R v Clarke
R v Clarke [1927] HCA 47; (1927) 40 CLR 227
A man arrested for murder gave police the information that convicted the real killers, and then claimed the £1,000 reward offered for it. He had given the information. Why did the Crown not have to pay?
Qualified by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v J Hutchinson Pty Ltd [2025] HCA 10
Edelman J in ACCC v J Hutchinson Pty Ltd [2025] HCA 10 (his Honour’s own reasons, not a joint holding) said that although some of the discussion in R v Clarke can be taken to suggest that Clarke needed a subjective intention of responding to the offer, the better understanding, consistent with the objective theory of contract, is that his performance was not objectively referable to the reward but was engaged in solely for a distinct object, clearing himself of a murder charge. So the test is whether the performance is objectively a response to the offer, and the performer’s private motive is not itself the test.
What happened?
In May 1926 the Western Australian Government issued a proclamation offering a reward of £1,000 “for such information as should lead to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons who committed the murders of two police officers, Walsh and Pitman” (Isaacs ACJ). Evan Clarke was arrested with Treffene on a charge of murder, and on 10 June 1926 he gave information and later evidence in the prosecution of Coulter and Treffene, who were convicted of the murder of Walsh. Higgins J recorded that Clarke had seen the proclamation in May, that he first thought of the reward after the failure of the convicted men’s appeal, and that he then decided to claim it.
Clarke sued the Crown for the reward by petition of right under the Crown Suits Act 1898 (WA). McMillan CJ gave judgment for the Crown at trial. The Full Court of Western Australia, by a majority, reversed that judgment, and the Crown appealed to the High Court.
What did the Court decide?
The High Court allowed the Crown’s appeal, discharged the order of the Full Court and restored the judgment of McMillan CJ. Isaacs ACJ, Higgins J and Starke J each gave reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
All three Justices held that Clarke could not recover the reward, each in separate reasons. Isaacs ACJ said that “acceptance is essential to contractual obligation” even where “the same act is at once sufficient for both acceptance and performance”, so that it is “not true to say that since such an offer calls for information of a certain description, then, provided only information of that description is in fact given, the informant is entitled to the reward”; that is true only if the word “given” means “given in exchange for the offer”, and the same act done “with reference to a totally distinct object would not be such a performance”. He found that Clarke was “acting with reference to a specific criminal charge against himself” and gave his information “exclusively in order to clear himself from a false charge of murder”.
Higgins J held that there was no contract because “[t]here cannot be assent without knowledge of the offer”: Clarke had seen the proclamation, but it was not “present to his mind”, and the presumption that a person who supplied what the offer asked had acted on its faith “is rebutted by his own express admission”. Starke J said that “unless a person performs the conditions of the offer, acting upon its faith or in reliance upon it, he does not accept the offer and the offeror is not bound to him”; that a person who knows of the offer and performs its conditions establishes prima facie an acceptance, but that this “is an inference of fact and may be excluded by evidence”; and that the trial judge’s finding that Clarke did not act on the faith of the offer could not be disturbed.
Why does this case matter?
Clarke’s information was, on one Justice’s account, necessary to a conviction, and he still recovered nothing. A problem that treats a reward offer as a promise to pay whoever produces the result is the kind of answer the case is used to test.
The case also has a later history that a student who learned it before 2025 may not have met.
Exam and application relevance
Distinguish satisfying the proclamation’s conditions from establishing a contract, and explain which facts affect each issue. Say whose reasons you are relying on, since the three Justices gave separate reasons, and read the later view in Hutchinson before stating the requirement.
Check your understanding
1. What had Clarke supplied, and why was he not paid?
2. In Isaacs ACJ’s reasons, what must “given” mean if the informant is to be entitled to the reward?
3. Why did Higgins J say there was no assent, even though Clarke had seen the proclamation?
4. What did Starke J say about the inference that a person who knows of an offer and performs its conditions has accepted it?
5. How did Edelman J say in Hutchinson that some of the discussion in Clarke should be understood?