Defamation
Defamation under the uniform Defamation Acts: the three elements, the serious harm threshold and concerns notice introduced by the 2021 reforms, the principal defences including the public interest defence, and the remedies available.
Learning outcomes
- State the three elements a plaintiff must prove and identify who bears each burden.
- Explain the serious harm threshold and the concerns notice procedure where the 2021 amendments apply, and say how to check whether they apply in the jurisdiction in issue.
- Select the appropriate defence and explain what the defendant must establish for it.
Defamation protects reputation, and in Australia it does so through legislation that is close to uniform across the states and territories. A student’s first task is therefore statutory rather than common law: identify the applicable Defamation Act, and check whether the jurisdiction has enacted the 2021 amendments, which introduced a serious harm threshold and a new public interest defence and were not adopted everywhere at the same time.
The three elements
These are the three traditional elements. Where the 2021 amendments apply, serious harm is a further element the plaintiff must establish (below).
Publication. The matter must be communicated to at least one person other than the plaintiff. Publication is broad: a republisher is generally liable for their own publication, and the administrator of a social media page may publish comments posted by others, as the High Court held in Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Voller (2021) 273 CLR 346.1
Publication has limits. In Google LLC v Defteros [2022] HCA 272, decided five Justices to two, a search engine operator that provided a search result containing a hyperlink to a newspaper article was held not to have published the article. Kiefel CJ and Gleeson J said that the operator did not approve the writing of the matter, did not contribute to its publication on the newspaper’s webpage, did not provide a forum where it could be communicated and did not encourage comment likely to contain defamatory matter; facilitating access to another’s webpage is not participating in communicating its contents ([49], [53]). Gageler J agreed with their conclusion and reasons ([59]), and Edelman and Steward JJ reached the same result in joint reasons; Keane J and Gordon J dissented. The case concerned a search result with a hyperlink, and the joint reasons recognised that search results may themselves contain defamatory matter ([23]); it affirmed the Voller principle that any voluntary act of participation in the communication of defamatory matter makes a person a publisher ([19]-[21]).
In New South Wales the position of online intermediaries is now also statutory. The Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) exempts search engine providers, and caching, conduit and storage services, from liability for defamation on the conditions in ss 10C and 10D, and gives digital intermediaries a defence in s 31A, for causes of action accruing after the digital intermediary amendments commenced on 1 July 2024.4 Whether another jurisdiction has equivalent provisions depends on its own Act. The Northern Territory’s Act has had its own digital intermediary exemptions and defence since 11 August 2025 (ss 9C, 9D and 28A, with transitional provisions in Part 7 Division 2).5
Identification. The matter must be reasonably understood to refer to the plaintiff. Naming is not required — the question is whether a reasonable reader with knowledge of the surrounding circumstances would identify them.
Defamatory meaning. The matter must tend to lower the plaintiff in the estimation of ordinary reasonable members of the community, expose them to hatred, contempt or ridicule, or cause them to be shunned or avoided. The test is objective and applied to the ordinary reasonable reader, who is taken to read the publication as a whole rather than dwelling on isolated phrases.
Serious harm, and the concerns notice
The 2021 amendments changed the shape of the action. Where they apply, a plaintiff must now establish that the publication has caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to reputation; for a corporation entitled to sue, serious financial loss. This is an element, not a defence, and the judicial officer decides it. It may be decided before or during the trial; if a party applies for it to be decided before trial, that is to happen as soon as practicable unless special circumstances justify postponing it. The reform was directed squarely at trivial claims.
Western Australia’s Act has not been amended in this way. The Defamation Act 2005 (WA) has no serious harm element; instead s 33 makes it a defence, which the defendant must prove, that the circumstances of publication were such that the plaintiff was unlikely to sustain any harm.3
The Northern Territory adopted the amendments in 2025. The Defamation Legislation Amendment Act 2025 (NT), which commenced on 11 August 2025, inserted the serious harm element (s 9A), the concerns notice requirement (s 11B) and the public interest defence (s 26A) into the Defamation Act 2006 (NT), and repealed its triviality defence. Those amendments apply only to publications after they commenced (s 47), so for a Northern Territory publication before 11 August 2025 the date of publication decides which version of the Act you apply.5
Where the 2021 amendments apply, a plaintiff must also give the publisher a concerns notice and allow the offer-to-make-amends period to run before commencing proceedings. Failure to do so is not a technicality; proceedings commenced without it are liable to be stayed. The court may give leave to commence before the offer period has run, but that does not excuse the concerns notice itself. In Western Australia a concerns notice under s 14 governs only the timing of an offer to make amends, which cannot be made once 28 days have elapsed since the notice was given or once a defence has been served (s 14(1), subject to s 14(3)-(5) and s 16(5)); the Act does not make a notice a precondition to commencing proceedings.3
The principal defences
Justification is substantive truth: the defendant proves the imputations carried were substantially true. Contextual truth allows a defendant to rely on other, substantially true imputations of such weight that the untrue imputations cause no further harm to reputation.
Honest opinion protects an expression of opinion, rather than fact, on a matter of public interest, based on proper material that is substantially true or itself privileged.
Absolute privilege protects parliamentary and judicial proceedings entirely. Qualified privilege at common law protects publication on an occasion where the recipient has a corresponding interest in receiving it. The statutory defence of qualified privilege is different in its terms: the recipient must have an interest or apparent interest in information on the subject, the matter must be published in the course of giving that information, and the defendant’s conduct in publishing it must have been reasonable in the circumstances. Qualified privilege, in either form, is defeated by malice.
The public interest defence introduced in 2021 protects publication of matter concerning an issue of public interest where the defendant reasonably believed the publication was in the public interest. It is directed at responsible journalism and is assessed against a non-exhaustive list of factors.
Innocent dissemination protects subordinate distributors, and triviality — where it survives — protects publication in circumstances unlikely to cause harm.
Remedies
Damages compensate for injury to reputation, hurt feelings and vindication. Damages for non-economic loss are capped, with the cap set annually. Where the 2021 reforms apply, the maximum is to be awarded only in a most serious case, and aggravated damages, where the defendant’s conduct increased the harm and an award is warranted, are awarded separately and are not limited by the cap. In Western Australia, which has not adopted those reforms, the cap of $250,000 as adjusted may be exceeded only where the circumstances of publication warrant aggravated damages (s 35(1)-(2)), and exemplary or punitive damages cannot be awarded (s 37).3
Injunctions to restrain publication are granted sparingly before trial: courts are reluctant to restrain speech in advance where a defence may succeed. Corrections and apologies, encouraged through the offer-to-make-amends scheme, are frequently the practical outcome.
Who may sue, and who may be sued
Not every plaintiff may bring an action. A corporation may sue only if it is an excluded corporation — broadly, a not-for-profit, or a small business employing fewer than ten people and not related to another corporation. This restriction is deliberate: it prevents substantial commercial entities from using defamation to suppress criticism, leaving them to injurious falsehood or the misleading conduct provisions where those apply.
An action does not survive the death of either party, and cannot be brought on behalf of a deceased person. Reputation, in Australian law, is personal to the living.
On the defendant’s side, liability runs to author, editor and publisher alike, and the chain can be long. A subordinate distributor — a newsagent, a platform in some circumstances — may rely on innocent dissemination, but only if it neither knew nor ought reasonably to have known the matter was defamatory and that lack of knowledge was not due to its own negligence. That is why notice matters in practice: it can take the defence away. Notice goes to the defence, not to whether there was a publication at all (Defteros at [55]). Innocent dissemination is not the only protection: the statutory defences are additional to any other defence, and where the applicable Act has digital intermediary provisions, its exemptions apply whether or not the intermediary knew the matter was defamatory, while its defence turns on an accessible complaints mechanism and, after a written complaint, reasonable access prevention steps, if any were available, taken before the complaint or within 7 days after it.
Identification and multiple publications
The plaintiff must be identified by the matter, but need not be named. It is enough that reasonable readers with knowledge of extrinsic facts would understand the matter to refer to the plaintiff, and the publisher’s intention is irrelevant — accidental identification is still identification.
Where a group is defamed, an individual member can sue only if the group is small enough, or the matter specific enough, that the imputation reaches them personally.
The single publication rule now applies in most jurisdictions. Where matter is published to the public and the first publisher, or an associate of it, later publishes substantially the same matter, the limitation period for the later publication runs from the date of the first publication — for electronic matter, the day it was first uploaded or sent — rather than from each subsequent download. The rule does not apply where the manner of the later publication is materially different, for example in the prominence given to the matter or the extent of the publication. That reversed the position under which every download was a fresh publication with its own limitation period.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction and confirm whether the 2021 amendments apply there, because the serious harm threshold and public interest defence depend on it.
- Take each imputation the plaintiff pleads separately, and test defamatory meaning against the ordinary reasonable reader reading the whole publication.
- Address publication and identification briefly unless the facts make either contentious, then deal with serious harm as a live element where the applicable Act has one (the Western Australian Act does not; see s 33).
- Where the applicable Act makes a concerns notice a precondition to suing, check whether one was given and note the consequence if it was not. The Western Australian Act does not make a concerns notice a precondition to suing: in its Division 1 a concerns notice times an offer to make amends rather than conditioning the right to sue.
- Work through the defences in the order the defendant would plead them, stating for each precisely what the defendant must prove.
- Turn to remedies last, and address the cap, aggravated damages and the reluctance to grant interlocutory injunctions.
Self-check
- Have I confirmed which Defamation Act applies and whether the 2021 reforms are in force there?
- Have I asked whether the applicable Act has a serious harm element and, if it does, treated it as an element the plaintiff must prove, not as a defence? In Western Australia there is no such element, and the separate triviality defence in s 33 is for the defendant to prove.
- Have I tested whether each pleaded imputation is carried, reading the publication as a whole?
- Have I identified who bears the burden on each defence?