Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 8]
Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 8] [2017] WASC 66
A witness was the sole magistrate in her regional district. Could concern that publicity about her family and private life might prompt recusal applications or complaints justify suppressing her occupation?
What happened?
Lloyd Rayney sought orders restricting publication of identifying information about his sister, Raelene Johnston, whose evidence concerned events before she became a magistrate. She was then the sole magistrate in a regional district. The Chief Magistrate supported the application because publicity might prompt unfounded recusal applications or complaints, while two media organisations opposed suppression.
What did the Court decide?
Chaney J dismissed the application and made no suppression order.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Chaney J held that the witness’s judicial office and the possibility of unfounded recusal applications, complaints or loss of privacy did not justify restricting publication in the absence of a serious impediment to her capacity to perform her functions. Her position did not, on those facts, warrant treating her differently from other witnesses under the principle of open justice.
Why does this case matter?
Use this case to distinguish a witness’s personal interests from a claim concerning the administration of justice.
Exam and application relevance
When a suppression application invokes the administration of justice, identify the concrete disruption said to follow from publication, connect it to the order sought and test it against the evidence. Keep any separate claim about the witness’s personal interests analytically distinct.
Check your understanding
1. What risks to the witness’s work as a magistrate were relied on to support suppression?
2. Why did Chaney J regard those risks as insufficient on the evidence?
3. How did the witness’s privacy concern differ from an impediment to the administration of justice?