Attachment, perfection and priority under the PPSA
What the Act reaches, and what it leaves out
A security interest is an interest in personal property created by a transaction. It counts if the transaction, in substance, secures payment or performance of an obligation (s 12(1)). This applies no matter what form the transaction takes, or who holds title.
Section 12(3) deems three further interests to be security interests, even if they secure nothing in substance. These are: a transferee of an account or chattel paper, a consignor under a commercial consignment, and a lessor or bailor under a PPS lease. A PPS lease is broadly a lease or bailment of goods for more than two years, by a lessor regularly in that business (s 13).
Two limits apply to all of this. First, personal property means property other than land (s 10). Second, s 8 excludes some interests entirely: general-law liens and charges, rights of set-off, interests in a fixture, and dealings with interests in land.
Attachment, and the writing that reaches third parties
A security interest only binds the grantor once it has attached to the collateral (s 19(1)). Attachment happens when the grantor has rights in the collateral, or power to pass on such rights, and either value is given or the grantor does something that creates the interest (s 19(2)).
For goods under a PPS lease, consignment, or conditional sale, the grantor gets these rights simply by taking possession (s 19(5)).
To bind a third party, attachment alone is not enough. The secured party must also either hold the collateral, have perfected it by control, or hold a written security agreement meeting s 20(2) (s 20(1)).
That agreement must be in writing, signed or adopted by the grantor. It must describe the specific collateral, or say the interest covers all the grantor’s present and future property.
Simply calling the property “consumer property” or “commercial property” is not enough. It must still be identified by item or class.
Perfection: registration, possession or control
An interest can be perfected in two ways. First, it may be perfected automatically by force of the Act. Second, it may be perfected if it has attached, is enforceable against a third party, and one of the steps in s 21(2) has happened.
Those steps are: registration that is effective for the collateral, possession (but not possession gained by seizure or repossession), or control. Control only applies to a closed list of mainly financial collateral.
Under s 21(3), attachment and the relevant step do not need a set order. Either one can happen first.
The default priority rules, and the priority time
Section 55 is the fallback rule. It applies only when the PPSA gives no other way to work out priority.
If both interests are unperfected, the one that attached first wins. A perfected interest always beats an unperfected one.
Between two perfected interests, priority goes by priority time. This is the earliest of three dates: registration, first perfection by possession or control, or perfection by force of the Act. A date only counts if the interest stayed continuously perfected from that point on.
This is not simply “first to perfect.” Registration can happen before attachment. So a party who registers early, then perfects later, can still outrank someone who perfected first.
Perfection by control is treated differently again. Under s 57, it beats perfection by any other method, regardless of other rules in the Part.
Purchase money security interests, and their deadlines
A purchase money security interest (PMSI) is a security interest that secures the purchase price of collateral, or is held by someone who gave value so the grantor could acquire the collateral. It also covers lessors or bailors under a PPS lease, and consignors under a commercial consignment (s 14(1)).
A PMSI beats a competing perfected security interest that is not a PMSI, but only if it is registered on time and the registration says it is a PMSI. The deadline depends on the type of collateral.
For inventory, registration must happen when the grantor (or someone else at the grantor’s request) gets possession, if the inventory is goods. For other inventory, it must happen when the interest attaches (s 62(2)).
For other personal property, registration must happen within 15 business days after possession is obtained (for goods) or after attachment (for other property). A court may extend this 15-day period under s 293 (s 62(3)).
In both cases, the registration must state that the interest is a PMSI (s 62(2)(c), (3)(c)). If either requirement is missed, the PMSI cannot rely on s 62. Another priority rule may apply instead, or otherwise s 55.
Where two PMSIs compete, the one held by a seller, lessor or consignor wins, as long as it is perfected within the same deadlines (s 63).
Applying this in a problem question
First check whether the Act even applies. Ask if the interest is in personal property, whether s 8 excludes it, and whether it really secures an obligation (or falls within s 12(3)).
Then work through the steps in strict order: attachment, third-party enforceability (which needs the writing s 20(2) requires), then perfection. Identify exactly which step the party missed.
For priority, fix each competing party’s priority time. Then apply s 55(6): a time only counts as a priority time if the interest stays continuously perfected once perfection happens at or after it. Continuity is measured from perfection, not the priority time itself — perfection can come later, and registration can even happen before attachment. Where a PMSI (purchase money security interest) is involved, check it against the registration deadline for that type of collateral, and against the statement s 62 requires.
If a buyer or lessee appears in the facts, go through ss 43 to 47 in turn. For each exception, ask whether it needs actual knowledge, or constructive knowledge as well.
If the grantor is insolvent, apply s 267 before ranking any of the competing interests.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.