Pirie v Saunders

High Court of Australia · 1961

ContractContract Formation

Pirie v Saunders [1961] HCA 4; (1961) 104 CLR 149

A solicitor writes down a client’s instructions for a draft lease, and the other side says the notes prove a binding deal that the statute requires to be in writing. Can a set of instructions do that job?

What happened?

Wilfred Saunders sued William Pirie and Ross Cripps for breach of an alleged agreement to grant him a lease of shop premises at Sylvania Heights. The agreement was said to have been made orally in June 1954. The defendants denied any contract, and pleaded that the agreement was one for an interest in land not evidenced by a note or memorandum signed as s 54A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) required. (Court, at p 152.)

The action failed at trial. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, by majority, ordered a new trial. That order is the one under appeal to the High Court. (Court, at p 152.)

Before the Full Court and the High Court the respondent relied on one document: a note the solicitor, Mr Hargraves, made when Cripps gave instructions to prepare a draft lease. The note named the parties, described the property as part of a lot on the Princes Highway, and set out the term, rent, commencement, premium and special conditions. A draft lease was then prepared and the parties corresponded about it. (Court, at pp 153-154.)

The Full Court majority held that a jury should decide whether Cripps, who gave the instructions for himself and for Pirie and stood by while they were written down, had by that conduct authenticated the note as a memorandum of the earlier oral bargain, under what it called the authenticated signature fiction. It ordered a new trial. The Court noted that the Full Court possibly meant to limit the new trial to that question, but that its formal order was in general terms (at p 154).

The High Court declined to examine whether the oral discussions were sufficient to form a binding contract. (Court, at p 152.)

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed with costs. The order of the Full Court was set aside and the appeal to that Court was dismissed with costs. The cross-appeal was dismissed with costs. The Court gave one judgment.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

A solicitor’s note of a party’s instructions for a draft lease is not a note or memorandum of a concluded contract where nothing in the note or its contents indicates a binding agreement. The Court held that the authenticated signature reasoning could not apply to a document not recognizable as a note or memorandum of a concluded agreement. The Court accepted that a note need not have been made after the contract, because a written offer may become a sufficient memorandum when accepted by conduct, but the document before it was not that kind of case. It also held, in the alternative, that the note did not specify the property adequately and did not contain all the terms of the proposed lease.

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · The Court (Dixon CJ, Fullagar, Kitto, Taylor and Menzies JJ), a single judgment

Read judgment: pp 154–155 (opens in a new tab)

The Court held that the notes could not be a memorandum of a concluded agreement because they were nothing more than instructions for a draft lease, and neither their existence nor their contents indicated a binding contract. That is the ground on which the appeal from the Full Court majority succeeded, so it is ratio. The reasons attributed to the Court as a whole, not to any Justice separately.

Ratio · The Court (single judgment)

Read judgment: pp 155–156 (opens in a new tab)

The Court gave the property description and the missing terms as further reasons, introduced by ‘even if these objections are not properly founded’. Each is an independent ground the Court also relied on, so it is treated as an alternative ratio. A student should not present them as the main reason, and should not present the first ground as resting on them.

Why does this case matter?

A writing requirement is only as useful as the answer to a simple question: what does the writing say? Students who rely on the appearance of names on a document, or on the fact that the document was made during a negotiation, tend to lose marks on the examiner’s question, which asks what the document itself shows and when it was made.

Exam and application relevance

Use Pirie in a question about a writing requirement for a contract for land. Work through the Full Court majority’s reasoning and say what it treated as the signature, and on what basis. Then test that reasoning against the document in the question, not against the general idea of a memorandum. The case construes s 54A as it stood in 1961, so check the statute in force in the relevant jurisdiction before applying the rule to a modern question.

Check your understanding

1. What did the Full Court majority rely on to treat the solicitor’s note as a memorandum, and what was the High Court’s answer to that reasoning?

2. Why did the High Court say the note could not be a memorandum of a binding contract, even though Cripps had given the instructions in the solicitor’s presence?

3. Why did the High Court decline to decide whether the oral discussions made a binding contract?