Meehan v Jones

High Court of Australia · 1982

ContractContract Formation

Meehan v Jones (1982) 149 CLR 571

A buyer agrees to buy land subject to finance on terms he finds satisfactory. The vendor says a term that turns on the buyer’s own satisfaction is too vague to bind anyone. Is the clause void for uncertainty?

What happened?

In 1979 a purchaser agreed to buy land at Roma in Queensland, on which an oil refinery stood, for $800,000. The contract was made subject to conditions, including that the purchaser or his nominee would reach a satisfactory arrangement with a named supplier of crude oil and receive approval for finance on satisfactory terms. The vendors argued that the conditions made the contract uncertain or illusory. The trial judge, Dunn J, refused a decree of specific performance. The Full Court of Queensland, Kneipp J dissenting, upheld that refusal.

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed, and specific performance of the contract was ordered. Aickin J died before judgment, and the four judgments are separate: there are no joint reasons.

Proposition

What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added

Principle analysis

A contract for the sale of land that is conditional on the purchaser obtaining finance on satisfactory terms is not void for uncertainty, and is not illusory merely because the condition turns on the purchaser’s own satisfaction. The four judgments agreed on that point. They did not agree on the standard the purchaser must meet. Gibbs CJ implied honesty but not a duty to make reasonable efforts. Murphy J thought the discretion unlimited, with no reasonableness term to be implied. Mason J did not decide whether honesty alone or honesty and reasonableness applies. Wilson J thought the authorities favoured honesty alone, did not decide the point, and said the purchaser clearly must make reasonable efforts to secure finance.

Why does this case matter?

A buyer who can walk away from a contract because he is not satisfied looks like a buyer who has promised nothing, and a student may reach that conclusion quickly. An examiner rewards the student who asks whose satisfaction the words require, and which judgment is speaking when a limit on that satisfaction is stated.

Exam and application relevance

In a question about a subject-to-finance clause, attribute any statement of the standard the purchaser must meet to the Justice who makes it. The four judgments are separate, so do not run them together as one rule. Check which of them actually decides the point you need, and which only expresses a view.

Check your understanding

1. Which Justices held that the finance condition was valid, and what order did the Court make?

2. Which Justices said the honesty question did not need to be decided for the appeal?

3. Did Gibbs CJ imply a term that the purchaser must make reasonable efforts to obtain finance?