NSW Fair Trading

A short factsheet on New South Wales’ consumer protection regulator: the Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW), its definition of ‘Secretary’ as the Commissioner for Fair Trading with a fallback to the head of the Department, and which powers that office holds.

Learning level
Orientation
Jurisdictions
nsw
Subjects
administrative-law, consumer-and-competition-law
Topics
statutory-bodies-and-regulators

Learning outcomes

  • State the Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) as the governing Act and explain how its definition of ‘Secretary’ makes the Commissioner for Fair Trading the holder of the Act’s powers, with the head of the Department as fallback.
  • Identify which office-holder exercises which power: the Secretary as defined, or the Minister.
  • Explain how s 28 applies the Australian Consumer Law as a law of New South Wales.

Act: Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW).1

Established: The Act does not create the office. It works through a definition instead: in the Act, “Secretary” means the Commissioner for Fair Trading, Department of Customer Service, or, if nobody is employed as Commissioner for Fair Trading, the Secretary of the Department (s 4).

Purpose: NSW Fair Trading is the administrative name under which the Department delivers consumer protection, applying the Australian Consumer Law as it operates in New South Wales.

Where the authority sits

The definition is the key to reading the Act. Its powers are conferred on “the Secretary”, and s 4 makes that word mean the Commissioner for Fair Trading while someone is employed in that role. Only when nobody is employed as Commissioner does the head of the Department become the statutory “Secretary”. Victoria also identifies its consumer regulator by employment, as the Director of Consumer Affairs Victoria employed under the Public Administration Act 2004 (Vic); the New South Wales device is to fold the Commissioner into another defined term.

So when a provision says “the Secretary”, read it as the Commissioner unless the role is unfilled. The powers this factsheet covers sit with two office-holders, not three:

  • the Secretary, as defined, is the regulator for the Australian Consumer Law (NSW) (s 30(1)), appoints investigators (s 18) and is the only person who may take and prosecute proceedings for an offence against the Act, directly or through a person acting with the Secretary’s authority (s 68(1));
  • the Minister or the Secretary may issue public warning statements (s 86A).

A student who reads “the Secretary” as the head of the Department, and looks for the Commissioner’s powers somewhere else, will attribute them to the wrong person.

Powers conferred under the Act

Investigators are employees whom the Secretary appoints by written order under s 18. Under s 86A the Minister or the Secretary may make or issue a public statement identifying and giving warnings or information about goods that are unsatisfactory or dangerous, services supplied in an unsatisfactory manner, and unfair business practices — including the use of terms that are or may be unfair in standard form consumer contracts — together with the persons responsible, and any other matter that adversely affects people acquiring goods or services from suppliers. Neither may do so unless satisfied that the statement is in the public interest (s 86A(3)).

The Act defines the Tribunal as the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT), which hears the matters the Act gives it. Other proceedings go to the courts the relevant provisions name: offence proceedings, for example, are dealt with summarily before the Local Court or the Supreme Court in its summary jurisdiction (s 68(2)).

How the Australian Consumer Law applies here

Section 28 applies the Australian Consumer Law text, as in force from time to time, as a law of this jurisdiction, where it may be referred to as the Australian Consumer Law (NSW) and forms part of the Act. That operation is subject to ss 29 to 31; under s 29 a later Commonwealth modification can be excluded by proclamation. Queensland, Victoria and the Northern Territory take the same rolling approach. Western Australia applies the Commonwealth text as in force on 1 June 2021, and a later Commonwealth amendment is picked up only if it has effect under s 19B and has come into operation under s 19C of its Act, after the amending law has been tabled (s 19A).

Is it a prosecuting authority?

Yes. Section 68(1) provides that proceedings for an offence against the Act may be taken and prosecuted only by the Secretary or, in the Secretary’s name, by a person acting with the Secretary’s authority — and the Secretary is, ordinarily, the Commissioner. For the Australian Consumer Law (NSW), the Secretary is the regulator (s 30(1)).

Self-check

  • Have I read “the Secretary” in a provision as the Commissioner for Fair Trading, unless nobody is employed as Commissioner (s 4)?
  • Have I checked whether the power is the Secretary’s alone or shared with the Minister, as the public warning power in s 86A is?
  • Have I contrasted the rolling application of the Australian Consumer Law in New South Wales with Western Australia’s dated text and its process for picking up later amendments?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.