Binding settlements and compulsory mediation
When agreed settlement terms bind before a formal deed is signed, under Masters v Cameron, and when the Federal Court, a New South Wales court or the Civil Dispute Resolution Act 2011 (Cth) can require parties to attempt resolution.
Learning outcomes
- Classify agreed settlement terms as binding at once, binding but conditional on a formal document, or not binding until a formal contract is signed, using Masters v Cameron.
- Distinguish a court’s power to refer parties to mediation, and the duty to participate in good faith, from any power to compel agreement.
- State what the Civil Dispute Resolution Act 2011 (Cth) requires of applicants, respondents and lawyers in the Federal Court and the Federal Circuit and Family Court (Division 2), and what follows if the requirement is not met.
Two questions decide whether a negotiated outcome ends a dispute: whether the parties are already bound by what they agreed, and whether a court or a statute can require them to try to negotiate at all. This article takes the first from the High Court’s contract authority and the second from Commonwealth and New South Wales legislation. The Commonwealth provisions discussed here apply to the Federal Court of Australia and, for the Civil Dispute Resolution Act 2011 (Cth), also the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2), and the New South Wales provisions to the courts and proceedings listed in Schedule 1 to the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). The corresponding provisions of the other States and Territories are not covered. Without-prejudice privilege and offers of compromise are dealt with in Settlement and alternative dispute resolution.
When agreed terms bind before a formal document is signed
Parties often settle in outline, at a mediation or in correspondence, and agree that the terms will later be recorded in a deed. Whether the outline is already a binding settlement is a question about the parties’ intention, and the leading statement of how to answer it is Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 3531. That case concerned a contract for the sale of land, not the settlement of a dispute. Applying its classification to settlement terms extends the case beyond its facts rather than applying a holding about settlements: the question is the same, and it is a question of contract formation.
The Court (Dixon CJ, McTiernan and Kitto JJ) said that where parties who have been negotiating reach agreement on terms and also agree that a formal contract will be prepared, the case may belong to any of three cases (at 360). In the first, the parties have finalised all the terms and intend to be bound at once, but propose to restate the terms in a fuller or more precise form. In the second, they have agreed every term and intend no departure from it, but have made performance of one or more terms conditional on a formal document. In the third, they do not intend to make a concluded bargain at all unless and until they execute a formal contract. The first two cases produce a binding contract. In the third the agreed terms have no binding effect of their own (at 360-362).
Which of the three a case falls into depends on the intention disclosed by the language the parties used, and no special form of words is essential (at 362). The words “subject to contract”, and expressions of similar import, prima facie create an overriding condition, so that what has been agreed is the intended basis for a future contract and not a contract (at 362-363). The memorandum in Masters was expressed to be “subject to the preparation of a formal contract of sale which shall be acceptable to my solicitors”. The Court held that no binding contract had been made, and that the purchasers’ conduct after signing did not estop them from denying one (at 364, 366-367).
The practical consequence for a settlement is that the wording of the agreed terms is evidence of which kind of case it is. If the parties intend to be bound immediately, the terms should say so; if either side intends to reserve the right to walk away until a deed is signed, the terms should say that. Nothing in Masters treats the existence of a later deed as decisive either way.
Court-ordered mediation
A court may send parties to mediation whether or not they agree. Section 53A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) allows the Federal Court to refer proceedings, or part of them, to a mediator or to a suitable person for another alternative dispute resolution process; those referrals may be made with or without the parties’ consent, while a referral to an arbitrator may be made only with consent. The power is subject to the Rules of Court and does not apply to criminal proceedings2.
New South Wales has a parallel power in Part 4 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). The court may, if it considers the circumstances appropriate, refer proceedings or part of them for mediation, with or without the parties’ consent (s 26(1)). Mediation is defined as a structured negotiation process in which a neutral and independent mediator assists the parties to achieve their own resolution of the dispute (s 25). Each party to proceedings referred for mediation has a duty to participate in the mediation in good faith (s 27), and the costs of the mediation are payable as the court orders or, failing an order, in proportions the parties agree (s 28)3. Reading these together, a referral can compel a party to take part in the process but cannot compel the party to agree; that is the article’s inference from the definition in s 25, which describes the resolution as the parties’ own.
Genuine steps before filing in a federal court
The Civil Dispute Resolution Act 2011 (Cth) works earlier in the life of a dispute. Its object is to ensure that, as far as possible, people take genuine steps to resolve disputes before certain civil proceedings are instituted (s 3)4. A person takes genuine steps if the steps constitute a sincere and genuine attempt to resolve the dispute, having regard to the person’s circumstances and the nature and circumstances of the dispute (s 4(1A)). The Act gives non-exhaustive examples, including notifying the other person of the issues and offering to discuss them, providing relevant information and documents, and considering whether an alternative dispute resolution process could resolve the dispute (s 4(1), (2)).
The Act then operates through two filing requirements:
- An applicant who institutes civil proceedings in an eligible court must file a genuine steps statement when filing the application. The statement must specify the steps taken to try to resolve the issues, or the reasons why none were taken, which may relate to urgency or to the safety or security of a person or property (s 6(1), (2)). The eligible courts are the Federal Court and the Federal Circuit and Family Court (Division 2) (s 5). No statement is needed for wholly excluded proceedings, and one is needed for proceedings that are partly excluded, though it need not relate to the excluded part (s 6(3), (4)).
- A respondent who is given a copy of the applicant’s statement must file its own before the hearing date specified in the application, stating that it agrees with the applicant’s statement or specifying how and why it disagrees (s 7).
A lawyer acting for a person who must file a statement must advise the person of the requirement and assist the person to comply (s 9).
The consequences are limited. Failure to file a statement does not invalidate the application, a response or the proceedings (s 10(2)). The court may, however, take account of whether a statement was filed and whether the person took genuine steps when exercising its powers (s 11) and when exercising its discretion to award costs (s 12(1)). The court may also take account of a lawyer’s failure to comply with s 9 in that discretion, and a lawyer ordered to bear costs personally for that failure must not recover them from the client (s 12(2), (3)).
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the court and the jurisdiction first. The statutory provisions above are Commonwealth or New South Wales provisions and say nothing about the other States and Territories.
- If a settlement is said to exist, read the words the parties used. Decide, from the language disclosed, whether the agreed terms were meant to bind at once, were meant to bind but to be restated or were conditional on a formal document, or were meant to bind only once a formal contract was signed (Masters v Cameron at 360-362).
- State the conclusion for each of those readings: in the first two there is a binding contract; in the third the agreed terms have no binding effect of their own.
- If a referral to mediation is in issue, ask whether the court is the Federal Court (s 53A) or a New South Wales court to which Part 4 applies (ss 26, 27), and whether the parties consented. Consent is not needed for a referral to mediation in either (in the Federal Court, subject to its Rules of Court).
- If the dispute was to be heard in an eligible federal court, check whether a genuine steps statement was required and filed, and treat a failure as relevant to the court’s powers and to costs, not as a ground for invalidating the proceedings (ss 10(2), 11, 12).
Self-check
- Have I asked what the parties intended, from their own language, rather than assuming that a promised deed means no agreement, or that an agreement in outline always binds?
- Have I said that Masters v Cameron concerned the sale of land and that its application to a settlement is an extension of the principle?
- Have I distinguished compelling a party to take part in mediation from compelling it to settle?
- Have I named the court and jurisdiction whose statute I am applying?