Appeals and special leave: the route to the High Court

Where a matter starts: original jurisdiction

Before you can appeal, there must be a first decision. This is called original jurisdiction, meaning the power to hear a matter at first instance, not on appeal.

The High Court’s original jurisdiction comes from the Constitution and from statute. Section 75 lists several categories, including matters under a treaty, matters involving consuls, matters where the Commonwealth is a party, matters between States or residents of different States, and matters seeking mandamus, prohibition or an injunction against a Commonwealth officer.

Section 76 lets Parliament add to this list. Section 30 of the Judiciary Act does so, covering matters arising under the Constitution or involving its interpretation.

Section 38 of the Judiciary Act makes some of these matters exclusive to the High Court, meaning State courts cannot hear them. This includes suits between States, but is subject to sections 39B and 44.

The Federal Court has whatever original jurisdiction Parliament gives it by statute. This jurisdiction is usually exercised by a single judge.

Section 39B(1A) of the Judiciary Act gives the Federal Court jurisdiction over constitutional matters and matters arising under Commonwealth law, except criminal matters. This means a constitutional question can start in either the High Court or the Federal Court, and the starting court shapes the appeal route that follows.

Appeals to the High Court: section 73 and the Judiciary Act

Section 73 of the Constitution lets the High Court hear appeals from federal courts, courts using federal jurisdiction, and State Supreme Courts. Parliament can set exceptions and rules, so the practical detail sits in the Judiciary Act. In these cases the High Court’s decision is final.

A Justice’s original jurisdiction decision can be appealed to the High Court, but an interlocutory judgment (a ruling made before the final decision) needs the Court’s leave under section 34.

For State Supreme Courts, and other State courts using federal jurisdiction, section 35(2) says no appeal is allowed, final or interlocutory, without special leave. Section 35(5) allows another Act to override this for particular matters. Section 35AA applies the same special leave rule to Territory Supreme Courts.

So, unless a special provision applies, there is no automatic right of appeal from a State or Territory Supreme Court. A party must first get the High Court’s special leave to be heard.

Special leave and section 35A

Section 35A lists what the High Court must consider on a special leave application. The Court may also look at any other matters it thinks relevant, so the list does not limit it.

Two things the Court must consider. First, whether the case raises a question of law that is publicly important, or one where the High Court must resolve differing judicial opinions on the state of the law. Second, whether the interests of justice, generally or in that case, require the High Court to hear it.

These two requirements differ in scope. The first concerns only questions of law. The second concerns the administration of justice, and can apply to the particular case, not just general legal questions.

Showing the court below made an error is not enough on its own. The Court must consider both requirements together, plus any other relevant matters.

A student answering a special leave problem should discuss both requirements. Explain how the facts relate to each, rather than just arguing the lower court was wrong.

This also helps when reading a High Court judgment. Since the Court chose to hear the case, its reasoning often reveals the point of law it granted leave for.

The Federal Court’s own appeals

The Federal Court has separate rules for civil appeals (section 23P applies the civil appeal rules). Under section 24(1)(a), it hears appeals from a single Judge’s original decisions. Section 25(1) says a Full Court normally exercises this appellate power, subject to exceptions.

Some decisions cannot be appealed at all. Section 24(1AA) excludes decisions to join or remove a party, and decisions to adjourn or expedite a hearing.

An interlocutory judgment (a ruling made during a case, not the final decision) usually needs leave, or permission, to appeal under section 24(1A). This does not apply if the judgment affects someone’s liberty, or involves contempt of court, under section 24(1C).

The path to the High Court comes from section 33, not the Judiciary Act rules used for State and Territory courts. Section 33(2) says no appeal goes to the High Court from a single Judge’s original decision, unless another Act allows it. Section 33(3) says no appeal from a Full Court judgment without the High Court’s special leave, meaning its permission to hear the case.

So the usual path for an appealable single-Judge decision has two steps: first appeal to a Full Court, then seek special leave to the High Court. This is subject to any other Act providing a different route.

Section 24(1)(c) lets the Federal Court hear appeals from State, ACT or Northern Territory courts exercising federal jurisdiction, but only if another Act specifically allows it. This excludes a Full Court of the Supreme Court. The passage does not say whether such an Act actually exists.

For a State Supreme Court, the High Court route comes from section 73 of the Constitution and section 35 of the Judiciary Act. The State’s own appeal process is a separate matter, set by that State’s own legislation.

One-way flow: Re Wakim

The flow of jurisdiction between courts is not symmetrical. Section 77(iii) lets Parliament give State courts federal jurisdiction. The question in Re Wakim was whether the reverse could happen: could the Federal Court exercise State jurisdiction under a Commonwealth-State cross-vesting scheme?

The High Court, Kirby J dissenting, said no. The majority reasoned that Chapter III only deals with the Commonwealth’s judicial power, not the States’. So Commonwealth law cannot give federal courts State jurisdiction, or let the States do so.

This holding is narrow. It only stops this one method of giving federal courts State jurisdiction. Section 77(iii) itself is unaffected.

As a High Court decision, Re Wakim binds lower courts. The High Court itself remains free to reconsider it later.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding where the case began. Work out if it was a federal court, a State or Territory Supreme Court, or another State court using federal jurisdiction.

Next, find the right appeal provision. A single Federal Court Judge appeals under section 24(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), then section 33 to reach the High Court. A State or Territory Supreme Court case uses section 73 of the Constitution and section 35 or 35AA of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). Appeals within a State’s own court system follow that State’s own legislation.

Then check if leave is needed. Interlocutory appeals (appeals about a non-final ruling) need leave under section 24(1A) of the Federal Court Act or section 34(2) of the Judiciary Act. An appeal to the High Court itself usually needs special leave, under sections 35(2) or 35AA(2) of the Judiciary Act, or section 33(3) of the Federal Court Act.

If the question asks whether special leave should be granted, apply section 35A. Identify the legal question, say whether it is important to the public or causes disagreement between courts, and discuss the interests of justice.

Finally, state the decision’s effect. A High Court decision binds lower Australian courts, but the High Court may later reconsider its own past decisions.

Self-check

Before submitting, check your work.

State where the matter started. Say whether an appeal needs no leave, needs leave, or (unless another Act says otherwise) needs special leave. Cite the section.

Apply the section 35A factors. Don’t just argue that the lower court made an error.

Don’t suggest a federal court can get State jurisdiction. Don’t suggest a State court’s appeal goes through the Federal Court. Remember a State’s own appeals are governed by its own legislation.

Where the authority sits

The High Court’s jurisdiction (its power to hear cases) comes from sections 73 to 77 of the Constitution. The Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) sets out the working rules for using that power.

The Federal Court’s jurisdiction comes from the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Both sets of provisions are current only to December 2024.

The reasoning in Re Wakim is included alongside these provisions. State and Territory Supreme Court legislation, the High Court Rules, and the cross-vesting Acts are not covered here.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.