Acceptable quality and the remedies for a failed consumer guarantee
Who is a consumer
Under s 3(1), you’re a consumer if you meet just one of three conditions, not all three.
The first condition is about price. You paid $40,000 or less, or a higher prescribed amount. Reg 77A of the Competition and Consumer Regulations 2010 (Cth) sets this at $100,000 for goods bought after the 2020 amendment. Check the regulations for the current figure.[^cite:acl-consumer-and-manufacturer-definitions]
The second condition looks at the goods themselves. You’re a consumer if the goods are normally bought for personal, domestic or household use, no matter the price.
The third condition covers vehicles and trailers bought mainly to transport goods on public roads.
Because these three conditions are alternatives, a business buying household-type goods can count as a consumer, regardless of cost.
Under s 3(2), you lose consumer status in certain situations. This happens if you bought the goods to re-supply them, or held yourself out as doing so (gift cards only lose status if re-supplied in trade or commerce). It also happens if you bought them to use up or transform them in trade or commerce, as part of production or manufacture, or to repair or treat other goods or fixtures on land.
Action against the manufacturer
If a s 54 guarantee is broken, an “affected person” can sue the manufacturer for damages under s 271(1). This also covers guarantees in ss 56, 58 and 59(1). An affected person is the consumer, someone who got the goods from the consumer (not to resell them), or someone who inherits title from the consumer.
“Manufacturer” is defined broadly in s 7(1). It includes the actual producer or assembler, anyone who claims to be the manufacturer or puts its name or brand on the goods, and an importer if the real manufacturer has no business in Australia when the goods were imported.
The action against the manufacturer fails in three situations, under s 271(2). These are: someone else (not the manufacturer or its staff/agents) caused the problem; an independent event happened after the goods left the manufacturer’s control; or the supplier simply charged more than the recommended or average price.
Damages under s 272 cover two things. First, the drop in value below whichever is lower: the price paid, or the average retail price at supply. Second, any foreseeable loss caused by the breach.
If the affected person asked for a repair or replacement under an express warranty, they must wait. They can only claim for reduced value once the manufacturer has refused or failed to fix it, under s 271(6).
Finally, s 273 sets a time limit. The action must start within three years of when the affected person knew, or reasonably should have known, about the problem.
Applying this in a problem question
First, check whether the buyer acquired the goods as a “consumer” under s 3(1) and (2). Work through each alternative test, and watch for the re-supply and production exclusions that can take the buyer outside this definition.
Next, confirm the supply was in trade or commerce, and not by auction. Then test the goods against s 54(2) and (3), using the price paid and any representations made about the goods. Weigh the limits in s 54(4), (6) and (7) before concluding the guarantee failed.
Check any contract term against ss 64 and 64A. Also check any clause about governing law against s 67 and Valve.
Decide under ss 259 and 260 whether the failure can be remedied, and whether it counts as “major”. Then confirm whether the right to reject the goods still survives under s 262.
Identify which remedy applies: a request to fix the problem within a reasonable time, rejection for a refund or replacement, or compensation for reduced value. Damages for foreseeable loss can also be added.
Finally, ask whether the manufacturer may also be liable under s 271. Work out who counts as an “affected person”, and whether the three-year time limit in s 273 has passed.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.