Assignment and priorities
Legal and equitable assignment, assignments of future property, and the rules that decide competitions between inconsistent interests.
Learning outcomes
- Distinguish a statutory legal assignment from an equitable assignment and state the requirements of each.
- Explain why an assignment of future property operates only in equity and only for value.
- Resolve a priority contest between competing interests in the same property.
Two related questions: how a right is transferred, and who prevails when two people claim inconsistent interests in the same subject matter. Both are dominated by the distinction between legal and equitable interests.
Assigning a chose in action
A chose in action — a debt, a contractual right, shares, an interest under a trust — cannot be handed over. It is transferred in one of two ways.
Statutory (legal) assignment. The property legislation of each jurisdiction provides for the legal assignment of a debt or other legal chose in action where the assignment is absolute, in writing signed by the assignor, and notice is given to the debtor. The form of notice differs, so read the local provision. In New South Wales it is “express notice in writing” (Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s 12);7 in Queensland the debtor must be “given actual notice of the assignment” (Property Law Act 2023 (Qld) s 190(2)).8 Satisfy those conditions and the assignee takes the legal right and may sue in their own name. Fail any of them — the assignment is by way of charge, or notice is never given — and the assignment is not void, but it passes no legal right; whether it takes effect in equity depends on equity’s own requirements (below). For a gift, equity recognises it once the donor “has done everything which it is necessary for him to have done to effect a transfer of legal title” (Corin v Patton (1990) 169 CLR 540 at [37], Mason CJ and McHugh J).4
Equitable assignment. Apart from the statutory writing requirements (below), no particular form is required. What is required is a clear manifestation of a present intention to assign, and the subject matter must be identifiable. Notice to the debtor is not a condition of validity: an equitable assignment of a debt “is effective as between the assignor and the assignee without notice to the debtor” (Thomas v National Australia Bank Ltd [1999] QCA 525 at [2], McMurdo P).2 But giving notice matters for three practical reasons: it generally stops the debtor discharging the debt by paying the assignor, it cuts off some, but not all, of the later defences the debtor could raise against the assignee, and, where the rule in Dearle v Hall governs (below), it fixes priority against later assignees. For an account within the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth), s 80 states the position. The transferee takes subject to the terms of the contract and any equity, defence or claim arising in relation to it, including set-off, and to other claims against the transferor that accrue before payment to the transferor stops discharging the debt (s 80(1)), unless the debtor has made an enforceable agreement not to assert defences (s 80(2)). The debtor may keep paying the transferor until it receives a notice stating the transfer, stating that payment is to be made to the transferee and identifying the contract, or, after such a notice from someone other than the transferor, if requested proof of the transfer is not given within 5 business days (s 80(7)-(8)). And, unless the debtor has otherwise agreed, an honest, commercially reasonable modification of the contract that has no material adverse effect on the transferee’s rights or the transferor’s ability to perform can bind the transferee even after notice, to the extent the right to payment has not been fully earned by performance (s 80(3)-(4)).10
An equitable assignee of a legal chose generally must join the assignor in proceedings, so that the debtor is not exposed twice.
Statutory writing requirements depend on the jurisdiction and the property. In New South Wales a disposition of a subsisting equitable interest, and the creation or disposition of an interest in land, must be in writing (Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s 23C), and the requirement does not affect resulting, implied or constructive trusts, parol leases taking effect in possession at the best rent reasonably obtainable without taking a fine, for a term (with any extension) not exceeding three years, or the law of part performance (Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) ss 23C(2), 23D(2), 23E(d)).9 In Queensland a complete voluntary assignment of property takes effect in equity “whether the assignment is oral or in writing”, subject to the writing requirements for land (Property Law Act 2023 (Qld) s 192(1), (4); ss 7, 8).8
Future property
Property not yet in existence or not yet owned — royalties under a licence not yet granted, an expectancy under a will, book debts of a business yet to trade — cannot be assigned at law, because there is nothing to assign. In equity a would-be present assignment of such property is, “when made for value, construed as an agreement to assign the thing when it is acquired”, and the assignee gets an equitable interest “immediately the legal ownership of it is acquired by the assignor, assuming it to have been sufficiently described to be then identifiable” (Norman v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1963) 109 CLR 9 at 25, Windeyer J).5
The consequence is decisive: because it rests on agreement, it binds only where it was made for value. Equity will not assist a volunteer, so a gratuitous assignment of future property is ineffective, while a gratuitous assignment of existing property may be perfected by doing everything necessary to be done by the assignor.
Priorities
The competition is resolved by the character of the interests involved.
- Legal versus later equitable. The legal interest usually prevails.
- Equitable versus later legal. The bona fide purchaser of the legal estate for value without notice takes free — equity’s darling. Notice includes actual, constructive (what reasonable inquiries would have revealed) and imputed (knowledge attributed to a principal through an agent, within the limits of the agency).
- Equitable versus equitable. Where the equities are equal, the first in time prevails. The earlier interest may be postponed where, “in all the circumstances”, the earlier holder’s conduct is such that “in fairness and in justice” it should be; a causal link between that conduct and the later interest may not be enough on its own, and a failure to caveat is “just one of the circumstances” (Heid v Reliance Finance Corporation Pty Ltd (1983) 154 CLR 326 at 342, Mason and Deane JJ).6 Arming another with the indicia of title, failing to lodge a caveat where that is expected, or leaving documents with an agent are circumstances that may justify postponement, depending on their effect and the conduct of both claimants. This postponing conduct is where these problems are actually decided.
- Competing equitable assignments of a chose in action. Priority is determined, per Dearle v Hall (1828) 3 Russ 1,1 by the order in which notice is given to the trustee or debtor, provided the later assignee took for value and without notice of the earlier assignment — a rule that displaces first in time and is frequently missed. As the Queensland Court of Appeal has put it, assignees of a fund vested in trustees “take priority according to the date on which they give notice to the trustees” (Thomas v National Australia Bank Ltd at [20], Pincus JA). Check first whether the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) applies.3 Where the chose is an account — a monetary obligation arising from disposing of property, or from granting rights or providing services in the ordinary course of a business of doing so, such as a trade debt, but not, for example, a negotiable instrument or a bank account (s 10) — the transferee’s interest is a security interest even on an outright transfer (s 12(3)(a)), and an assignment that in substance secures an obligation is one whatever its form (s 12(1), (2)(j)). Priority between such interests is then decided under the Act, generally by whether each is perfected and then by priority time, such as the time of registration (s 55), not by the order of notice. Some transfers of accounts are outside the Act, including those made solely for collection or to satisfy a pre-existing debt (s 8(1)(f)), and Dearle v Hall still decides competing assignments the Act does not reach, such as outright assignments of an interest under a trust.
- A mere equity, such as a right to rescind or rectify, ranks below a full equitable interest acquired for value without notice.
Land under Torrens
For land under the Torrens system the statutory scheme governs, and general law priority rules apply only where the statute leaves room. Registration confers indefeasible title subject to the exceptions in the relevant Act, fraud principally among them; unregistered interests take effect in equity and are protected in practice by caveat. Failing to caveat may amount to postponing conduct, though it is not automatically so. The detail is jurisdiction-specific and must be taken from the local Act.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the subject matter, and whether it is existing or future property.
- Test the assignment against the statutory requirements; if it fails, ask whether it is good in equity, and whether value was given.
- Classify every competing interest as legal, equitable or a mere equity, and date each.
- Apply the rule for that combination, then ask whether notice or postponing conduct displaces it. For an assignment of a debt or other account, or one by way of security, first decide whether the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) applies, including its definition of an account and its exclusions; if it does, apply its priority rules.
- For land, start with the Torrens statute rather than the general law.
Where the authority sits
The conveyancing or property law statute of the jurisdiction for statutory assignment and writing requirements, its Torrens legislation for land, the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) for assignments of accounts and assignments by way of security, and case law for equitable assignment, future property and the priority rules.