Acceptable quality and the remedies for a failed consumer guarantee

Who is a consumer, how the acceptable-quality guarantee in section 54 is tested, what a contract term can and cannot do to it, and the remedies against the supplier and the manufacturer when it fails.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, nt, act
Subjects
consumer-and-competition-law
Topics
australian-consumer-law-guarantees

Learning outcomes

  • Decide whether a buyer acquired goods as a consumer under s 3 of the Australian Consumer Law, applying each alternative and the re-supply and production exclusions.
  • Apply the acceptable-quality test in s 54, including the reasonable-consumer standard, the matters in s 54(3) and the limits in s 54(4) to (7).
  • Explain what a contract term or governing-law clause can and cannot do to the guarantees under ss 64, 64A and 67.
  • Classify a failure as remediable, irremediable or major and identify the consumer’s remedies against the supplier, and the action against the manufacturer.

The guarantee of acceptable quality in s 54 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) is a central consumer guarantee when goods fail, and what a consumer can do about a failure depends on what kind of failure it was and who is being pursued. The prior questions are whether the buyer is a “consumer” and whether the failure is a “major failure”, because those two answers decide which remedies exist. This article takes goods through the consumer definition, the acceptable-quality test, the limits on contracting out, the consumer’s remedies against the supplier, and the separate action against the manufacturer. It builds on the orientation article on the guarantees. It states the Commonwealth text of Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth); the participating States and Territories apply the ACL through their own application laws, which may modify it, so a problem set in one of them should identify that law (the consumer law framework explains the scheme).6

Who is a consumer

A person acquires goods as a consumer “if, and only if” one of three conditions is met (s 3(1)): the amount paid or payable did not exceed $40,000 or a greater prescribed amount -- reg 77A of the Competition and Consumer Regulations 2010 (Cth) prescribes $100,000 for goods acquired on or after the 2020 amendment commenced, so check the regulations for the current figure; the goods were of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use or consumption; or the goods were a vehicle or trailer acquired for use principally in transporting goods on public roads.1 Because the conditions are alternatives, a business can be a consumer when it buys goods of a household kind, whatever they cost. The status is lost if the buyer acquired the goods, or held itself out as acquiring them, for re-supply (for gift cards, re-supply in trade or commerce), or for using them up or transforming them in trade or commerce in a process of production or manufacture or in repairing or treating other goods or fixtures on land (s 3(2)).

The acceptable-quality test

Where a person supplies goods to a consumer in trade or commerce, other than by auction, there is a guarantee that the goods are of acceptable quality (s 54(1)). Goods are of acceptable quality if they are as fit for all the purposes for which goods of that kind are commonly supplied, acceptable in appearance and finish, free from defects, safe and durable “as a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with the state and condition of the goods (including any hidden defects of the goods), would regard as acceptable” (s 54(2)).2 The test is applied to the matters in s 54(3): the nature and price of the goods (if relevant), statements on packaging or labels, representations by the supplier or manufacturer, and other relevant circumstances. Price can therefore affect what a reasonable consumer would regard as acceptable.

Three provisions say when goods do not fail the test:

  • Section 54(4): goods are taken to be of acceptable quality if the only reasons they are not were specifically drawn to the consumer’s attention before the consumer agreed to the supply, and s 54(5) lets a transparent written notice displayed with goods on display do this.
  • Section 54(6): goods do not fail if (a) the consumer caused them to become of unacceptable quality, or failed to take reasonable steps to prevent it, and (b) they are damaged by abnormal use. The text joins paragraphs (a) and (b) with “and”, so on its wording both are needed.
  • Section 54(7): goods do not fail if the consumer examined them before agreeing and the examination ought reasonably to have revealed that they were not of acceptable quality.

Two neighbouring guarantees follow the same structure. Goods must be reasonably fit for any disclosed purpose and for any purpose the supplier represents, unless the circumstances show the consumer did not rely, or could not reasonably rely, on the relevant skill or judgment (s 55(3)); and goods supplied by description must correspond with the description (s 56). Services carry parallel guarantees of due care and skill (s 60); fitness for a purpose or result made known, unless the circumstances show the consumer did not rely, or could not reasonably rely, on the supplier’s skill or judgment, and not for professional services of a qualified architect or engineer (s 61); and supply within a reasonable time where the time is not fixed or to be determined as agreed (s 62). Section 63 excludes some services from these guarantees, including those supplied under a contract of insurance. The remedies for services are in a separate set of provisions that this article does not cover.2

Contracting out

A contract term is void to the extent that it purports to exclude, restrict or modify the guarantees, a right conferred by them, or liability for failing to comply (s 64(1)), and s 276 says much the same of the remedies in Part 5-4, subject to an exception in s 276(3). A term is not taken to exclude, restrict or modify the application of a provision unless it does so expressly or is inconsistent with the provision (s 64(2)).2 The rule has a qualification the orientation article does not mention. Section 64A lets a term limit a supplier’s liability for a failure, other than under ss 51 to 53, to replacement, repair or their cost, for goods that are not of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, and to resupply or its cost, for services that are not of such a kind; but the term does not apply if the buyer establishes it is not fair or reasonable for the supplier to rely on it, having regard to factors including relative bargaining strength.2

Avoiding the guarantees by a governing-law clause also fails. In Valve Corporation v ACCC the Full Court of the Federal Court rejected Valve’s argument that the guarantees did not apply to its supplies of computer games to Australian consumers because the objective proper law of its subscriber agreements was that of Washington State. The Court said the guarantees apply to supplies whether or not there is a contract, that s 64 is designed to prevent contracting out, and that s 67 is one of several provisions designed to prevent attempts to avoid the guarantees and does not specify the Division’s scope.4 It is a Full Court decision, so it does not bind the High Court or State courts. The High Court has since cited the decision, with the primary judgment, among intermediate-court authorities contrary to a submission that a court must first apply choice of law rules to find the governing law before construing a forum statute, and has described s 67 as applying Part 3-2 by reference to the proper law of the contract with an anti-avoidance objective; both passages are in Karpik v Carnival plc, a case about s 23 of the ACL and not the guarantees.5

Remedies against the supplier

Section 259 can be read as a ladder, which is a way of organising its remedies rather than wording in the Act, and the rung depends on the failure.

  1. A failure that can be remedied and is not major. The consumer may require the supplier to remedy it within a reasonable time (s 259(2)(a)). The supplier chooses how: by curing a defect in title, by repair, by replacing the goods with goods of an identical type, or by refunding the price (s 261). If the supplier refuses or fails to remedy within a reasonable time, the consumer may have the failure remedied elsewhere and recover the reasonable costs, or reject the goods, subject to s 262 (s 259(2)(b)).
  2. A failure that cannot be remedied, or is major. The consumer may reject the goods, subject to s 262, or keep them and recover compensation for the reduction in their value below the price paid or payable (s 259(3)).
  3. In addition, the consumer may recover damages for loss that was reasonably foreseeable as a result of the failure (s 259(4) and (6)), unless the failure occurred only because of a cause independent of human control after the goods left the supplier’s control (s 259(5)).

A failure is major if any of the following is true (s 260(1)): a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with its nature and extent would not have acquired the goods; the goods depart in a significant respect from their description, sample or demonstration model; they are substantially unfit for a common purpose and cannot easily and within a reasonable time be made fit; they are unfit for a purpose made known to the supplier or to a person who conducted the prior negotiations and cannot easily and within a reasonable time be made fit; or they are not of acceptable quality because they are unsafe. Several failures can add up to a major failure if a reasonable consumer, fully acquainted with them taken as a whole, would not have acquired the goods (s 260(2)).3

The right to reject is lost in the situations listed in s 262(1): the rejection period has ended, the goods have been lost, destroyed or disposed of, they were damaged after delivery for reasons unrelated to their state at supply, or they are attached to or incorporated in other property and cannot be detached or isolated without damaging the goods. The rejection period is the time within which it would be reasonable to expect the failure to become apparent, having regard to the type of goods, the likely use, the reasonable length of use and the reasonable amount of use (s 262(2)). On a valid rejection the supplier must, as the consumer elects, refund the price or replace the goods with the same type of similar value if reasonably available, and cannot meet a refund obligation by letting the consumer acquire other goods from the supplier (s 263(4) and (5)).3

Action against the manufacturer

Where the s 54 guarantee applies to a supply and is not complied with, an “affected person” may sue the manufacturer for damages (s 271(1); s 271 also covers the guarantees in ss 56, 58 and 59(1)). That person is the consumer who acquired the goods, a person who acquired them from the consumer other than for re-supply, or a person who derives title through the consumer. “Manufacturer” includes a producer or assembler, a person who holds itself out to the public as the manufacturer or has its name or brand applied to goods it supplies, and an importer where, at the time of importation, the manufacturer has no place of business in Australia (s 7(1)).1 The s 54 action fails if the guarantee was not complied with only because of the act, default, omission or representation of a person other than the manufacturer or its employee or agent, a cause independent of human control after the goods left the manufacturer’s control, or the supplier charging more than the recommended or average retail price (s 271(2)). Damages cover the reduction in value below the lower of the price paid or payable and the average retail price at the time of supply, and foreseeable loss (s 272), an action for reduction in value waits until the manufacturer has refused or failed to repair or replace where the affected person required that under an express warranty (s 271(6)), and an action must start within three years after the affected person first became aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, of the non-compliance (s 273).3

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Establish whether the buyer acquired the goods as a consumer under s 3(1) and (2), checking each alternative and the re-supply and production exclusions.
  2. Check that the supply was in trade or commerce and not by auction, then test the goods against s 54(2) and (3), using the price and any representations, and weigh the s 54(4), (6) and (7) limits before concluding that the guarantee failed.
  3. Check any contract term against ss 64 and 64A, and any governing-law clause against s 67 and Valve.
  4. Decide under ss 259 and 260 whether the failure can be remedied and whether it is major, then confirm whether the right to reject survives s 262.
  5. Identify the remedy: a request to remedy within a reasonable time, rejection with refund or replacement, or compensation for reduced value, adding damages for foreseeable loss.
  6. Ask whether the manufacturer is also liable under s 271, who is an affected person, and whether three years has passed (s 273).

Self-check

  • Have I tested the consumer definition by each alternative in s 3(1) and not by price alone?
  • Have I treated the “reasonable consumer fully acquainted” test as applying the s 54(3) matters, including price?
  • Have I kept the supplier’s remedies in s 259 separate from the manufacturer’s liability in s 271?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.