Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission (IBAC) (Vic)

A short factsheet on IBAC: its establishing Act, purpose, investigative powers, and the limited power it has to bring criminal proceedings, which does not make it a general prosecuting authority.

Learning level
Orientation
Jurisdictions
vic
Subjects
administrative-law, criminal-law-and-procedure
Topics
statutory-bodies-and-regulators, integrity-and-misconduct-oversight

Learning outcomes

  • State IBAC’s establishing Act and its core function investigating corrupt conduct (with priority to serious or systemic corrupt conduct) and police misconduct connected with the Victorian public sector.
  • Explain IBAC’s investigative role and its statutory power to bring proceedings for offences arising out of its investigations, and why that does not make it a general prosecuting authority.
  • Distinguish IBAC’s corrupt-conduct jurisdiction from the Victorian Ombudsman’s general maladministration jurisdiction and from Integrity Oversight Victoria’s oversight-of-IBAC role.

Act: Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission Act 2011 (Vic).1

Established: The Act was assented to on 29 November 2011. IBAC was formally established on 1 July 2012 and became fully operational in February 2013, replacing the former Office of Police Integrity.

Purpose: IBAC identifies, exposes and investigates corrupt conduct and police personnel misconduct connected with the Victorian public sector (s 15(2)). Since 1 July 2016 it must give priority to conduct it considers may be serious or systemic corrupt conduct (s 15(1A)), but that priority does not confine it: it may still investigate any matter it considers may be corrupt conduct (s 15(1B)). Its jurisdiction covers public sector agencies and bodies, local councils, members of Parliament and their staff, the judiciary, and Victoria Police personnel (sworn and unsworn). It is an integrity body, not a general police force or prosecutor.

Powers conferred under the Act

The IBAC Act and other legislation give IBAC investigative powers not available to an ordinary agency, including compelling the production of documents and objects, entering and searching premises, seizing documents and objects, using surveillance devices, intercepting telecommunications, and holding private and public hearings at which a person can be required to give evidence. Not all of these come from the IBAC Act itself: surveillance device warrants are issued under the Surveillance Devices Act 1999 (Vic), and telecommunications interception operates under the Commonwealth Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979. These are investigative and reporting powers, exercised subject to statutory safeguards and court oversight for the more intrusive ones -- not powers to determine guilt or impose punishment.

Is it a prosecuting authority?

Not primarily, but it can bring prosecutions. IBAC is an investigative and exposure body, and its hearings and coercive powers do not determine guilt. But proceedings for an offence in relation to any matter arising out of an IBAC investigation may be brought by IBAC itself, by a sworn IBAC Officer authorised by the Commissioner, or by a police officer (s 190(1)), a power in the Act since 10 February 2013. Proceedings for an offence against the IBAC Act or its regulations may likewise be brought by IBAC, an authorised sworn IBAC Officer or an authorised police officer (s 189(1)). A student should therefore not say IBAC cannot prosecute; the accurate description is that it is not a general prosecuting authority, and that the power these two sections give it is to bring proceedings for offences arising out of its own investigations and for offences against its own Act.

How it relates to the other Victorian bodies

IBAC’s own conduct is overseen by Integrity Oversight Victoria -- the body created by a companion Act at the same time as IBAC specifically to oversee Victoria’s integrity agencies, comparable in design to WA’s Parliamentary Inspector of the CCC and NSW’s Inspector of the LECC. IBAC does not do merits review (that is VCAT’s role) and its jurisdiction is narrower than the Victorian Ombudsman’s general maladministration jurisdiction: the Ombudsman Act 1973 (Vic) draws an explicit line between the two, with matters that appear to involve corrupt conduct going to IBAC rather than the Ombudsman in the first instance.

How this compares with WA’s CCC and NSW’s ICAC

Every mainland state built its own integrity commission, but not to the same design. WA’s Corruption and Crime Commission is to be able to investigate cases of serious misconduct and has organised-crime functions under the same Act, while the Public Sector Commissioner is to be able to investigate cases of minor misconduct (Corruption, Crime and Misconduct Act 2003 (WA) ss 7B, 18, 21, 45B). NSW’s Independent Commission Against Corruption deals with “corrupt conduct” as defined in s 8 of its Act: Cunneen [2015] HCA 14 construed s 8(2), and s 8(2A) also covers conduct that impairs, or could impair, public confidence in public administration and could involve the matters it lists, such as collusive tendering. IBAC’s function reaches corrupt conduct generally, with a statutory priority on serious or systemic corrupt conduct (s 15(1A)-(1B)), and Victoria Police personnel misconduct specifically, within one Act. A student should not assume these three bodies’ jurisdictional tests, thresholds or scope are interchangeable just because all three are commonly described as anti-corruption commissions.

Self-check

  • Have I stated IBAC’s function as investigation and exposure, while recognising its limited power to bring proceedings under ss 189-190?
  • Have I distinguished IBAC’s corrupt-conduct and police-misconduct jurisdiction from the Ombudsman’s general maladministration jurisdiction?
  • Have I avoided assuming IBAC’s jurisdictional test is identical to WA’s CCC or NSW’s ICAC?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.