Offences against property

The core appropriation offence and the three things that aggravate it - force, entry and deception - across the common-law, Theft Act and Code models.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
nsw, vic, qld
Subjects
criminal-law-and-procedure
Topics
offences-against-property

Learning outcomes

  • Identify the core appropriation offence in a named jurisdiction and say whether its elements are in the Act or at common law.
  • Say which of force, entry or deception aggravates a given set of facts, and state what that jurisdiction requires for the aggravation.
  • Explain why an intention of permanently depriving is required in Victoria but not in Queensland, and why a deception is required in New South Wales and Victoria but not in Queensland.

The comparison framework used here organises the offences for study; it is not the structure of the Acts. Four things are worth holding together because the same facts raise them: the core appropriation offence — taking or dealing with someone else’s property dishonestly — and then force, entry and deception. Robbery really is built on the core offence: in each of the three jurisdictions it requires a stealing. The entry and deception offences are not. Burglary, breaking and entering, and fraud are offences in their own right with their own elements, and none of them requires a completed theft or larceny. So read the framework as a way of comparing provisions, not as a hierarchy in the statute. The core offence itself is also defined quite differently in each of the three systems, and in New South Wales it is not defined by statute at all. This article states the position in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland; it does not state the provisions of the other jurisdictions.

What this covers

The core appropriation offences; robbery, which is built on them; and the entry and deception offences, which have elements of their own.

The elements

The core offence is where the three systems part company most sharply.

In New South Wales it is not in the Act. Section 117 of the Crimes Act 1900 is headed “Punishment for larceny” and does exactly that — five years’ imprisonment, “except in the cases hereinafter otherwise provided for”1 — while saying nothing about what larceny is. The elements remain those of the common law offence.

Victoria states them. Under s 72(1) of the Crimes Act 1958 a person steals if he “dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it”, and theft carries ten years (s 74(1))5. Section 73 then works out each component, and does so in ways worth knowing precisely6. Dishonesty is defined negatively: s 73(2) says an appropriation is not dishonest where the accused believed he had a legal right to deprive the other, or believed the other would have consented had they known, or believed the owner could not be found by reasonable steps — the last limb excluded where the property came to him as trustee or personal representative. Appropriation is “any assumption by a person of the rights of an owner”, including a later assumption by keeping or dealing with property as owner even where it was originally come by innocently (s 73(4)). And the intention of permanently depriving is satisfied without meaning the owner to lose the thing itself, where the accused intends “to treat the thing as his own to dispose of regardless of the other’s rights”; borrowing counts only where it is “for a period and in circumstances making it equivalent to an outright taking or disposal” (s 73(12)).

Queensland defines stealing differently again. Section 391(1) of the Criminal Code 1899 reaches a person who “fraudulently takes” anything capable of being stolen or fraudulently converts it, so conversion is within the offence and not merely taking9. Section 391(2) then deems the taking or conversion fraudulent if done with any of six intents9 — and they run well past permanent deprivation. An intent to use the thing as a pledge or security is enough; so is an intent to part with it on a condition as to its return the accused may be unable to perform, or to deal with it so it cannot be returned in its former condition. For money, an intent to use it at the taker’s will is enough even though they intend to repay the amount. Stealing carries five years “if no other punishment is provided” (s 398(1))10, subject to a long list of special cases.

Force aggravates it into robbery. New South Wales s 94 carries fourteen years for robbing, assaulting with intent to rob, or stealing a chattel, money or valuable security from the person of another2 — that third limb requiring no force at all. Victoria s 75(1) requires the accused to steal and, “immediately before or at the time of doing so, and in order to do so”, use force on any person or put or seek to put a person in fear of being “then and there” subjected to force; fifteen years7. Queensland s 409(1) is wider in two ways that decide cases: the violence may be used or threatened “at or immediately before or immediately after” the stealing, and it may be directed to any person or property; in either case it must be used or threatened in order to obtain the thing stolen or to prevent or overcome resistance to its being stolen11. Robbery carries fourteen years, rising to life where the offender is or pretends to be armed with a dangerous or offensive weapon or instrument, is in company with one or more others, or wounds or uses other personal violence at, immediately before or immediately after the robbery (s 411(2))11. And s 411 does not hold the whole penalty position. Section 411(3) points to s 161Q of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992, which makes it a circumstance of aggravation that the offender was a participant in a criminal organisation and knew, or ought reasonably to have known, the offence was being committed at the direction of, in association with participants in, or for the benefit of one; s 409(2) requires a Crown Law Officer’s consent before an indictment charging it is presented, and where it is proved s 161R requires, unless life imprisonment is imposed as the base component or the offender is already serving life, a cumulative mandatory component of the lesser of seven years and the offence’s maximum, served wholly in a corrective services facility and not able to be mitigated by the ordinary route (the cooperation provisions in s 161S still apply).1112

Entry produces a separate offence, not an aggravated theft, and the jurisdictions ask different questions. None of these offences requires a completed appropriation offence, and none is confined to stealing: what each requires is set out in its own terms. New South Wales s 112(1) is satisfied in either of two ways: the accused breaks and enters a dwelling-house or other building and commits any serious indictable offence therein, or, being in such a building, commits any serious indictable offence there and breaks out — fourteen years, rising to twenty in circumstances of aggravation and twenty-five in circumstances of special aggravation3. So s 112 needs an offence actually committed, but any serious indictable offence will do. Victoria s 76(1) asks only about entry and intent: entering any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to steal anything there, or to commit an offence involving an assault to a person there or any damage to the building or property in it punishable by five years or more; ten years, and complete on entry, so nothing need be taken, assaulted or damaged7. Queensland s 419(1) also needs only the intent, but confines the offence to a dwelling13: entering or being in the dwelling of another with intent to commit an indictable offence in the dwelling, at fourteen years — rising to life if entry was by a break, or if the offence was committed in the night, or violence was used or threatened, or the offender was armed, in company, or damaged property13; and s 419(5) makes entering or being in another’s dwelling and committing an indictable offence there a separate crime carrying life.13

Fraud is its own offence, and two of the three require a deception while Queensland’s does not. New South Wales s 192E(1) requires that the accused “by any deception” dishonestly4 “(a) obtains property belonging to another, or (b) obtains any financial advantage or causes any financial disadvantage”; ten years. The second limb needs no property at all, so fraud here is not a species of larceny: willingness to pay does not make the obtaining honest (s 192E(2)), and s 192E(4) makes fraud and larceny alternative verdicts to each other4, which is a statement that they are different offences rather than one built on the other. Victoria s 81(1) likewise requires a deception, and does track the theft definition by also requiring an intention of permanently depriving8 — while its neighbour s 82(1), obtaining a financial advantage by deception, does not require property either.8 Queensland s 408C(1) requires no deception14: dishonesty plus conduct within any one of eight paragraphs — including gaining a benefit or advantage “pecuniary or otherwise”, causing a detriment, inducing someone to do an act they could lawfully abstain from, and making off without paying, which requires that the accused knew payment on the spot was required or expected for property or services lawfully supplied and intended to avoid payment — constitutes fraud, at five years, rising to fourteen where the offender was a director, officer or employee of the victim (s 408C(2)), and to twenty where the value is at least $100,000 or the offender carries on the business of committing the offence (s 408C(2A))14.

Where the boundaries are

Three traps follow from the above, and all three come from carrying one jurisdiction’s concept into another.

The first is looking for the core offence in the wrong place. In New South Wales the Crimes Act gives larceny a penalty and no elements, so an answer that cites s 117 for the test has cited the wrong thing.

The second is treating “dishonestly” as one idea. Victoria defines it negatively through three belief limbs that operate on the appropriation; Queensland’s stealing provision uses “fraudulently”, given content by the deeming list in s 391(2), while its fraud provision uses “dishonestly” without defining it; and in New South Wales larceny’s fault element comes from the common law while s 192E uses “dishonestly” in a statutory offence.

The third is assuming permanent deprivation is always required. It is an element of Victorian theft and of the Victorian deception offence, but Queensland’s deeming provision expressly reaches intents that fall short of it — most visibly the person who spends money meaning to pay it back.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Name the jurisdiction and the Act before naming an offence, and check whether that jurisdiction’s core offence is statutory or at common law.
  2. If the charge is robbery, establish the stealing first: all three robbery provisions require it. Identify the property, the dealing, the fault element on that jurisdiction’s own terms, and what the accused intended should become of the thing.
  3. For an entry or fraud offence, do not go looking for a completed theft — test the offence’s own statutory elements: for entry, whether the accused entered as a trespasser or by a break, what intent is required and whether some further offence must actually be committed; for fraud, whether that jurisdiction requires a deception, and whether the result alleged is one the provision names.
  4. Check for alternative verdicts and for aggravated forms before settling on a single charge.

Self-check

  • Have I cited the source of the elements, not just the penalty section?
  • Have I used the fault word that this jurisdiction’s provision actually uses?
  • Have I checked whether permanent deprivation is required here, rather than assuming it?
  • For an entry offence, have I said whether the offence is complete on entry or needs something done inside?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.