Hall v Busst
Hall v Busst (1960) 104 CLR 206
A vendor kept a first option to buy the land back, priced by adding the value of improvements, deducting deficiencies and allowing for depreciation. Can a court enforce a price nobody can yet work out?
What happened?
Busst sold Bedarra, an island off the Queensland coast with improvements and chattels, to Hall for £3,157 4s 0d. The sale was made under an agreement and an indenture, both dated 15 July 1949, and was completed by a transfer registered before 29 November 1957. (Dixon CJ, at pp 212-213.)
The indenture contained the provisions on which the case turns. Clause 3 stopped Hall from transferring, assigning or leasing any part of the land without Busst’s written consent. Clause 4 required one month’s notice of an intention to deal with the land and gave Busst a first option to purchase. Clause 5 fixed the option price as the original sum, plus the value of additions and improvements since the purchase, less the value of deficiencies in the chattels and a reasonable sum for depreciation of the buildings and other property. Clause 6 gave one month to exercise the option. (Dixon CJ, at p 212.)
On 29 November 1957 Hall agreed in writing to sell the land, with fixtures and chattels, for £8,500. She did not obtain Busst’s consent and did not give the clause 4 notice. (Dixon CJ, at pp 212-213; Fullagar J, at pp 219-220.)
Busst sued Hall for damages for breach of contract. On a case stated, the questions were whether the indenture required Hall to obtain consent (question a), to give notice (question b), and to give Busst the option (question c). The trial judge answered each question in the affirmative and ordered that the action proceed to trial on damages. The Full Court of Queensland dismissed Hall’s appeal. (Dixon CJ, at pp 213-214.)
What did the Court decide?
The appeal to the High Court was allowed with costs. The order of the trial judge was discharged, the appeal to the Full Court was allowed, and each of the three questions in the case stated was answered “No”. By agreement of the parties the action was dismissed with costs.
Proposition
What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis
Principle analysis
Dixon CJ, Fullagar J and Menzies J each held that the option price was too uncertain to found an enforceable option, and they gave different reasons. Dixon CJ held that the value of improvements and the depreciation sum had no external standard by which the court could fix them. Fullagar J held that the three essential elements, the parties, the subject matter and the price, must be fixed with certainty by the contract, and that a price to be fixed in an action at law is not enough. Menzies J held that cl 5 gave no means of calculating the price. Kitto J and Windeyer J dissented on this point. Dixon CJ and Fullagar J also held the restraint on alienation in cl 3 void, as a separate ground.
Ratio and obiter
Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.
Ratio · Dixon CJ (price analysis); Fullagar J (price analysis); Menzies J
Read judgment: pp 216–217 (opens in a new tab), pp 221–223 (opens in a new tab), pp 235–236 (opens in a new tab)
Each of the three Justices treated the price terms as too uncertain to found an enforceable option, and each stated his own reason. Dixon CJ and Fullagar J also rested the result on the restraint, so for them the decision has a second ground. The three reasons are not one test, and the record states each separately.
Separate reasoning · Kitto J; Windeyer J
Read judgment: pp 225–226 (opens in a new tab), pp 245–246 (opens in a new tab)
Kitto J said the valuation terms did not seem uncertain and that courts answer such questions every day. Windeyer J held the cl 5 price provisions valid and would have dismissed the appeal. Both dissented on the outcome, so their reasons are a minority view of the same clause and not part of the majority grounds.
Why does this case matter?
A student who sees a price written as a formula often assumes it is certain. The examiner asks something narrower: can a court compute the figure from the contract, or from a recognised standard, without the parties agreeing it later? A strong answer takes each element of the price separately, asks what measure each one has, and notes that the members of the Court did not give the same reasons.
Exam and application relevance
Use Hall where a clause sets a price, or an option price, by reference to values the contract does not fix, and where a restraint on alienation sits alongside it. The judgments divided on the price terms, so name each Justice’s reasons separately and do not present one test as the Court’s. Keep the price point separate from the restraint ground, which is a different argument.
Check your understanding
1. Which three Justices held the option unenforceable for uncertainty, and which two dissented?
2. Dixon CJ and Fullagar J gave a second ground for the same result. What was it, and whose reasons state it?
3. Kitto J said the valuation terms were not void for uncertainty. What reason did he give for that view?