Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 5]
Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 5] [2014] WASC 147
A barrister acquitted of his wife’s murder claimed lost professional income from police statements he alleged were defamatory. The State said other events could explain the loss. Was that a reason to strike out his damages plea?
What happened?
Lloyd Rayney sued Western Australia for defamation, over police statements made after his wife’s murder. The civil case waited for his criminal trial. He was acquitted, and the State’s appeal later failed.
His statement of claim, paragraph 11, claimed special damages: lost barrister fees, future fees, and lost chance of becoming Senior Counsel. He particularised past loss and relied on an actuarial report.
The State applied, for a third time, to strike out paragraph 11. It argued the plea was inconsistent, abusive, lacked pleaded causation, and ignored five other possible causes of loss.
What did the Court decide?
Edelman J, sitting alone in chambers, dismissed the State’s application, so paragraph 11 stood. His Honour gave his reasons orally at the end of the hearing on 17 April 2014, and the edited reasons were published on 2 May 2014.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Edelman J refused to strike out a plea of special damages for lost income. Such pleas needn’t address matters reducing damages—that’s for cross-examination or the defence. The plaintiff must plead causation and prove loss; defendants bear onus on mitigation or intervening acts.
Why does this case matter?
Winning a pleading application is not winning the damages. Paragraph 11 survived, but the ruling did not establish that Mr Rayney lost the income he claimed or that the police statements caused it. A student who cites an interlocutory decision like this one as a finding about the merits has misread what it decided, and an examiner will notice.
Exam and application relevance
For pleading-defect problems, ask: what’s the defect, and can the other side understand the case against it? Who bears onus on causation, intervening acts, or mitigation? Who decides—judge or jury?
Remember this is one judge’s interlocutory ruling, under WA court rules, decided on pleadings before evidence.