Waterside Workers’ Federation of Australia v J W Alexander Ltd
Waterside Workers’ Federation of Australia v J W Alexander Ltd (1918) 25 CLR 434
A federal court’s president held office for a fixed seven years, not until removal. Were the court’s enforcement powers valid, and could the rest of its Act stand without them?
Qualified by legislation: Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act s 72, from 29 July 1977
Since 29 July 1977 (Constitution Alteration (Retirement of Judges) 1977, No 83 of 1977) s 72 also provides that the appointment of a Justice of the High Court or of a court created by the Parliament is for a term expiring on attaining the maximum age: seventy years, or a lower age that the Parliament has fixed by law for a court it creates. Removal remains possible only on an address from both Houses for proved misbehaviour or incapacity (s 72(ii)). The case was decided on the text of s 72 before that alteration, which had no age provision and which the case’s seven-year appointment was tested against; read the case with the current text of s 72.
What happened?
The Commonwealth Court of Conciliation and Arbitration made an award enforceable by its own penalties. The Court’s president had been appointed for seven years, and the question was whether that term was valid for a court exercising federal judicial power. The Court was asked to answer three questions about the whole Act: whether it was beyond the Parliament’s powers, whether the award was invalid because of the appointment, and whether the award was enforceable.
What did the Court decide?
Before you read the Proposition, decide two things. Does a term of seven years rather than life for a presiding judge matter when a court enforces its own awards? And if the enforcing powers fall, can the arbitral powers stand on their own? The seven judges did not agree on either question. Read the separate judgments to see which Justices took which view, and on which provisions.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
A court created by the Parliament may not exercise judicial power unless its presiding judge holds office on the terms that s 72 prescribes. The Court divided four to three on the enforcing provisions of the Act, with the majority holding them invalid for that reason. Six of the seven judges held the arbitral provisions valid and the award not invalid because of the appointment; four held the award not enforceable by the Court. Whether the arbitral provisions could stand without them was itself divided. The section applied was s 72 as it then read, which required tenure for life. Section 72 has since been altered, and it now fixes a term expiring at a maximum age.
Why does this case matter?
A student who reads the case as a single ruling on s 72 will miss how much the outcome depends on the separate judgments. The case shows how the Court reasons about a court’s independence through the terms of the presiding judge’s office, and how it decides whether a valid part of a statute survives when an invalid part is removed. Both points come up again when a question tests whether a federal body is a court.
Exam and application relevance
Where a question involves a federal tribunal with a fixed term for its head, work through s 72 and ask what the tribunal is authorised to do. Then ask whether the invalid part can be severed from the rest. Give the view of each judge on the point, and do not treat a single judge’s view as the Court’s. Check the current text of s 72, because the section has been changed since this case was decided.
Check your understanding
1. Why did the Justices need to decide whether the enforcing provisions could be separated from the arbitral provisions?
2. Which Justices held that the appointment of the president for seven years was valid, and which held the enforcing provisions invalid?