Approaching a contracts problem question

How to read a contracts problem question, identify the issues it raises, choose what to leave out, and structure an answer that applies the law to the facts.

Learning level
Application
Jurisdictions
au-national, nsw
Subjects
contract
Topics
contract-formation

Learning outcomes

  • Read a problem question for what it asks rather than for the topic it sits in.
  • Identify the issues the facts raise, and leave out the ones they do not.
  • Structure an answer that states a principle and applies it to the facts.
  • Reach a conclusion that is qualified where the facts are uncertain.

A problem question gives you facts and asks what follows in law. It is not an invitation to write what you know about contract law. This guide is about the moves between reading the facts and writing the answer — reading the question, finding the issues, deciding what to leave out, and setting out the reasoning so a marker can follow it.

Assessment differs between subjects and between teaching periods: how long you have, what you may bring, how much the task is worth, and whether there is an examination at all. Read your own subject’s assessment instructions, and treat nothing here as a prediction of what you will be asked.

What the question is asking

Start with the instruction, not the topic. “Advise Anna” asks you to reach a position and support it. “Discuss” asks you to set out the competing arguments. “Critically evaluate” asks for a reasoned assessment of the law or proposition the question identifies — its strengths and weaknesses, its coherence, the competing arguments — and a supported judgment. That is a different task from applying it, and your subject’s instructions govern.

Then find who is asking and about what. A question that asks whether Anna can recover her deposit is asking about remedies and about whichever rule makes the contract enforceable or not — it is not asking for everything you know about formation.

Spotting the issues

An issue is something the facts put in doubt. Work through the facts and ask, of each one, why is this here? A date, a signature, a conversation before signing, a letter that crosses in the post: each is usually there because it bears on a rule.

The common error is the opposite of missing issues. The published guidance of the body that examines the NSW Diploma in Law reports that candidates very often raise issues the facts do not raise, and treats that as a sign of not having mastered the basic principles rather than as harmless extra work.

So the discipline is: name the issue, and say which fact raises it. An issue you cannot anchor to a fact is one you have brought with you.

Choosing what to leave out

This is the part most students do not practise, and it is assessable in its own right — an admission authority’s own objective for contract law is to select the principles applicable to a given set of facts.

Suppose the facts are: the buyer accepted the supplier’s oral quote and the contract was formed on that call; the supplier’s standard form arrived afterwards, with no prior notice of its terms and no earlier dealings between them; the form contains a clause excluding liability for late delivery. Delivery is late and the supplier relies on the clause. The question asks whether the supplier can rely on it.

That question turns on whether the clause is a term of the contract at all. On these facts it is not: the contract was complete before the form arrived, and nothing gave the buyer notice of the clause beforehand. It is tempting to also discuss how the clause should be construed — but once you have concluded it was never incorporated, its meaning cannot matter. Say so in a sentence and move on.

The order is what does the work. Construction can be set aside only after incorporation is decided against the clause, never before.

Notice what the narrower question did for you. Had it asked simply whether the supplier is liable, incorporation would not have been enough — an exclusion clause is a defence, not the source of liability, so you would also have had to establish the delivery obligation, its breach, and the consequences the question asks about. Read what the question asks before deciding what is irrelevant.

Leaving something out deliberately is not the same as missing it. One line — “the clause’s construction does not arise, because it was not incorporated” — shows the marker you considered and discarded it.

Structuring the answer

State the issue, state the principle, apply it to the facts, conclude. Deal with one issue at a time and finish it before starting the next.

Some subjects name a framework for this and some do not; where yours does, follow your subject’s. The shape matters more than the label: a marker is looking for a principle stated accurately, then the facts of this problem measured against it.

Authority belongs in the application, not in a list. You do not need a full citation in an examination — the LPAB’s guidance1 says identifying a case or an Act by short name is enough, though secondary sources must still be acknowledged. What you do need is the proposition the case supports, and the reason it applies here.

Applying the law rather than stating it

This is the move that separates answers. Stating the law is “generally, a person who is not a party to a contract cannot sue on it, subject to the recognised exceptions”. Applying it is “Anna was not a party: the promise was made to her husband alone, and the contract names her only as the person to be paid, so unless an exception applies she cannot enforce it directly.”

Notice what the second sentence does. It picks the facts that matter, puts them against the rule, and reaches a result. If a sentence in your answer does not do one of those three things, ask what it is for.

Where a case is genuinely unsettled, say so and say what turns on it. The privity cases are an example: a student who writes that the High Court has established a general right for third parties to sue has stated something no majority held, and a marker who knows the area will see it.

Reaching a conclusion

Answer the question that was asked. “Anna is unlikely to succeed against the supplier” is a conclusion; “this is a complex area” is not.

Qualify where the facts are genuinely incomplete, and say what the missing fact would decide: “if the form had been supplied before the contract was formed and the buyer had adequate notice of the clause, it might have been incorporated — and we would then have to decide whether it covers late delivery.” An appropriately qualified conclusion is not a hedge — it is a statement of what the facts support.

Checking your answer

Under time pressure, four questions:

  1. Did I answer the question asked, or the topic it came from?
  2. Is every issue I raised anchored to a fact?
  3. Does every principle I stated get applied to these facts?
  4. Did I reach a position?

The examining body’s own closing advice is that the best answers are often the shortest, because they get to the point and concentrate on what is relevant rather than on everything the student knows.

Self-check

  • Take a problem question you have already attempted. Which of your paragraphs would survive question 2 above?
  • Name one doctrine you would be tempted to discuss in a question about an exclusion clause that the facts would not raise.
  • How would you write one sentence that discards an issue without ignoring it?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.