Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 6]

Supreme Court of Western Australia · 2015

Civil ProcedureProcedure

Rayney v The State of Western Australia [No 6] [2015] WASC 279

A defamation defendant sought to justify an imputation that police reasonably suspected the plaintiff of murder. Could the pleading rely on evidence known to police without identifying that evidence?

What happened?

Lloyd Rayney sued the State of Western Australia for defamation arising from police media conferences. The State pleaded that the publications conveyed an alternative imputation that police suspected Mr Rayney of murdering his wife, had reasonable grounds for that suspicion, and that the imputation was true. It sought to amend its particulars to rely on evidence of specified matters known to police. Mr Rayney challenged the plea and the adequacy of the proposed particulars.

What did the Court decide?

Chaney J refused to strike out the challenged defence and allowed the amendment, subject to further particulars.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

Chaney J held that a defendant may plead and seek to justify a defamatory imputation that police suspected the plaintiff of an offence and had reasonable grounds for doing so. The defendant must prove the grounds capable of objectively supporting the suspicion; where the existence of evidence is relied upon as a supporting fact, the pleading must particularise that evidence.

Why does this case matter?

The label attached to a suspicion does not tell the opposing party what case must be met. Precision about the material relied upon affects both procedural fairness and the evidence required at trial.

Exam and application relevance

Identify precisely the imputation the defendant seeks to justify. Then separate the fact that police held a suspicion from the asserted grounds and test each stage against the applicable pleading and proof rules.

Check your understanding

1. Why was proof that police held a suspicion insufficient to establish reasonable grounds for it?

2. Why did Chaney J permit reliance on the existence of evidence while requiring the evidence to be particularised?

3. What orders resolved the pleading dispute?