Appeals and special leave: the route to the High Court

How a matter reaches the High Court: original jurisdiction, appeals under section 73 of the Constitution and the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), the special leave criteria in section 35A, the Federal Court’s appellate jurisdiction, and why Re Wakim means jurisdiction flows one way between State and federal courts.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
australian-legal-system
Topics
court-hierarchies-and-jurisdiction

Learning outcomes

  • Identify, for a decision of a federal court or a State or Territory Supreme Court, whether an appeal to the High Court lies and whether leave is needed.
  • State the matters section 35A of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) directs the High Court to consider on an application for special leave.
  • Explain why Commonwealth law lets State courts exercise federal jurisdiction but not federal courts exercise State jurisdiction, by reference to Re Wakim.

The court hierarchy is a set of routes as well as a ranking, and a case reaches a court by one of them. The prior question for a student is therefore which court the matter started in, and which Commonwealth law governs the next step, because an appeal exists only where a law gives one and several steps need leave. This article states that Commonwealth law for the High Court and the Federal Court: the Constitution, the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) and the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). It states no State’s or Territory’s own law on appeals within its courts; for those routes, start from the Supreme Court legislation of the jurisdiction concerned. The structure the routes run through is in court hierarchy and jurisdiction.

Where a matter starts: original jurisdiction

An appeal presupposes a first decision. The original jurisdiction of the High Court comes from the Constitution and from statute. Section 75 gives the High Court original jurisdiction in matters arising under a treaty, in matters affecting consuls or representatives of other countries, in matters in which the Commonwealth or a person suing or being sued on its behalf is a party, in matters between States or between residents of different States, and in matters in which mandamus, prohibition or an injunction is sought against an officer of the Commonwealth.1 Section 76 allows Parliament to add to that list, and section 30 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) does so for all matters arising under the Constitution or involving its interpretation.2

Section 38 of the Judiciary Act makes the High Court’s jurisdiction exclusive of the State courts in a short list of matters, including suits between States, subject to sections 39B and 44. The Federal Court of Australia has the original jurisdiction that laws made by the Parliament vest in it, and that jurisdiction is ordinarily exercised by a single Judge.4 Section 39B(1A) of the Judiciary Act includes in it matters arising under the Constitution or involving its interpretation and matters arising under laws made by the Parliament, other than criminal matters.2 A constitutional question can therefore begin in either court, and the starting court decides which appeal route comes next.

Appeals to the High Court: section 73 and the Judiciary Act

Section 73 of the Constitution gives the High Court jurisdiction “with such exceptions and subject to such regulations as the Parliament prescribes” to hear appeals from all judgments, decrees, orders and sentences of a Justice exercising the High Court’s original jurisdiction, of any other federal court or court exercising federal jurisdiction, and of the Supreme Court of any State. In those cases the High Court’s judgment is final and conclusive. The jurisdiction is constitutional, but the conditions of using it are statutory, so the practical rules are in the Judiciary Act. An appeal from a Justice exercising the High Court’s original jurisdiction lies to the High Court, but an appeal from an interlocutory judgment needs the High Court’s leave (section 34). For appeals from the Supreme Court of a State, whether the judgment was given in federal jurisdiction or otherwise, and from any other State court where the judgment was given in the exercise of federal jurisdiction, section 35(2) provides that no appeal may be brought, from a final or an interlocutory judgment, unless the High Court gives special leave to appeal. Section 35(5) makes that subject to any special provision in another Act preventing or permitting appeals from State Supreme Courts in particular matters. Section 35AA does the same for the Supreme Court of a Territory.3

The consequence is that, outside any special provision, there is no appeal as of right from a State or Territory Supreme Court to the High Court: a party must first persuade the High Court to hear the case.

Special leave and section 35A

Section 35A states what the High Court must look at when it decides an application for special leave. It “may have regard to any matters that it considers relevant”, so the list does not confine the Court, but it “shall have regard to” two things. The first is whether the proceedings involve a question of law that is of public importance, “whether because of its general application or otherwise”, or one on which a decision of the High Court, as the final appellate court, is required to resolve differences of opinion between different courts, or within the one court, as to the state of the law. The second is whether the interests of the administration of justice, either generally or in the particular case, require the High Court to consider the judgment.

The two limbs differ in width. The first is directed to a question of law, either of public importance or on which the High Court’s decision is needed to resolve differences of opinion. The second looks at the administration of justice and is not limited to questions of law, because it can reach the particular case as well as the general position. The section does not state that an application succeeds if the court below was wrong; it requires the Court to consider both the question-of-law matters in paragraph (a) and the administration-of-justice matter in paragraph (b), while permitting consideration of any other relevant matters. A student answering a special leave question should therefore address both matters and say how the facts bear on each, rather than arguing error alone. It also suggests reading a High Court appeal judgment with its route in mind: the Court chose to hear the case, and the point of law the reasons address is often the point it chose it for.

The Federal Court’s own appeals

The Federal Court has a parallel structure for civil matters (section 23P of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) applies the relevant Division to the Court’s appellate jurisdiction in civil matters). Under section 24(1)(a) it hears appeals from judgments of the Court constituted by a single Judge exercising original jurisdiction, and under section 25(1) that appellate jurisdiction is, subject to the section and other Acts, exercised by a Full Court. Some judgments cannot be appealed at all: section 24(1AA) excludes, among others, a decision to join or remove a party and a decision to adjourn or expedite a hearing. An appeal from an interlocutory judgment needs the leave of the Court or a Judge (section 24(1A)), except where the judgment affects the liberty of an individual or the proceedings relate to contempt of the Court or any other court (section 24(1C)).4

The route from the Federal Court to the High Court is set by section 33 of the same Act, not by the Judiciary Act provisions that deal with State and Territory courts. Except as another Act provides, no appeal lies to the High Court from a single Judge exercising the Federal Court’s original jurisdiction (section 33(2)), and no appeal lies from a judgment of a Full Court unless the High Court gives special leave (section 33(3)). The ordinary route for an appealable judgment of a single Judge exercising original jurisdiction is therefore two steps, an appeal to a Full Court and then an application for special leave, subject to any other Act providing otherwise.

Section 24(1)(c) makes the Federal Court appeal route from State courts exercising federal jurisdiction depend on provision in another Act. Under section 24(1)(c) the Federal Court hears appeals from the judgments of a State, Australian Capital Territory or Northern Territory court exercising federal jurisdiction, but only “in such cases as are provided by any other Act”, and the paragraph excludes a Full Court of the Supreme Court. Whether any Act provides for such an appeal is not established by the sources cited here. For a State Supreme Court, the sources cited here state the High Court route in section 73 of the Constitution and section 35 of the Judiciary Act; the State’s own appeal structure is for its own legislation.

One-way flow: Re Wakim

The hierarchy is not symmetrical, and the reason is in Chapter III. Section 77(iii) allows Parliament to invest any State court with federal jurisdiction, and the earlier article explains how section 39 of the Judiciary Act does so. The reverse process was in issue in Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally (1999) 198 CLR 511. A cross-vesting scheme enacted by the Commonwealth and the States provided, among other things, that the Federal Court could exercise jurisdiction conferred on it by State law, and its validity was challenged.5

The High Court, Kirby J dissenting, held the scheme invalid in that respect. Gummow and Hayne JJ, with whom Gleeson CJ and Gaudron J agreed on the validity of the cross-vesting legislation, held that the Commonwealth legislation purporting to confer State jurisdiction on federal courts, or to consent to the States doing so, is invalid. Their central step was that Chapter III, and the incidental powers attached to it, concern the judicial power of the Commonwealth, whereas the jurisdiction in question was the judicial power of the States. McHugh J and Callinan J reached the same result by their own reasons. The case stands for a limited proposition, that federal courts cannot be given State jurisdiction by this route, and it leaves section 77(iii) untouched. As a High Court decision it binds lower Australian courts, and the High Court can reconsider its own decisions.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the court in which the matter started, and whether it was a federal court, a State or Territory Supreme Court, or another State court exercising federal jurisdiction.
  2. Find the appeal provision that fits. For a single Judge of the Federal Court, start at section 24(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and use section 33 for the step to the High Court; for a State or Territory Supreme Court, start at section 73 of the Constitution and section 35 or 35AA of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth); for a step within a State’s own courts, say its own legislation governs.
  3. Check whether leave is required: leave for an interlocutory appeal (section 24(1A) of the Federal Court Act; section 34(2) of the Judiciary Act), or special leave to appeal to the High Court (sections 35(2) or 35AA(2) of the Judiciary Act; section 33(3) of the Federal Court Act).
  4. If the question is whether special leave should be granted, apply section 35A to the facts: identify the question of law, say whether it is of public importance or divides courts, and address the interests of the administration of justice.
  5. State what the decision is worth: a High Court decision binds lower Australian courts, and the High Court can reconsider its own decisions.

Self-check

  • Have I said which court the matter started in, whether an appeal lies without leave, with leave or (subject to any special provision in another Act) only with special leave, and cited the section?
  • Have I applied the section 35A matters, rather than arguing error alone?
  • Have I avoided suggesting that a federal court can be given State jurisdiction, or that a State court’s appeal route runs through the Federal Court, and said that a State’s own appeals are governed by its own legislation?

Where the authority sits

The High Court’s jurisdiction rests on sections 73 to 77 of the Constitution and, for the working rules, the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth); the Federal Court’s on the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Those provisions are stated as compiled to December 2024, together with the reasons in Re Wakim. State and Territory Supreme Court legislation, the High Court Rules and the cross-vesting Acts are not covered.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.