations.
The matters Victorian and Queensland decision-makers must consider on a permit or development application are covered later in the article.
Applying this in a problem question
First, find the Act giving the power, and see how it brings in ESD (ecologically sustainable development). It may do this through an object, a purpose clause, the public interest, or by naming the principles directly.
If the Act names the principles, as s 136(2)(a) of the EPBC Act does, treat them as a mandatory consideration. Check s 391 separately, since it deals with the precautionary principle on its own.
If the Act only reaches ESD through an object or the public interest, without naming the principles, apply Walker and Warkworth by analogy. Ask whether issues relevant to the principles actually arose on the facts. Don’t assume that simply failing to mention them makes the decision invalid.
Check which version of the ESD definition applies. The New South Wales text now includes social considerations, so an older case might quote earlier wording.
Finally, keep validity separate from weight. Walker shows that, unless the statute says how much weight to give a consideration, it’s generally up to the decision-maker, not the court, to decide that weight ([34]). So a decision-maker who did consider ESD may still choose against the more environmentally protective outcome.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.