Green v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [No 4]
Green v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [No 4] [2021] WASC 474
Two financial-newspaper articles accused a prominent technology entrepreneur of dishonest business conduct. After the defences failed, what harm and conduct justified a $400,000 award?
What happened?
Dr Jemma Green co-founded and chaired Power Ledger Pty Ltd, a blockchain-based renewable-energy trading business. Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd published the Australian Financial Review Weekend and republished its material online; Aaron Patrick was its journalist.
The defendants published two newspaper articles and substantially similar online versions. One conveyed that Dr Green caused unethical market manipulation by using undisclosed paid promoters. The other conveyed that, through her creation, promotion and operation of Power Ledger, she defrauded the public and investors. Dr Green sought damages, including aggravated damages, and an injunction.
What did the Court decide?
Le Miere J held that the defendants had not established justification or honest opinion for the market-manipulation publication. The second publication conveyed the pleaded fraud imputation, for which no affirmative defence had been pleaded. His Honour found Dr Green entitled to aggravated damages and ordered the defendants to pay $400,000 inclusive of aggravated damages. The question whether an injunction should issue was deferred until the parties had considered the reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Le Miere J treated compensatory damages for defamation as serving consolation for personal hurt and vindication of reputation, with the amount required to bear an appropriate and rational relationship to the harm. His Honour explained that aggravated damages are an increase in compensatory damages, rather than a separate head, where improper, unjustifiable or bad-faith conduct by the defendant increases the plaintiff’s harm. Honest and vigorous maintenance of a bona fide defence does not itself aggravate damages; persistence that is improper, unjustifiable or lacking in bona fides may do so.
In applying those principles, his Honour considered the seriousness and reach of the publications, the injury to Dr Green’s professional reputation and feelings, the need for public vindication, and conduct that aggravated the injury. The reasons distinguish unsuccessful defences and ordinary contested litigation from conduct that increases the harm.
Why does this case matter?
Damages problems can become a list of amounts awarded in other cases. This decision shows why the factual assessment matters: the gravity and reach of an allegation, the part of the plaintiff’s life it attacks, the injury proved and the need for vindication each shape the award. It also helps separate hard-fought litigation from conduct that compounds the injury.
Exam and application relevance
Use the decision to organise a damages analysis around the harm actually proved and the compensatory purposes served by the award. When aggravation is alleged, identify the particular conduct, explain how it increased the injury, and distinguish it from the proper maintenance of a defence.
The $400,000 figure resulted from the circumstances Le Miere J found in this proceeding. A comparison with another award should address the gravity of the imputation, extent of publication, injury to reputation and feelings, need for vindication and aggravating conduct found in the case, rather than relying on the headline amount alone.
Check your understanding
1. What imputations did Le Miere J find that the two groups of publications conveyed?
2. What purposes of compensatory damages did his Honour identify, and how do aggravated damages fit within compensation?
3. Why is the honest and vigorous maintenance of a bona fide defence different from aggravating conduct?
4. Which features of the harm and publication informed the amount awarded to Dr Green?