Company constitutions and replaceable rules
Three possible sources of an internal rule
Section 134 lets companies be run by replaceable rules, by a constitution, or by both. It also points to other statutory provisions and common law. So a constitution is not compulsory, and it does not cover every legal duty on management.
A replaceable rule is a standard management rule set out in the Corporations Act. A company’s constitution can change or remove it. Section 135 lists these rules and says which companies they apply to. Section 141 gives a table of them, but you still need to check what the actual rule says.
Some rules are replaceable for proprietary companies, but mandatory for public companies. Section 135(1)(b) creates this difference. A public company’s constitution cannot make a mandatory rule merely optional.
Filing and access are separate obligations
Section 136(5) applies to public companies. It requires lodging the special resolution within 14 days, plus the constitution or modification. It also covers a proprietary company still waiting on its application to become public.
This does not mean every proprietary company change triggers the same duty.
Section 138 lets ASIC direct a company to lodge a consolidated constitution. Section 139 lets a member request a copy in writing. If the member pays any required fee, up to the prescribed amount, a seven-day deadline applies.
If a company refuses to give a copy, check these specific conditions first. Do not assume all company documents are simply public.
Filing obligations and access obligations serve different purposes. They are also separate from rules about voting and when a change takes effect. A good answer keeps these obligations distinct.
For questions on penalties or filing defects, look to the actual statutory text. Do not assume an administrative mistake automatically invalidates the amendment.
The statutory contract and protected members
Section 140(1) makes the constitution and replaceable rules a contract. It binds the company and members, the company and each director and secretary, and members with each other. Everyone agrees to follow these rules so far as they apply to them.
Section 135(3) says breaking a replaceable rule is not itself a breach of the Act. But it can still breach the contract created by s 140. These are two different consequences.
The statutory contract does not let any outsider named in the constitution enforce every benefit promised to them. Whether outsiders can enforce such promises needs further case-law analysis.
Section 140(2) protects existing members from certain changes, unless they agree in writing. A later change cannot force them to take more shares, pay more money to the company, or face new or bigger transfer restrictions. The transfer-restriction protection has exceptions for the specified public-to-proprietary conversion and for proportional takeover provisions.
Even if a majority votes for such a change, this does not decide whether it binds a particular existing member.
Applying this in a problem question
First, identify the company’s type and its registration history. Then locate the relevant management rule.
Next, decide whether that rule applies as a replaceable rule. Check whether the constitution modifies it.
Then test any adoption or alteration against s 136. Also check for any further constitutional requirement.
Work out the effective date under s 137. Remember that filing and voting requirements are different things.
Finally, consider the s 140 relationship. Check whether any non-consenting member is protected, then state the consequence.
This process does not fully resolve other problems. Minority-oppression, class-rights and expropriation questions need their own separate statutory and case-law controls.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.