Binding settlements and compulsory mediation

When agreed terms bind before a formal document is signed

Parties sometimes settle in outline, then plan to record the deal later in a deed. Whether that outline already binds them depends on the parties’ intention. The leading case on this is Masters v Cameron, though it was actually about selling land, not settling a dispute.

The Court set out three possible situations. First, the parties have agreed all terms and intend to be bound straight away, planning only to restate the deal more formally later. Second, they have agreed all terms but made performance of some conditional on signing a formal document. Third, they do not intend any binding agreement until a formal contract is signed. The first two situations create a binding contract; the third does not.

Which situation applies depends on the language the parties actually used. No particular wording is required. But phrases like “subject to contract” usually signal the third situation -- meaning there is no contract yet, just a basis for negotiating one.

In Masters itself, the agreement was “subject to” a formal contract acceptable to the party’s solicitors. The Court held this meant no binding contract existed, and the buyers were not stopped from denying one despite their later conduct.

For settlements, this means the wording used is evidence of which situation applies. Parties who want to be bound immediately should say so clearly. Parties who want to stay free until a deed is signed should say that too. Masters does not say that simply planning a later deed decides the matter either way.

Court-ordered mediation

Courts can order parties into mediation, even if they do not agree to it.

Under the Federal Court of Australia Act, s 53A, the Federal Court may refer proceedings to a mediator or other dispute resolution process, with or without consent. Referral to an arbitrator, though, needs consent. This power follows the Rules of Court and does not apply to criminal cases.

New South Wales has a similar power under the Civil Procedure Act, Part 4. Courts may refer proceedings to mediation without consent, if the circumstances are appropriate (s 26(1)). Mediation is defined as a structured negotiation helped by a neutral mediator, aimed at letting parties reach their own resolution (s 25).

Parties sent to mediation must take part in good faith (s 27). Mediation costs are paid as the court orders, or otherwise as the parties agree (s 28).

Putting these provisions together, a party can be forced to participate in mediation, but not forced to settle. This is because s 25 describes the outcome as the parties’ own resolution.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out the court and jurisdiction. The provisions discussed are Commonwealth or New South Wales provisions. They say nothing about other States and Territories.

If a settlement is claimed, look at the actual words the parties used. Work out whether they meant to be bound straight away, bound but restating terms later, bound only once a formal document was signed, or not bound until a formal contract existed (Masters v Cameron at 360-362).

The first two readings create a binding contract. The third reading means the agreed terms do not bind on their own.

If mediation referral is the issue, check whether the court is the Federal Court (s 53A) or a New South Wales court under Part 4 (ss 26, 27). Consent is not required for referral in either, though the Federal Court’s own Rules of Court may affect this.

If the matter was to be heard in an eligible federal court, check if a genuine steps statement was required and filed. A failure to file one affects the court’s powers and costs. It does not invalidate the proceedings (ss 10(2), 11, 12).

Self-check

Check what the parties actually intended, using their own words. Do not assume a promised deed means there is no agreement yet. Do not assume an outline agreement always binds the parties.

Remember that Masters v Cameron was a case about selling land. Using it to decide a settlement dispute extends the principle beyond its original facts.

Keep separate two different things: forcing a party to attend mediation, and forcing a party to actually settle. A court can require participation without requiring agreement.

Always identify which court and jurisdiction’s statute you are relying on, since the rules may differ between them.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.