Approaching a contracts problem question
What the question is asking
Look at the instruction word first. “Advise Anna” means reach a position and back it up.
“Discuss” is different. It means set out the competing arguments, without necessarily picking a side.
“Critically evaluate” is different again. It asks you to assess the law’s strengths and weaknesses, its coherence, and the arguments for and against, then give a supported judgment. That is not the same as simply applying the law. Follow whatever your subject’s instructions say.
Next, work out who is asking what. If a question asks whether Anna can recover her deposit, it is asking about remedies and about the rule that makes the contract enforceable. It is not asking you to write everything you know about formation.
Spotting the issues
An issue is something the facts put in doubt. Go through each fact and ask why it is there. A date, a signature, a letter — each one usually points to a legal rule.
Many students raise issues the facts do not support. Examiners for the NSW Diploma in Law say this is common, and see it as a sign of weak understanding, not just extra effort.
So always name the issue, then point to the fact that raises it. If you cannot link an issue to a fact, you have invented it.
Choosing what to leave out
Knowing what to leave out is a skill law students rarely practise. It is also something markers assess directly.
Take this example. A buyer accepts a supplier’s oral quote, forming the contract then and there. The supplier’s form arrives later, with an exclusion clause the buyer never saw beforehand. The supplier later relies on that clause after a late delivery.
The real question is whether the clause is even a term of the contract. Here it is not, because the contract was already complete when the form arrived. Since the clause was never incorporated, its meaning (its construction) does not matter. Say this in one sentence, then move on.
Order matters. You only reach construction after deciding incorporation in the clause’s favour. If incorporation fails, construction never arises.
Also read the question carefully. If it had asked whether the supplier is liable, incorporation alone would not answer that. An exclusion clause is a defence, not the source of liability. You would still need to show the delivery obligation, its breach, and the consequences asked about.
Leaving a point out deliberately differs from missing it. A single sentence — noting that construction does not arise because the clause was never incorporated — shows the marker you considered it and set it aside for a reason.
Applying the law rather than stating it
Applying the law means using facts, not just reciting rules. Stating the rule is not enough: “a person who is not a party to a contract generally cannot sue on it, subject to exceptions.”
Applying it means matching facts to that rule and reaching a result. For example, Anna was not a party, since the promise went to her husband, so she cannot enforce it unless an exception applies.
Every sentence should either state a fact, state the rule, or connect them to a conclusion. If it does none of these, cut it.
Where law is genuinely unsettled, say so, and explain what the outcome depends on. On privity, claiming the High Court created a general third-party right overstates the law, since no majority decided that.
Reaching a conclusion
Give a real answer to the question asked. “Anna is unlikely to succeed” is a conclusion. “This is complex” is not.
If some facts are missing, say so, and explain what the missing fact would decide. For example: if a form was given before the contract formed, and the buyer had proper notice of it, the clause might be incorporated (made part of the contract). You would still need to check if it covers the problem at hand.
A conclusion qualified this way is not weak or evasive. It simply states what the facts actually support.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.