Company constitutions and replaceable rules

How constitutions and replaceable rules govern internal management, when they may be changed, and which statutory protections survive a special resolution.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
corporations-and-commercial-law
Topics
corporate-personality, members-rights

Learning outcomes

  • Identify the applicable internal management rules.
  • Explain adoption and alteration of a constitution.
  • Apply the statutory contract and protection against specified increases in member obligations.

Internal company management is not governed by the constitution alone. Under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the prior question is which statutory provisions apply as replaceable rules and whether a constitution displaces them. That question determines the rule governing a particular decision before a student asks whether the board or members complied. This article explains the statutory architecture, rather than the whole law of minority protection or constitutional expropriation.

Three possible sources of an internal rule

Section 134 recognises internal management by replaceable rules, by a constitution, or by a combination. Its note also points to ordinary statutory provisions and common law. A constitution is therefore neither compulsory for every ordinary company nor a complete statement of every legal obligation affecting management.1

A replaceable rule is a statutory management provision that the applicable constitution may displace or modify. Section 135 identifies the provisions by their headings and specifies the companies to which they apply. Section 141 provides a table of the rules. The table is a route to the substantive provisions, rather than a substitute for checking what the relevant rule actually requires.

Distinguish a replaceable rule from a mandatory statutory rule. Some headings identify a provision as replaceable for proprietary companies but mandatory for public companies. Section 135(1)(b) gives effect to that distinction. A public-company constitution cannot turn an ordinary mandatory statutory provision into an optional management preference merely by declaring an inconsistent internal rule.

Establish whether the replaceable rule applies

The application rules depend partly on registration history. Under s 135(1)(a), the ordinary replaceable-rule category applies to companies registered after 1 July 1998 and certain older companies that repealed their constitutions after that date. The proprietary/public category has its own historical and change-of-type conditions. Identify which limb applies instead of announcing that the table governs every company in the same way.

The section also makes an important exception for a proprietary company while the same person is both its sole director and sole shareholder. The marked section or subsection does not apply during that situation. That is not a rule about every company with one director: the identity of the sole shareholder matters too. The Act points to special provisions for those one-person companies.

Once a provision applies as a replaceable rule, s 135(2) allows the constitution to displace or modify it. Read the actual constitutional language and the substantive statutory rule together. An internal document called “board policy” is not, simply by its title, a constitutional amendment. Its legal effect needs a separate basis.

Adoption and alteration require the statutory route

Section 136(1)(a) allows adoption on registration where each proposed consenting member agrees in writing to the terms before lodgment of the application. After registration, adoption may occur by special resolution or through the specified court-order route. The required agreement before registration should not be confused with the voting mechanism available after the company exists.

Under s 136(2), a special resolution may modify or repeal the constitution or a provision of it. But subsections (3) and (4) permit further constitutional requirements for an alteration to be effective, and ordinarily require those conditions to be met before they themselves are changed. The words of the particular constitution are essential. A special resolution is not automatically sufficient whenever an entrenched requirement is present.

Section 137 identifies when an adoption, modification or repeal takes effect. For a special resolution, the default is its passing date unless it specifies a later date or a mechanism determining a later date. Court orders have a corresponding rule. Do not apply a future constitutional rule to an earlier decision without checking the operative date.

Filing and access are separate obligations

Section 136(5) requires a public company to lodge a copy of the relevant special resolution within 14 days and, on adoption or modification, the constitution or modification. It also reaches a proprietary company whose application to become public remains undetermined. This is not a statement that every proprietary-company alteration has the same filing obligation.

Under s 138, ASIC may direct lodgment of a consolidated constitution. Section 139 gives a member a route to obtain a copy: a written request and payment of any required fee up to the prescribed amount engage the seven-day obligation. A problem about a refused copy should be analysed through those conditions rather than a general assertion that company documents are public.

The filing and access provisions serve different functions from the voting and effective-date provisions. A sound answer identifies each obligation separately. Questions about penalties or the consequences of a particular filing defect should be answered from the relevant statutory text, rather than assuming that every administrative failure invalidates the amendment.

The statutory contract and protected members

Section 140(1) gives the constitution and applicable replaceable rules effect as a contract between company and members, company and each director and secretary, and members with one another. Each person agrees to observe and perform them so far as they apply to that person. The identified relationships explain why the instrument matters beyond being a private operating manual.

Under s 135(3), breach of an applicable replaceable rule is not of itself a contravention of the Act. That does not make the rule meaningless: its contractual effect under s 140 is a different legal consequence. Conversely, the statutory contract should not be expanded into a claim that any outsider mentioned in a constitution can enforce every promised benefit. That broader enforceability issue requires case-law analysis beyond the provisions explained here.

Under s 140(2), absent written agreement, a member is not bound by a modification made after membership began so far as it requires additional shares, increases liability to contribute to share capital or otherwise pay money to the company, or imposes or increases share-transfer restrictions. The transfer limb has exceptions for the specified public-to-proprietary change and proportional takeover provisions. A majority’s successful vote therefore does not answer whether an increased obligation binds a particular existing member.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the company’s type and registration history, and locate the substantive management rule.
  2. Decide whether it applies as a replaceable rule and whether the constitution modifies it.
  3. Test adoption or alteration under s 136, including any further constitutional requirement.
  4. Fix the effective date under s 137 and distinguish filing from voting requirements.
  5. Identify the s 140 relationship and any protected non-consenting member before stating the consequence.

Minority-oppression, class-rights and expropriation questions need their separate statutory and case-law controls. Compliance with this alteration machinery should not be treated as a complete answer to those different challenges.