Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 5]

Supreme Court of Western Australia · 2014

Civil ProcedureTortsProcedureDefamation

Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 5] [2014] WASC 147

A barrister acquitted of his wife’s murder claimed lost professional income from police statements he alleged were defamatory. The State said other events could explain the loss. Was that a reason to strike out his damages plea?

What happened?

Lloyd Rayney sued the State of Western Australia for defamation. His claim arose from statements made by a police officer, Detective Senior Sergeant Lee, at media conferences in August and September 2007, after the murder of Mr Rayney’s wife, Corryn Rayney. The civil proceedings waited for the criminal proceedings against Mr Rayney: he was acquitted of wilful murder and of the alternative charge of manslaughter on 1 November 2012, and the Court of Appeal dismissed the State’s appeal on 23 September 2013.

Paragraph 11 of Mr Rayney’s statement of claim pleaded special damages: lost fees as a barrister up to judgment, lost future fees, and the lost opportunity to be appointed Senior Counsel. He particularised a past loss of $77,000 including GST and served a schedule of special damages relying on an actuarial report by Mr Dennis Barton, which estimated his lost future earnings from 8 January 2008.

In its third application to strike out parts of the statement of claim, the State asked the Court to strike out paragraph 11 under O 20 r 19 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA). It argued that the plea was inconsistent with other paragraphs, was an abuse of process, claimed a loss that did not flow naturally from the publications without pleading the causal connection, and left out five events that could have caused some of the loss: the acquittal and the State’s appeal, the time Mr Rayney spent on those hearings, his arrest and bail hearing, other proceedings to which he was a party, and his undertakings to the Legal Practice Board to restrict or not engage in legal practice.

What did the Court decide?

Edelman J, sitting alone in chambers, dismissed the State’s application, so paragraph 11 stood. His Honour gave his reasons orally at the end of the hearing on 17 April 2014, and the edited reasons were published on 2 May 2014.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Edelman J refused to strike out a defamation plaintiff’s plea of special damages for lost professional income. Unlike a pleaded imputation that leaves out material context, a plea of damages that does not raise matters which might reduce those damages, even substantially, does not present a false issue; such matters may be explored in cross-examination or raised in the defence. The onus of pleading and proving a new intervening act or a failure to mitigate lies on the defendant, while the plaintiff must still plead the material facts said to give rise to a causal connection and must prove the loss. Because the loss was specifically pleaded and particularised with an actuarial report, the State had fair warning of the case it had to meet, and whether other events caused or reduced the loss was an issue for trial on the evidence.

Why does this case matter?

Winning a pleading application is not winning the damages. Paragraph 11 survived, but the ruling did not establish that Mr Rayney lost the income he claimed or that the police statements caused it. A student who cites an interlocutory decision like this one as a finding about the merits has misread what it decided, and an examiner will notice.

Exam and application relevance

When a problem has one party attacking the other’s pleading of loss, work through three questions. What is the pleading’s defect said to be, and does it leave the other side unable to understand the case it must meet? Which party bears the onus on each disputed matter, such as causation, a new intervening act or mitigation? And who will decide the issue: Edelman J stressed that special damages in a Western Australian defamation trial are for the judicial officer rather than the jury, which is part of why an incomplete damages plea did not carry the risk that an incomplete plea of an imputation would.

Keep the decision’s standing in view: it is a single judge’s interlocutory ruling under the Western Australian rules of court, made on the pleadings before any evidence was heard.

Check your understanding

1. What material did Mr Rayney use to particularise his claim for lost future income, and how did Edelman J use it in answering the State’s complaint about fair warning?

2. Why did Edelman J treat an incomplete plea of special damages differently from an incomplete plea of a defamatory imputation?

3. Which matters did his Honour say the State would have to plead and prove, and what remained for Mr Rayney to plead and prove?