Valve Corporation v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

Federal Court of Australia (Full Court) · 2017

Consumer And Competition LawAustralian Consumer Law Guarantees

Valve Corporation v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2017] FCAFC 224

A US games platform with millions of Australian subscribers uses agreements governed by Washington State law. Does the law of the contract decide whether Australia’s consumer guarantees reach the sale?

What happened?

Valve Corporation is a company based in Washington State in the United States. It runs Steam, an online network for distributing video games, and had more than two million Australian subscriber accounts ([1]). To obtain a game a consumer installs the Steam Client, creates an account and downloads the game ([18]), and must accept the Steam Subscriber Agreement (SSA) before completing a purchase ([24]).

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) alleged that Valve contravened s 18 and s 29(1)(m) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) by statements that misrepresented the existence, exclusion or effect of the consumer guarantees, in particular the acceptable quality guarantee in s 54. One was the SSA statement, in capital letters, that all Steam fees were payable in advance and were not refundable in whole or in part ([3]-[4]). The ACCC accepted that ss 18 and 29(1)(m) could apply in the case only if s 54 applied ([78]).

Valve defended on the footing that, having regard to s 67 of the ACL, headed “Conflict of laws”, the consumer guarantees did not apply where a supply is made under a contract whose objective proper law is the law of a country other than Australia ([6]). Section 67 provides that the provisions of Division 1 of Part 3-2 apply in relation to the supply under a contract despite a term of the contract in two cases: where the proper law of a contract for the supply of goods or services to a consumer would be the law of a part of Australia but for a term providing otherwise, and where a term purports to substitute the law of another country, or of a State or Territory, for provisions of the Division ([71]).

The primary judge found that the law with the closest and most real connection to the SSAs between Valve and Australian consumers was the law of Washington State, a finding not challenged on appeal ([80], [97]). He found that the three alleged representations based on the SSA, and one of the two based on the Steam Refund Policy, had been made and were misleading ([8]). He imposed a pecuniary penalty of $3 million and made declarations and other orders ([9]). Valve appealed from the whole of the judgment and the ACCC cross-appealed on two alleged representations made in online chats ([10]).

What did the Court decide?

The Full Court of the Federal Court (Dowsett, McKerracher and Moshinsky JJ) gave joint reasons. It identified six issues, the first being whether the primary judge erred in concluding that the consumer guarantees in Division 1 of Part 3-2 of the ACL, and the associated remedies, applied to supplies of computer games by Valve to consumers in Australia ([11], [96]). The orders were that the appeal be dismissed with costs and the cross-appeal be dismissed with costs ([12], [225]). Valve’s challenge to the $3 million penalty and to the other relief did not succeed ([223]-[224]).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

The Full Court, in joint reasons, rejected Valve’s contention that the consumer guarantees in Division 1 of Part 3-2 do not apply to a supply made under a contract whose objective proper law, the law with which the contract has its closest and most real connection, is the law of a country other than Australia ([103]). Division 1 applies guarantees to the supply of goods and services and, in contrast to the earlier mechanism of implying terms into a contract, provides that certain guarantees apply to certain transactions, so the guarantee provisions are “capable of application whether or not there is a contract” ([104], [106]). Its substantive provisions are presumed to regulate only conduct in Australia, subject to contrary provision such as s 5 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ([105]).

No provision of the ACL expressly limits the Division to supplies under contracts whose proper law is Australian, so Valve’s contention depended on an implication drawn from s 67 or from the Division generally ([110]). The Court saw no sound basis for it. Subdivisions A and B are expressed in terms of supply and draw no distinction between supply under a contract and other supply, neither their text nor their consumer protection purpose suggests the limit, and given the legislative move from contractual implications to direct guarantees it would make little sense if the guarantees applied, at least as regards contracts, only where the proper law was that of Australia or a part of it ([111]).

The Court read the contract-related provisions as directed to avoidance. The evident purpose of s 64 is to ensure that parties cannot contract out of the guarantees ([107]). Section 67 appears to be another provision designed to ensure that the guarantees cannot be avoided, directed at two situations involving a contractual term: paragraph (a), a term that displaces an Australian proper law, and paragraph (b), a term that purports to substitute another country’s law, or the law of a State or Territory, for provisions of the Division ([108]-[109]).

Valve’s contention would elevate s 67 to a provision that specifies the scope of application of the Division, but its role is more limited. It is one of a number of provisions, including ss 64 and 276, designed to prevent attempts to contract out of, or otherwise avoid, the guarantees. It overlaps with s 64 but does not merely duplicate it, because it is directed to particular types of terms relating to the applicable law ([112]). The Court did not accept that the premise of s 67(a) is that the guarantees apply only where the objective proper law of a contract of supply is Australian law ([113]).

In summary, s 67 “is designed to ensure the full reach of Div 1 of Pt 3-2”, and it would be inconsistent with the statutory scheme and purpose to read it as limiting the scope of the Division so that a supply is not covered where the supply is under a contract whose objective proper law is that of another country ([114]). The Court said its reasons on this issue were “substantially the same as those of the primary judge” ([115]).

The Court also dealt with Valve’s separate submission that its supply of computer games occurred outside Australia, in Washington State, where it agreed to supply. It held that the supply of computer games by Valve to customers in Australia took place where the customer downloaded the game on his or her computer ([116]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Dowsett, McKerracher and Moshinsky JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [103]–[115] (opens in a new tab)

These paragraphs answer the first issue, raised by grounds 1 and 2 of the notice of appeal ([96]). The Court’s rejection of Valve’s reading of Division 1 and s 67, and of the implication Valve needed, is the ground on which it rejected those grounds ([115]) and on which the guarantees applied to the supplies in question, which the ACCC’s case under ss 18 and 29(1)(m) required ([78]).

Ratio · Dowsett, McKerracher and Moshinsky JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [116] (opens in a new tab)

The Court dealt with Valve’s separate submission about the place of supply in full, although it seemed to go beyond grounds 1 and 2 and it was unclear whether it had been made to the primary judge, and rejected it. The rejection is part of the reason the guarantees were held to apply. The final sentence of [116], about s 5(1), depends on the views expressed on the third issue, which the Court said it did not need to decide ([140]), and is not relied on.

Why does this case matter?

A supplier based overseas may say that Australian protections did not apply to its sales because its contracts are governed by foreign law. This Full Court decision considers how a foreign governing law bears on the consumer guarantees, so it is a decision to know when a problem has an overseas supplier relying on a governing-law clause.

Exam and application relevance

Identify the supply, the consumer and the supplier first, then the term or the choice of law that is said to take the supply outside the guarantees. Set out both limbs of s 67 and s 64 and apply them to that term, and say whose reasons you are relying on: here, the joint reasons of the three judges of the Full Court.

Valve is a decision on Division 1 of Part 3-2 of the ACL. The text of s 67 on which the Court reasoned ([71]) is the same as the text of s 67 now set out in Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), so a current problem can use the current section.

Check your understanding

1. What did Valve say s 67 had the effect of doing, and which finding about the SSAs was not challenged on appeal ([6], [80], [97])?

2. According to [108]-[109], what are the two situations to which s 67 is directed?

3. At [112], what overlap with s 64 did the Court accept, and why did it say that s 67 does not merely duplicate s 64?

4. Whose reasons are the reasons on the first issue, and what did the Court say at [115] about their relationship to the primary judge’s reasons?

5. What did the Court say, at [116], about where the supply of computer games to customers in Australia took place?