Attachment, perfection and priority under the PPSA

The operative provisions of the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth): which interests the Act reaches and which s 8 excludes, when a security interest attaches and when it becomes enforceable against a third party, what perfection requires, how the default and purchase money priority rules rank competing interests, when a buyer or lessee takes free, and what happens to an unperfected interest on the grantor’s insolvency.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
property
Topics
personal-property-security

Learning outcomes

  • Determine whether a transaction creates a security interest the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) reaches, applying the substance test, the interests the Act deems to be security interests, and the interests it excludes.
  • Separate attachment, enforceability against a third party and perfection, and identify which of those steps a secured party has failed to complete.
  • Rank competing security interests by fixing each one’s priority time under the default rules, and apply the purchase money priority rules including the registration deadlines they impose.
  • Identify when a buyer or lessee takes personal property free of a security interest, and state what happens to an unperfected interest on the grantor’s insolvency.

The Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (“the PPSA”) decides contests over personal property: between competing secured parties, between a secured party and a buyer, and between a secured party and an insolvency practitioner. Before asking who wins, a student must ask how far along the Act’s sequence — attachment, enforceability against third parties, perfection — the secured party got, because the priority rules rank interests by perfection status and priority time rather than by order of creation. The PPSA is a single Commonwealth statute applying throughout Australia, reaching a security interest wherever the collateral or the grantor has the connection with Australia that s 6 requires.1

What the Act reaches, and what it leaves out

A security interest is an interest in personal property provided for by a transaction that, in substance, secures payment or performance of an obligation, without regard to the transaction’s form or to who holds title (s 12(1)).1 Section 12(3) goes further and deems three interests to be security interests whether or not they secure anything in substance: those of a transferee of an account or chattel paper, a consignor under a commercial consignment, and a lessor or bailor under a PPS lease — broadly, a lease or bailment of goods for more than two years by a lessor regularly engaged in that business (s 13). Two boundaries sit in front of all that: personal property is property other than land (s 10), and s 8 excludes whole classes of interest — general-law liens and charges, rights of set-off, interests in a fixture, dealings with interests in land.

Attachment, and the writing that reaches third parties

A security interest is enforceable against the grantor only if it has attached to the collateral (s 19(1)).2 It attaches when the grantor has rights in the collateral, or power to transfer rights in it to the secured party, and either value is given or the grantor does an act by which the interest arises (s 19(2)). Goods leased under a PPS lease, consigned, or sold under a conditional sale agreement give the grantor rights in them on obtaining possession (s 19(5)).

Enforceability against a third party needs attachment plus one of three things: the secured party possesses the collateral, has perfected by control, or holds a security agreement covering the collateral in accordance with s 20(2) (s 20(1)).2 That agreement must be evidenced by writing the grantor signed or adopted, describing the particular collateral or stating that the interest covers all the grantor’s present and after-acquired property. “Consumer property” and “commercial property” will not do unless the property is also described by item or class.

Perfection: registration, possession or control

An interest is perfected if it is perfected by force of the Act, or if it has attached, is enforceable against a third party, and one of the steps in s 21(2) has been taken: a registration effective with respect to the collateral, possession other than by seizure or repossession, or — for a closed list of mainly financial collateral — control.3 Attachment and that step may occur in either order (s 21(3)).

The default priority rules, and the priority time

Section 55 sets priority where the Act provides no other way of determining it.4 Between unperfected interests, priority follows the order of attachment. A perfected interest has priority over an unperfected one. Between currently perfected interests, priority follows the order in which their priority times occur — the earliest of the registration time, the time the party first perfected by possession or control, and the time the interest was perfected by force of the Act — but a time counts only if the interest, once perfected at or after it, remains continuously perfected.

So the rule is not first to perfect: because registration can precede attachment, a party who registers early and perfects later can outrank one who perfected first. Perfection by control sits outside this contest, taking priority over perfection by any other means despite any other provision of the Part (s 57).

Purchase money security interests, and their deadlines

A purchase money security interest (PMSI) is an interest taken in collateral to the extent that it secures the purchase price, or taken by someone who gives value to enable the grantor to acquire rights in it to the extent that value is so applied; it also covers a lessor or bailor under a PPS lease and a consignor under a commercial consignment (s 14(1)).5

A PMSI outranks a competing perfected non-PMSI in the same collateral only if its registration is timely and self-describing, and the day the clock runs from depends on what the collateral is. For inventory, the PMSI must be perfected by registration at the time the grantor, or another person at the request of the grantor, obtains possession — where the inventory is goods — and at the time the interest attaches, where the inventory is anything else (s 62(2)). For personal property other than inventory, it must be perfected by registration before the end of 15 business days after the day possession is so obtained, for goods, or after the day the interest attaches, for any other property (s 62(3)); a court may extend that 15-day period under s 293. In each case the registration must state that the interest is a PMSI (s 62(2)(c), (3)(c)). Missing either requirement prevents reliance on s 62; apply any other applicable priority rule, and otherwise s 55. Between competing PMSIs, the one granted to a seller, lessor or consignor has priority if perfected within those same times (s 63).

When a buyer or lessee takes free

The Act also lets some buyers take free, and its exceptions are where the obvious answer inverts. A buyer or lessee for value takes personal property free of an unperfected security interest, unless they were a party to the transaction that created it (s 43).6 A buyer takes free of a perfected interest in serial-numbered property if a register search by serial number alone immediately before the sale would not have disclosed the registration — but not if they hold it as inventory (s 44); prescribed motor vehicles have their own rule, with a longer search window (s 45).

Under s 46 a buyer or lessee takes free of an interest given by the seller or lessor where the property was sold or leased in the ordinary course of that party’s business of dealing in property of that kind. It has two exceptions: for serial-numbered property, a buyer or lessee holding it as inventory or for an inventory holder (s 46(2)(a)); and a buyer or lessee with actual knowledge that the sale breaches the security agreement (s 46(2)(b)). For that knowledge exception s 46 needs actual knowledge, where s 45 is defeated by constructive knowledge too. Section 47 protects a consumer buyer for new value of no more than $5,000, or a prescribed higher amount.

The unperfected interest on the grantor’s insolvency

Failing to perfect can cost the secured party the interest itself rather than its ranking. On the grantor’s winding up, administration, restructuring, deed of company arrangement or bankruptcy, a security interest it granted that is unperfected at the critical time vests in the grantor immediately before the event (s 267), subject to the exclusions in s 268.7

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Ask whether the Act reaches the interest: is it an interest in personal property, is it excluded by s 8, and does the transaction in substance secure an obligation or fall within s 12(3)?
  2. Work the sequence in order — attachment, third-party enforceability including the writing s 20(2) requires, then perfection — and name the step the party failed.
  3. Fix each competing party’s priority time, then check what s 55(6) actually asks: a time counts as a priority time only if, once the interest is perfected at or after that time, it remains continuously perfected. Continuity runs from perfection, which may come later than the priority time — a registration time can precede attachment. Then test any PMSI against the registration deadline for that kind of collateral and the statement s 62 requires.
  4. Where a buyer or lessee is on the facts, work ss 43 to 47 in turn, asking of each exception whether it needs actual knowledge or also constructive knowledge.
  5. Where the grantor is insolvent, apply s 267 before ranking anything.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.