De Kauwe v Cohen [No 4]

Supreme Court of Western Australia · 2022

TortsDefamation

De Kauwe v Cohen [No 4] [2022] WASC 35

Company officers circulated allegations about a fellow director during a boardroom struggle. Did their corporate roles make those communications occasions of qualified privilege?

What happened?

Dr Brendan de Kauwe and five of the defendants were directors of eSense Lab Ltd, an Israeli life-sciences company listed on the ASX. Other defendants were its company secretary and an adviser to a company providing media and investor-relations services. During a dispute over the company’s management, letters, notices, emails and ASX announcements conveyed allegations about Dr de Kauwe. He sued in defamation and alleged that two publications also amounted to injurious falsehood.

What did the Court decide?

Le Miere J found liability for some publications and not for others. Several internal company communications were protected by common law qualified privilege, while the 5 February letter was not published on a privileged occasion and, in the alternative, its publisher was actuated by malice. The plaintiff obtained compensatory and aggravated damages for the successful defamation claims. He also established injurious falsehood against each defendant, but received no separate damages for that tort because he accepted that the same loss could not be recovered twice.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

A corporate relationship does not decide common law qualified privilege by itself. Le Miere J required close scrutiny of the particular occasion: the identity and relationship of publisher and recipient, the content and circumstances of the communication, and whether this publisher had a duty or interest to communicate it to this recipient, who had a corresponding duty or interest in receiving it.

Why does this case matter?

The dispute shows how a boardroom conflict can generate several defamation claims within one proceeding. A case analysis should distinguish the successful claims from those that failed.

Exam and application relevance

Compare two publications from the dispute and explain why their privilege outcomes differed. The decision also shows why separate publications in the same corporate conflict may produce different outcomes.

Check your understanding

1. Why did the directors’ and officers’ corporate roles not determine qualified privilege by themselves?

2. What facts should be identified before assessing whether a particular internal communication occurred on an occasion of qualified privilege?